Re: [DISCUSS] Clearing Down the Kibble Github Repo

2023-07-10 Thread Sharan Foga
That's sounds like a practical way forward. And I see there is already an empty 
nextgen branch

Also if we are going to keep the history and the PR improves what we have -  I 
dont see any reason not to merge it before we start any of the new stuff. 

Thanks
Sharan

On 2023/07/10 20:05:59 Daniel Gruno wrote:
> On 2023-07-10 22:02, sharanf wrote:
> > Hi All
> > 
> > When we separated out the repos into Kibble-1 and Kibble the plan was to 
> > start again from scratch. Some work was done in the new Kibble repo but 
> > that has been stalled for quite a while. I know Daniel has some ideas 
> > for either kickstarting some new work but that could mean clearing down 
> > the Kibble repo once again.
> > 
> > We don't have a working version on things in the Kibble repo as its 
> > Kibble-1 that is the working version. I've also seen that we are getting 
> > some PRs Inlcuding this one (https://github.com/apache/kibble/pull/17) 
> > coming through on the Kibble repo that are more documentation focussed 
> > changes.
> > 
> > So I'd like to discuss whether we continue to merge these PRs or decide 
> > to clear the Kibble repo down and begin again.
> > 
> > What do people think?
> 
> I think, if the aim is to sort of start afresh, perhaps the best 
> compromise there is to move the current main branch to the side (rename 
> it, keep its history) and make a new main branch from scratch.
> 
> And yeah, I do have some WIP stuff that grabs ideas and prototypes from 
> both old and newer kibble code, I should polish it up and commit, when 
> time allows :)
> 
> > 
> > Thanks
> > Sharan
> 
> 


Re: [DISCUSS] Clearing Down the Kibble Github Repo

2023-07-10 Thread Daniel Gruno

On 2023-07-10 22:02, sharanf wrote:

Hi All

When we separated out the repos into Kibble-1 and Kibble the plan was to 
start again from scratch. Some work was done in the new Kibble repo but 
that has been stalled for quite a while. I know Daniel has some ideas 
for either kickstarting some new work but that could mean clearing down 
the Kibble repo once again.


We don't have a working version on things in the Kibble repo as its 
Kibble-1 that is the working version. I've also seen that we are getting 
some PRs Inlcuding this one (https://github.com/apache/kibble/pull/17) 
coming through on the Kibble repo that are more documentation focussed 
changes.


So I'd like to discuss whether we continue to merge these PRs or decide 
to clear the Kibble repo down and begin again.


What do people think?


I think, if the aim is to sort of start afresh, perhaps the best 
compromise there is to move the current main branch to the side (rename 
it, keep its history) and make a new main branch from scratch.


And yeah, I do have some WIP stuff that grabs ideas and prototypes from 
both old and newer kibble code, I should polish it up and commit, when 
time allows :)




Thanks
Sharan




[DISCUSS] Clearing Down the Kibble Github Repo

2023-07-10 Thread sharanf

Hi All

When we separated out the repos into Kibble-1 and Kibble the plan was to 
start again from scratch. Some work was done in the new Kibble repo but 
that has been stalled for quite a while. I know Daniel has some ideas 
for either kickstarting some new work but that could mean clearing down 
the Kibble repo once again.


We don't have a working version on things in the Kibble repo as its 
Kibble-1 that is the working version. I've also seen that we are getting 
some PRs Inlcuding this one (https://github.com/apache/kibble/pull/17) 
coming through on the Kibble repo that are more documentation focussed 
changes.


So I'd like to discuss whether we continue to merge these PRs or decide 
to clear the Kibble repo down and begin again.


What do people think?

Thanks
Sharan