Package: dpkg
Version: 1.0.8
I have three test packages foo (1.0-0), foo (1.0-1) and bar (1.0-0).
Table 1: current interpretation by dpkg
Package Version Depends Depends (in words)
foo 1.0-0 bar (1.0-0) bar with version higher than 1.0-0
foo 1.0-1 bar (1.0-1) bar with version higher than 1.0-1
bar 1.0-0 -
If this bar (1.0-0) is installed no version of these foo packages can
be installed because they both require higher version of bar than
provided. In practice foo (1.0-0) can be installed, foo (1.0-1)
can't. The character is misleading and in practice it is
interpretated by dpkg as =. I would suggest to change the syntax
used in Depends/Conflict/Provides/Recommends/Suggest fields into a
more intuitive way (Table 2).
Table 2: suggested interpretation by dpkg
Package Version Depends Depends (in words)
foo 1.0-0 bar (=1.0-0) bar with version higher than or equal to 1.0-0
foo 1.0-1 bar (1.0-1) bar with version higher than or equal to 1.0-1
bar 1.0-0 - ~~~
However, changing this now will break almost every Debian
installation. A way to prevent is is to prevent building new packages
with Depends/Conflict/etc fields with or in it, and notify the
maintainer to change this to = or =. Installation rules should
remain the same until no more packages have or in it. For
consistency a = character should be allowed to indicate that the
mentioned version is requested.
Erick
Transcript example below:
# dpkg --info bar-1.0-0.deb
old debian package, version 0.939000.
size 424 bytes: control archive= 242, main archive= 169.
140 bytes, 6 lines control
Package: bar
Version: 1.0
Package_Revision: 0
Maintainer: Erick Branderhorst [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Description: bar test package
# dpkg --info foo-1.0-0.deb
old debian package, version 0.939000.
size 443 bytes: control archive= 260, main archive= 170.
162 bytes, 7 lines control
Package: foo
Version: 1.0
Package_Revision: 0
Maintainer: Erick Branderhorst [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Description: foo test package
Depends: bar (1.0-0)
# dpkg --info foo-1.0-1.deb
old debian package, version 0.939000.
size 443 bytes: control archive= 261, main archive= 169.
162 bytes, 7 lines control
Package: foo
Version: 1.0
Package_Revision: 1
Maintainer: Erick Branderhorst [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Description: foo test package
Depends: bar (1.0-1)
# dpkg -i bar-1.0-0.deb
Selecting previously deselected package bar.
(Reading database ... 22075 files and directories currently installed.)
Unpacking bar (from bar-1.0-0.deb) ...
Setting up bar ...
# dpkg -i foo-1.0-0.deb
Selecting previously deselected package foo.
(Reading database ... 22076 files and directories currently installed.)
Unpacking foo (from foo-1.0-0.deb) ...
Setting up foo ...
# dpkg -i foo-1.0-1.deb
(Reading database ... 22077 files and directories currently installed.)
Preparing to replace foo (using foo-1.0-1.deb) ...
Unpacking replacement foo ...
dpkg: dependency problems prevent configuration of foo:
foo depends on bar (1.0-1); however:
Version of bar on system is 1.0-0.
dpkg: error processing foo (--install):
dependency problems - leaving unconfigured
Errors were encountered while processing:
foo
--
Erick [EMAIL PROTECTED] +31-10-4635142
Department of General Surgery (Intensive Care) University Hospital Rotterdam NL
