Re: [RFS] coinutils and coinor-osi
Hi Håvard, Le 19/12/2023 à 09:19, Håvard F. Aasen a écrit : Hi Pierre, On 18.12.2023 18:13, Pierre Gruet wrote: Dear Håvard, This is a follow-up to your RFS email [0]. I am willing to sponsor your packages coinor-data-sample and coinor-data-netlib except that is appears some copyright entries are missing, see the output of scan-copyrights for instance. Are you comfortable with fixing these? After Julien's initial reply to the RFS [1], I reached out to upstream asking about the license, it turns out they do not know where the files originates from, who has the copyright or which license applies [2]. It seems that the packages can't be included in Debian. Let me know if I'm wrong in this. Hmm no, Julien and you are right. I overlooked that in my preliminary copyright check. The files in question is the same files that has been shipped with coinutils the last 15 years, though, I hoped to replace them with coinor-data-sample and coinor-data-netlib. Also you have been doing a great work on coinutils and I would like to upload it, is it fine for you? I have tested rdeps with ratt and everything is OK. Alternatively I can grant you DM permissions, please tell me. Either way is fine, but having upload rights would be nice. Granted, please go ahead when you wish to. I'm hoping we can continue with the prepared package, and as long as I haven't misjudged the licensing issues with the extra test files, remove them with the next upstream release. Going forward, the source files will be downloaded from GitHub and will not contain the extra test files. Sounds reasonable. In the worst scenario, the problematic data files won't be shipped by any package and we will cope with this situation. I hope to prepare the next release relatively fast, I only need to rebuild the rdeps and see which, if any, packages breaks without the extra test files. Also please fetch the current state of the repository, I have acknowledged the QA upload by Adrian Bunk. Will do, thanks for incorporating the changes. I case you do upload, I just pushed two small changes to the repo. Ack! Best, -- Pierre OpenPGP_signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Re: [RFS] coinutils and coinor-osi
Hi Pierre, On 18.12.2023 18:13, Pierre Gruet wrote: > Dear Håvard, > > This is a follow-up to your RFS email [0]. I am willing to sponsor your > packages coinor-data-sample and coinor-data-netlib except that is appears > some copyright entries are missing, see the output of scan-copyrights for > instance. > > Are you comfortable with fixing these? > After Julien's initial reply to the RFS [1], I reached out to upstream asking about the license, it turns out they do not know where the files originates from, who has the copyright or which license applies [2]. It seems that the packages can't be included in Debian. Let me know if I'm wrong in this. The files in question is the same files that has been shipped with coinutils the last 15 years, though, I hoped to replace them with coinor-data-sample and coinor-data-netlib. > Also you have been doing a great work on coinutils and I would like to upload > it, is it fine for you? I have tested rdeps with ratt and everything is OK. > Alternatively I can grant you DM permissions, please tell me. Either way is fine, but having upload rights would be nice. I'm hoping we can continue with the prepared package, and as long as I haven't misjudged the licensing issues with the extra test files, remove them with the next upstream release. Going forward, the source files will be downloaded from GitHub and will not contain the extra test files. I hope to prepare the next release relatively fast, I only need to rebuild the rdeps and see which, if any, packages breaks without the extra test files. > Also please fetch the current state of the repository, I have acknowledged > the QA upload by Adrian Bunk. > Will do, thanks for incorporating the changes. I case you do upload, I just pushed two small changes to the repo. -- Håvard [1] https://lists.debian.org/debian-science/2023/06/msg4.html [2] https://github.com/coin-or-tools/Data-Sample/issues/2
Re: [RFS] coinutils and coinor-osi
Dear Håvard, This is a follow-up to your RFS email [0]. I am willing to sponsor your packages coinor-data-sample and coinor-data-netlib except that is appears some copyright entries are missing, see the output of scan-copyrights for instance. Are you comfortable with fixing these? Also you have been doing a great work on coinutils and I would like to upload it, is it fine for you? I have tested rdeps with ratt and everything is OK. Alternatively I can grant you DM permissions, please tell me. Also please fetch the current state of the repository, I have acknowledged the QA upload by Adrian Bunk. Best regards and thanks for all the work, -- Pierre [0] https://lists.debian.org/debian-science/2023/06/msg00012.html OpenPGP_signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
