Congratulations Alex,
Serkan...
18.02.2020 10:42 tarihinde Alex Harui yazdı:
Today, I received permission to disclose that Alina & Pashmina's team has 88 of
their modules ready for release (tested and validated by their QA team). They
still have more modules to migrate before they deliver to their customer, but it is
a good sign that the emulation is sufficient for many needs.
Once I can merge the "has" branch and re-stabilize, I will hope that's the last
big change we need for a while. I have heard that there are other migration efforts
underway using migration and I'm sure they will keep finding bugs, but I'm feeling better
about the emulation code.
-Alex
On 12/18/19, 9:05 AM, "Alex Harui" wrote:
Every day, I hope to hear news that Alina & Pashmina or Serkan or somebody else has
deployed a production app using the MXRoyale and/or Spark Royale emulation components. But
instead, I see more bugs being filed for "obvious" things. You can look at the
issues list of open and fixed issues and the commits that fixed them to get a feel for it.
Each of us has their own threshold of how good a 1.0 version should be, so if more of you can
look at these bugs and think it is ok for a 1.0 to have these problems, then great, let's
release the next version as 1.0, but when I try to remember what Flex 1.0 was like, I think
it didn't have these kinds of problems.
As Carlos said below, we get one chance to make a good first impression, so I am being conservative. But it isn't my decision alone. It is really up to the rest of you.
-Alex
On 12/18/19, 6:41 AM, "Carlos Rovira" wrote:
Hi Piotr,
I'm afraid my perception is that we need to get to 1.0 in a natural way. I
mean: releasing 1.0 and giving exposure in all ways we can (webs,
social
media, magazines,...), means people will try us. If they try and fail,
will
never come back. So think about this as "only on bullet in your gun",
if
you fail de shot, that will be bad for all the work we are done. I'm
ok to
release 1.0 as soon as we see from "bird eye perspective" that all
things
work as we expect.
For me that things are:
* Documentation will need to have at least some missing pages of features
like: DataBindnig, Loading External Data (HTTPSerice, RemoteObject,
JSON),
View States, Item Renderers. Things like this are essential.
* Emulation components need to be in a shape that allow migrations in a
good degree. I think people approaching direct migration with emulation
components will many issues. I don't take into account look and feel of
emulation components, just functionality and working from a flex code
perspective, and just normal use cases with MX/Spark code, not third
party
libraries that we have no control over. Simple apps like TDF, and
examples
should work.
If we decided we want to bypass the previous, at least we need to ensure
"first try" of Royale for a newcomer (someone that knows very few
about the
tech) is successful. This is most important things of all. The other
two
are needed if we want people does not get frustrated and have
solutions on
their own and stay with us. The opposite is people can have a first try
successful but abandon Royale due to unfinished things.
I think 0.9.7-SNAPSHOT captures in a realistic number where we are.
Technology works, and most people using it now can do lots of things,
but
we still need to cover some things to reach that 1.0. We are not too
far
but I think is still some month in the future.
just my 2 :)
Carlos
El mié., 18 dic. 2019 a las 10:30, Piotr Zarzycki (<
piotrzarzyck...@gmail.com>) escribió:
> Hello,
>
> This thread is old and this was the last message from me. What has
changed
> on your end guys ?
>
> Thanks,
> Piotr
>
> wt., 30 kwi 2019 o 10:07 Piotr Zarzycki
> napisał(a):
>
> > Hi Guys,
> >
> > Thank you so far for a great discussion. I see that there is an
obvious
> > needs to improve documentation the most.
> >
> > I would like to express my personal feelings regarding releasing
anything
> > what is not 1.0 after 0.9.6. Based on my experience with this
project I
> > don't believe that releasing 0.9.7, 0.9.8 till 1.0 etc. will take
less
> than
> > 6-8 months form now on. Even if we will have automatic release
process I
> > cannot believe that is going to happen in a less time than I
mention.
> >
