Bug#910591: ITA: logdata-anomaly-miner -- lightweight tool for log checking, log analysis
Dear Boyuan, I fixed all bugs you mentioned and lintian shows no more errors. Hence, it should be possible to continue with your review. Regards, Markus Wurzenberger -Original Message- From: Boyuan Yang Sent: Samstag, 13. Oktober 2018 01:56 To: Wurzenberger Markus Cc: 910...@bugs.debian.org; 910...@bugs.debian.org; Tobias Frost Subject: Re: Bug#910591: ITA: logdata-anomaly-miner -- lightweight tool for log checking, log analysis Control: tag -1 + moreinfo Tobias Frost 于2018年10月12日周五 上午1:35写道： > From my perspective (and I think this is also the opinion of the MIA > team), it is ok for Markus to take over the package in this case, as > he got the (verbal) ok from the former maintainer and we do not have > reasons to believe that this is not true. IMHO there is no need to > formally orphan it beforehand (and strictly it would not need an ITA either). > (And still, if we find out that Roman would disagrees, he can easily > be re-instatniated as maintainer.) > > -- > tobi Thanks tobi, that makes things easier. Markus, I just reviewed your package and there are pretty many problems. Have you taken a look at https://mentors.debian.net/package/logdata-anomaly-miner ? There are several errors and hints that you should solve first. Please run lintian every time you prepare a upload and solve all errors and warnings. * You should almost never convert a standard 3.0(quilt) package to 3.0(native) without proper explanation. Could you please revert packaging format back to 3.0 (quilt) or is there any reasons for converting package type? * Please use Standards-Version 4.2.1. That corresponds to the latest version of debian-policy. * dh-systemd is an obolete package. Please depends on latest dehelper (e.g., >= 11) and remove dependency to dh-systemd. The debian/compat file also must be updated accordingly. * You are using "dh --with python3" in debian/rules but not specifying any dependency or build-dependency on python3 (You are depending on python2 and python2 libraries all around in debian/control instead). That is a big error and must be solved. Please fix those bugs and notify me after all problems are solved. Thanks! -- Regards, Boyuan Yang smime.p7s Description: S/MIME cryptographic signature
Bug#910591: ITA: logdata-anomaly-miner -- lightweight tool for log checking, log analysis
Control: tag -1 + moreinfo Tobias Frost 于2018年10月12日周五 上午1:35写道： > From my perspective (and I think this is also the opinion of the MIA > team), it is ok for Markus to take over the package in this case, > as he got the (verbal) ok from the former maintainer and we do not have > reasons > to believe that this is not true. IMHO there is no need to formally > orphan it beforehand (and strictly it would not need an ITA either). > (And still, if we find out that Roman would disagrees, he can easily be > re-instatniated as maintainer.) > > -- > tobi Thanks tobi, that makes things easier. Markus, I just reviewed your package and there are pretty many problems. Have you taken a look at https://mentors.debian.net/package/logdata-anomaly-miner ? There are several errors and hints that you should solve first. Please run lintian every time you prepare a upload and solve all errors and warnings. * You should almost never convert a standard 3.0(quilt) package to 3.0(native) without proper explanation. Could you please revert packaging format back to 3.0 (quilt) or is there any reasons for converting package type? * Please use Standards-Version 4.2.1. That corresponds to the latest version of debian-policy. * dh-systemd is an obolete package. Please depends on latest dehelper (e.g., >= 11) and remove dependency to dh-systemd. The debian/compat file also must be updated accordingly. * You are using "dh --with python3" in debian/rules but not specifying any dependency or build-dependency on python3 (You are depending on python2 and python2 libraries all around in debian/control instead). That is a big error and must be solved. Please fix those bugs and notify me after all problems are solved. Thanks! -- Regards, Boyuan Yang
Bug#910591: ITA: logdata-anomaly-miner -- lightweight tool for log checking, log analysis
On Thu, Oct 11, 2018 at 10:12:23AM -0400, Boyuan Yang wrote: > Control: tag -1 - moreinfo > X-Debbugs-CC: roman.fied...@ait.ac.at > > Hi Markus, > > Wurzenberger Markus 于2018年10月11日周四 上午7:20写道： > > > > Hi Boyuan, > > > > unfortunately, Roman left our organization. Therefore, there is no > > possibility > > for him to make any confirmations via e-mail. Before he left, he handed me > > over the logdata- anomaly-miner launchpad project and repository to maintain > > and further develop it, as you can see here: > > https://launchpad.net/logdata-anomaly-miner > > https://git.launchpad.net/logdata-anomaly-miner > > He should have informed the downstream distributions before leaving to > fully hand over the > responsibilities... but it seems a little bit late to make such reminder. > > > Please let me know how to handle this situation so that I can keep the > > logdata-anomaly-miner Debian package up to date. > I am sending a mail copy to Debian QA/MIA Team since it looks like a > missing-in-action > scenario. Meanwhile, all latter uploads should not remove Roman from > maintainer list > unless he sends out a public email declaring the handover of > maintenance, or the Debian MIA > Team decides that his package should be orphaned. From my perspective (and I think this is also the opinion of the MIA team), it is ok for Markus to take over the package in this case, as he got the (verbal) ok from the former maintainer and we do not have reasons to believe that this is not true. IMHO there is no need to formally orphan it beforehand (and strictly it would not need an ITA either). (And still, if we find out that Roman would disagrees, he can easily be re-instatniated as maintainer.) -- tobi > I don't have enough time recently to review the work; I may examine it > later or some > other Debian Developers would review it. > > -- > Thanks, > Boyuan Yang > > > Regards, > > Markus Wurzenberger > > > > -----Original Message- > > From: Boyuan Yang > > Sent: Mittwoch, 10. Oktober 2018 22:10 > > To: 910...@bugs.debian.org; 910...@bugs.debian.org > > Subject: Bug#910591: ITA: logdata-anomaly-miner -- lightweight tool for log > > checking, log analysis > > > > X-Debbugs-CC: roman.fied...@ait.ac.at markus.wurzenber...@ait.ac.at > > Control: tag -1 + moreinfo > > > > Hi Markus, > > > > I noticed your RFS and ITA document. However, it seems that the original > > maintainer (Roman Fiedler) never submitted the RFA or Orphaning bug to > > declare > > that this package is given up for adoption. I think an acknowledgment from > > the > > original maintainer should be necessary. > > > > Dear Roman, could you please send an public email to confirm that you are > > willing to have Markus taken over the package maintenance? > > > > If Markus is no longer able to send emails to make confirmation, that is > > another situation and needs to be handled differently. signature.asc Description: PGP signature
Bug#910591: ITA: logdata-anomaly-miner -- lightweight tool for log checking, log analysis
Control: tag -1 - moreinfo X-Debbugs-CC: roman.fied...@ait.ac.at Hi Markus, Wurzenberger Markus 于2018年10月11日周四 上午7:20写道： > > Hi Boyuan, > > unfortunately, Roman left our organization. Therefore, there is no possibility > for him to make any confirmations via e-mail. Before he left, he handed me > over the logdata- anomaly-miner launchpad project and repository to maintain > and further develop it, as you can see here: > https://launchpad.net/logdata-anomaly-miner > https://git.launchpad.net/logdata-anomaly-miner He should have informed the downstream distributions before leaving to fully hand over the responsibilities... but it seems a little bit late to make such reminder. > Please let me know how to handle this situation so that I can keep the > logdata-anomaly-miner Debian package up to date. I am sending a mail copy to Debian QA/MIA Team since it looks like a missing-in-action scenario. Meanwhile, all latter uploads should not remove Roman from maintainer list unless he sends out a public email declaring the handover of maintenance, or the Debian MIA Team decides that his package should be orphaned. I don't have enough time recently to review the work; I may examine it later or some other Debian Developers would review it. -- Thanks, Boyuan Yang > Regards, > Markus Wurzenberger > > -Original Message- > From: Boyuan Yang > Sent: Mittwoch, 10. Oktober 2018 22:10 > To: 910...@bugs.debian.org; 910...@bugs.debian.org > Subject: Bug#910591: ITA: logdata-anomaly-miner -- lightweight tool for log > checking, log analysis > > X-Debbugs-CC: roman.fied...@ait.ac.at markus.wurzenber...@ait.ac.at > Control: tag -1 + moreinfo > > Hi Markus, > > I noticed your RFS and ITA document. However, it seems that the original > maintainer (Roman Fiedler) never submitted the RFA or Orphaning bug to declare > that this package is given up for adoption. I think an acknowledgment from the > original maintainer should be necessary. > > Dear Roman, could you please send an public email to confirm that you are > willing to have Markus taken over the package maintenance? > > If Markus is no longer able to send emails to make confirmation, that is > another situation and needs to be handled differently.
Bug#910591: ITA: logdata-anomaly-miner -- lightweight tool for log checking, log analysis
Hi Boyuan, unfortunately, Roman left our organization. Therefore, there is no possibility for him to make any confirmations via e-mail. Before he left, he handed me over the logdata- anomaly-miner launchpad project and repository to maintain and further develop it, as you can see here: https://launchpad.net/logdata-anomaly-miner https://git.launchpad.net/logdata-anomaly-miner Please let me know how to handle this situation so that I can keep the logdata-anomaly-miner Debian package up to date. Regards, Markus Wurzenberger -Original Message- From: Boyuan Yang Sent: Mittwoch, 10. Oktober 2018 22:10 To: 910...@bugs.debian.org; 910...@bugs.debian.org Subject: Bug#910591: ITA: logdata-anomaly-miner -- lightweight tool for log checking, log analysis X-Debbugs-CC: roman.fied...@ait.ac.at markus.wurzenber...@ait.ac.at Control: tag -1 + moreinfo Hi Markus, I noticed your RFS and ITA document. However, it seems that the original maintainer (Roman Fiedler) never submitted the RFA or Orphaning bug to declare that this package is given up for adoption. I think an acknowledgment from the original maintainer should be necessary. Dear Roman, could you please send an public email to confirm that you are willing to have Markus taken over the package maintenance? If Markus is no longer able to send emails to make confirmation, that is another situation and needs to be handled differently. -- Regards, Boyuan Yang smime.p7s Description: S/MIME cryptographic signature
Bug#910591: ITA: logdata-anomaly-miner -- lightweight tool for log checking, log analysis
X-Debbugs-CC: roman.fied...@ait.ac.at markus.wurzenber...@ait.ac.at Control: tag -1 + moreinfo Hi Markus, I noticed your RFS and ITA document. However, it seems that the original maintainer (Roman Fiedler) never submitted the RFA or Orphaning bug to declare that this package is given up for adoption. I think an acknowledgment from the original maintainer should be necessary. Dear Roman, could you please send an public email to confirm that you are willing to have Markus taken over the package maintenance? If Markus is no longer able to send emails to make confirmation, that is another situation and needs to be handled differently. -- Regards, Boyuan Yang
