Re: HCatalog to Hive Committership
I have worked closely with all 7 HCatalog committers and IMHO none of them really require any mentorship per se. They are mature, level headed and have understanding of hive codebase already. I am willing to help out in any shape or form to accelerate the process. Thanks, Ashutosh On Tue, Apr 23, 2013 at 1:06 PM, Carl Steinbach cwsteinb...@gmail.comwrote: I volunteer. On Mon, Apr 22, 2013 at 10:54 AM, Alan Gates ga...@hortonworks.com wrote: Asking for volunteers is probably better than making assignments. We have 7 HCatalog committers (http://hive.apache.org/credits.html). If current Hive committers/PMC members could volunteer to mentor a committer we can start assigning mentors to pupils. Seem reasonable? Alan. On Apr 16, 2013, at 6:10 PM, Carl Steinbach wrote: HCatalog committers will be assigned shepherds - How do we go about getting assigned one? I recommend asking Alan about this since he wrote the proposal. Alan, who is responsible for making these assignments? Thanks. Carl
Re: HCatalog to Hive Committership
Asking for volunteers is probably better than making assignments. We have 7 HCatalog committers (http://hive.apache.org/credits.html). If current Hive committers/PMC members could volunteer to mentor a committer we can start assigning mentors to pupils. Seem reasonable? Alan. On Apr 16, 2013, at 6:10 PM, Carl Steinbach wrote: HCatalog committers will be assigned shepherds - How do we go about getting assigned one? I recommend asking Alan about this since he wrote the proposal. Alan, who is responsible for making these assignments? Thanks. Carl
Re: HCatalog to Hive Committership
HCatalog committers will be assigned shepherds - How do we go about getting assigned one? I recommend asking Alan about this since he wrote the proposal. Alan, who is responsible for making these assignments? Thanks. Carl
Re: HCatalog to Hive Committership
Thanks for your response. This clarifies a lot. I just have two follow-up questions: 1. Does reviewing patches have any bearing? 2. Is it a requirement that the aggregate of patches submitted touch all the hive components? Also it'd be great to know if the other PMCs have a similar criteria? -Francis On Apr 4, 2013, at 4:06 PM, Edward Capriolo wrote: Anecdotally, The criteria is patches/features and a track record of being dedicated to hive. 10 smaller medium features might do it, or one big one and five other bugs, or two patches and crazy dedication on the mailing list. After enough work someone takes notice and nominates you. I did not remember that shepherd language :) but the best bet is hanging out on the hive IRC, I would volunteer but I am fairly bugged down ATM with things not hive. On Thu, Apr 4, 2013 at 4:18 PM, Francis Christopher Liu fc...@yahoo-inc.com wrote: Hi, Given that moving HCatalog into Hive is well underway. As an HCatalog committer I'd like to better understand the path to becoming a Hive committer. Based on what I gleaned from email discussions. I'd like to verify the following: HCatalog committers will be assigned shepherds - How do we go about getting assigned one? HCatalog committers are expected to become Hive Committers in 6-8 months - Will there be a review done in 6-8 mos for the existing HCatalog committers. What would be the criteria? What happens if we don't get voted/nominated? I and a few of my colleagues (also HCat committers) are interested in becoming Hive committers and it would greatly help our effort if we could clarify the things discussed in the list. Feel free to point out anything I missed or misunderstood. -Francis
Re: HCatalog to Hive Committership
Francis, You may have already seen this but I thought I'd post anyways: https://cwiki.apache.org/Hive/becomingacommitter.html Mark On Fri, Apr 5, 2013 at 11:35 AM, Francis Liu tof...@apache.org wrote: Thanks for your response. This clarifies a lot. I just have two follow-up questions: 1. Does reviewing patches have any bearing? 2. Is it a requirement that the aggregate of patches submitted touch all the hive components? Also it'd be great to know if the other PMCs have a similar criteria? -Francis On Apr 4, 2013, at 4:06 PM, Edward Capriolo wrote: Anecdotally, The criteria is patches/features and a track record of being dedicated to hive. 10 smaller medium features might do it, or one big one and five other bugs, or two patches and crazy dedication on the mailing list. After enough work someone takes notice and nominates you. I did not remember that shepherd language :) but the best bet is hanging out on the hive IRC, I would volunteer but I am fairly bugged down ATM with things not hive. On Thu, Apr 4, 2013 at 4:18 PM, Francis Christopher Liu fc...@yahoo-inc.com wrote: Hi, Given that moving HCatalog into Hive is well underway. As an HCatalog committer I'd like to better understand the path to becoming a Hive committer. Based on what I gleaned from email discussions. I'd like to verify the following: HCatalog committers will be assigned shepherds - How do we go about getting assigned one? HCatalog committers are expected to become Hive Committers in 6-8 months - Will there be a review done in 6-8 mos for the existing HCatalog committers. What would be the criteria? What happens if we don't get voted/nominated? I and a few of my colleagues (also HCat committers) are interested in becoming Hive committers and it would greatly help our effort if we could clarify the things discussed in the list. Feel free to point out anything I missed or misunderstood. -Francis
Re: HCatalog to Hive Committership
#4 on the list https://cwiki.apache.org/Hive/becomingacommitter.html: - help improve the website and the wiki That's the Hive wiki, so contributions to the HCatalog wiki wouldn't count. But what if we decide to put all the HCatalog docs into the Hive wiki? Would that be a contribution to Hive? I only ask because there's a ton of grunt work to be done on converting the HCatalog and WebHCat documentation from xml to wiki markup. But it's a trick question, because the current plan is to give HCat docs a separate wiki tab. One might say it's equivalent but I'm not trying to define the line between Hive and HCat -- I'm just scouting for volunteers to help with the grunt work, hoping to give them an extra incentive. – Lefty On Fri, Apr 5, 2013 at 11:38 AM, Mark Grover grover.markgro...@gmail.comwrote: Francis, You may have already seen this but I thought I'd post anyways: https://cwiki.apache.org/Hive/becomingacommitter.html Mark On Fri, Apr 5, 2013 at 11:35 AM, Francis Liu tof...@apache.org wrote: Thanks for your response. This clarifies a lot. I just have two follow-up questions: 1. Does reviewing patches have any bearing? 2. Is it a requirement that the aggregate of patches submitted touch all the hive components? Also it'd be great to know if the other PMCs have a similar criteria? -Francis On Apr 4, 2013, at 4:06 PM, Edward Capriolo wrote: Anecdotally, The criteria is patches/features and a track record of being dedicated to hive. 10 smaller medium features might do it, or one big one and five other bugs, or two patches and crazy dedication on the mailing list. After enough work someone takes notice and nominates you. I did not remember that shepherd language :) but the best bet is hanging out on the hive IRC, I would volunteer but I am fairly bugged down ATM with things not hive. On Thu, Apr 4, 2013 at 4:18 PM, Francis Christopher Liu fc...@yahoo-inc.com wrote: Hi, Given that moving HCatalog into Hive is well underway. As an HCatalog committer I'd like to better understand the path to becoming a Hive committer. Based on what I gleaned from email discussions. I'd like to verify the following: HCatalog committers will be assigned shepherds - How do we go about getting assigned one? HCatalog committers are expected to become Hive Committers in 6-8 months - Will there be a review done in 6-8 mos for the existing HCatalog committers. What would be the criteria? What happens if we don't get voted/nominated? I and a few of my colleagues (also HCat committers) are interested in becoming Hive committers and it would greatly help our effort if we could clarify the things discussed in the list. Feel free to point out anything I missed or misunderstood. -Francis
Re: HCatalog to Hive Committership
Anecdotally, The criteria is patches/features and a track record of being dedicated to hive. 10 smaller medium features might do it, or one big one and five other bugs, or two patches and crazy dedication on the mailing list. After enough work someone takes notice and nominates you. I did not remember that shepherd language :) but the best bet is hanging out on the hive IRC, I would volunteer but I am fairly bugged down ATM with things not hive. On Thu, Apr 4, 2013 at 4:18 PM, Francis Christopher Liu fc...@yahoo-inc.com wrote: Hi, Given that moving HCatalog into Hive is well underway. As an HCatalog committer I'd like to better understand the path to becoming a Hive committer. Based on what I gleaned from email discussions. I'd like to verify the following: HCatalog committers will be assigned shepherds - How do we go about getting assigned one? HCatalog committers are expected to become Hive Committers in 6-8 months - Will there be a review done in 6-8 mos for the existing HCatalog committers. What would be the criteria? What happens if we don't get voted/nominated? I and a few of my colleagues (also HCat committers) are interested in becoming Hive committers and it would greatly help our effort if we could clarify the things discussed in the list. Feel free to point out anything I missed or misunderstood. -Francis
