SPIN Public license

2004-10-06 Thread eddyp

Hello all,

I am planning to package an application covered by the Spin Public License.

Could you tell me if this : 
http://cm.bell-labs.com/cm/cs/what/spin/SPIN_public_license.txt


is a free or non-free license?


Please CC me as I am not on the list.

--

Regards,
EddyP



Re: SPIN Public license

2004-10-06 Thread Josh Triplett
eddyp wrote:
 I am planning to package an application covered by the Spin Public License.
 
 Could you tell me if this :
 http://cm.bell-labs.com/cm/cs/what/spin/SPIN_public_license.txt
 
 is a free or non-free license?

In general, when requesting that debian-legal review a license, it is
preferable to include the text of the license in your mail, so that
others may easily quote and review in followups.

The text of the license at that address follows:
 LUCENT TECHNOLOGIES INC.
 SPIN SOFTWARE PUBLIC LICENSE AGREEMENT
 
 PLEASE READ THIS AGREEMENT CAREFULLY BEFORE PROCEEDING.
 BY CLICKING ON THE ACCEPT BUTTON BELOW, OR BY DOWNLOADING,
 INSTALLING, USING, COPYING, MODIFYING OR DISTRIBUTING THE
 SOFTWARE OR DERIVATIVE WORKS THEREOF, YOU ARE CONSENTING TO
 BE BOUND BY THIS AGREEMENT.
 IF YOU DO NOT AGREE TO ALL OF THE TERMS OF THIS AGREEMENT,
 CLICK ON THE DO NOT ACCEPT BUTTON BELOW AND THE
 INSTALLATION/DOWNLOAD PROCESS WILL NOT CONTINUE.
 
 1. DEFINITIONS
 1.1
 Agreement means this Lucent Technologies Inc. SPIN Software Public License 
 Agreement.
 
 1.2
 Contributor(s) means any individual or entity that creates or contributes 
 to a
 Modification of the Original Software.
 
 1.3 
 Licensee means an individual or a legal entity entering into and exercising 
 rights
 under this Agreement or future versions thereof.
 For the purposes hereunder, Licensee includes any entity that controls, is 
 controlled by,
 or is under common control with Licensee.  For purposes of this definition, 
 control
 means (i) the power, direct or indirect, to cause the direction or management 
 of such
 entity, whether by contract or otherwise;
 or (ii) ownership of fifty percent (50%) or more of the controlling shares or 
 beneficial
 ownership of such entity.  Licensee is also referred to herein as You.
 
 1.4
 Licensed Software means the Original Software, Modifications, or any 
 combination
 of the Original Software and Modifications.
 
 1.5
 LUCENT means Lucent Technologies Inc., a Delaware corporation having an 
 office
 at 600 Mountain Ave., Murray Hill, NJ 07974, its related companies and/or 
 affiliates.
 
 1.6
 SPIN Software means the source code for the logic model checking system 
 named SPIN,
 developed, copyrighted, and distributed by LUCENT.
 
 1.7
 Modification(s) means any addition, deletion, change, or improvement to the 
 Original
 Software or prior Modifications thereto.  Modifications do not include 
 additions to the
 Original Software or prior Modifications which (i) are separate modules of 
 software which
 may be distributed in conjunction with Licensed Software; or (ii) are not 
 derivative works
 of the Licensed Software itself.
 
 1.8
 Object Code means machine readable software code.
 
 1.9
 Original Contributor means LUCENT.
 
 1.10
 Original Software means the SPIN Software, in both Source Code form and 
 Object Code
 form, and any associated documentation as originally developed by Original 
 Contributor,
 and as originally furnished under this Agreement.
 
 1.11
 Recipient means any individual or legal entity receiving the Licensed 
 Software under
 this Agreement, including all Contributors, or receiving the Licensed 
 Software under
 another license agreement as authorized herein.
 
 1.12
 Source Code means human readable software code.
 
 2.0 GRANT of Rights
 2.1
 Subject to the terms of this Agreement, Original Contributor grants to 
 Licensee, a royalty-free, nonexclusive,
 non-transferable, worldwide license, subject to third party intellectual 
 property claims, to use, reproduce,
 modify, execute, display, perform, distribute and sublicense, the Original 
 Software (with or without
 Modifications) in Source Code form and/or Object Code form for commercial 
 and/or non-commercial purposes
 subject to the terms of this Agreement.  This grant includes a nonexclusive 
 and non-transferable license under
 any patents which Original Contributor has a right to license and which, but 
 for this license, are unavoidably
 and necessarily infringed by the execution of the inherent functionality of 
 the Original Software in the form
 furnished under this Agreement. Nothing contained herein shall be construed 
 as conferring by implication,
 estoppel or otherwise any license or right under any existing or future 
 patent claim which is directed to a
 combination of the functionality of the Original Software with the 
 functionality of any other software programs,
 or a combination of hardware systems other than the combination of the 
 Original Software and the hardware or
 firmware into which the Original Software is loaded. Distribution of Licensed 
 Software to third parties pursuant
 to this grant shall be subject to the same terms and conditions as set forth 
 in this Agreement, and may, at your
 option, include a reasonable charge for the cost of any media.  You may also, 
 at your option, charge for any
 other software, product or service which includes or incorporates the 
 Original Software

Re: SPIN Public license

2004-10-06 Thread Don Armstrong

On Thu, 07 Oct 2004, eddyp wrote:
 I am planning to package an application covered by the Spin Public License.
 
 is a free or non-free license?

This license is not DFSG Free, and is most likely not suitable for
inclusion in non-free either.

It was most recently discussed here:

http://people.debian.org/~terpstra/thread/20040130.042108.fd756a5d.en.html

Andrew Suffield lambasted the license authors here:

http://people.debian.org/~terpstra/message/20040130.050608.e083c434.en.html

and I followed suit here with explanations of which clauses fail the
DFSG:

http://people.debian.org/~terpstra/message/20040130.062427.f5d7d3e8.en.html


Don Armstrong

-- 
Fate and Temperament are two words for one and the same concept.
 -- Novalis [Hermann Hesse _Demian_]

http://www.donarmstrong.com http://rzlab.ucr.edu


signature.asc
Description: Digital signature