Re: Platform meeting changes effective June 2013

2013-07-10 Thread Gary Kwong

On 5/29/13 9:05 PM, Brad Lassey wrote:

On 5/29/13 11:42 PM, Anthony Jones wrote:

What is the attendance like from the Asia-Pacific region?


I can't recall anyone from Asia-Pacific who is a regular attendee.



It is extremely difficult to (expect anyone to, or otherwise) regularly 
attend a meeting that is held at 3am local time.


That's why the notes are great for catching up on what was discussed, 
which is what I do whenever I'm in that region.


Just my 2 cents,
-Gary
___
dev-platform mailing list
dev-platform@lists.mozilla.org
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-platform


Re: Platform meeting changes effective June 2013

2013-07-10 Thread Chris Pearce

On 5/31/2013 3:25 AM, Lawrence Mandel wrote:

2. Work on summarizing discussions or vague items in the agenda so that the 
notes can be understood by people who don't attend the meeting

Please let me know how the notes shape up.


As someone who can't attend most meetings due to inconvenient time 
zones, I greatly appreciate good meeting notes, and I regularly try to 
read them. Thanks for taking charge of this!



Cheers,
Chris Pearce.
___
dev-platform mailing list
dev-platform@lists.mozilla.org
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-platform


Re: Platform meeting changes effective June 2013

2013-07-10 Thread Brad Lassey

On 5/29/13 11:42 PM, Anthony Jones wrote:

What is the attendance like from the Asia-Pacific region?


I can't recall anyone from Asia-Pacific who is a regular attendee.

___
dev-platform mailing list
dev-platform@lists.mozilla.org
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-platform


Re: Platform meeting changes effective June 2013

2013-05-30 Thread Lawrence Mandel
- Original Message -
 On 30/05/13 04:55, Mike Hommey wrote:
  As someone that will soon be in UTC+9, and taking on the occasion
  to
  represent all the people in that timezone and surroundings, a
  couple
  hours before 3am is not very a great time to decide whether I'd
  attend
  or not. That being said, I haven't attended much so far. OTOH, if
  the
  meeting value is increasing which it looks like it will, i might
  want
  to. I don't know if 3am is attractive enough, though.
 
 What is the attendance like from the Asia-Pacific region?

I think the answer is low to none. This is specifically why I will do #2 below.

 2. Work on summarizing discussions or vague items in the agenda so that the 
 notes can be understood by people who don't attend the meeting

Please let me know how the notes shape up.

Lawrence
___
dev-platform mailing list
dev-platform@lists.mozilla.org
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-platform


Re: Platform meeting changes effective June 2013

2013-05-29 Thread Mike Hommey
On Tue, May 28, 2013 at 09:29:46PM -0700, Lawrence Mandel wrote:
 I would also prefer an agenda that is set before the meeting and need
 to discuss this with those who will be contributing to the agenda. I
 think a day in advance might be pushing it given when I see most
 Mozilla meeting agendas take shape. I would be happy with a fairly
 solid agenda a couple of hours in advance of the meeting. Would that
 be enough time to let you decide if you want to attend?

As someone that will soon be in UTC+9, and taking on the occasion to
represent all the people in that timezone and surroundings, a couple
hours before 3am is not very a great time to decide whether I'd attend
or not. That being said, I haven't attended much so far. OTOH, if the
meeting value is increasing which it looks like it will, i might want
to. I don't know if 3am is attractive enough, though.

Mike
___
dev-platform mailing list
dev-platform@lists.mozilla.org
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-platform


Platform meeting changes effective June 2013

2013-05-28 Thread Lawrence Mandel
tl;dr The platform meeting will revert to focus on engineering teams as of next 
week.

We discussed the platform meeting's use during today's platform meeting. The 
consensus of the people who attended the meeting is that the platform meeting 
is useful and should be continued. Here is my summary of the key points from 
the discussion.
 
- releng and relman both find this a useful venue to disseminate information
- People like the team status updates - suggestion to hear from more of the 
technical teams
- Useful venue for flagging topics on mailing lists - summaries of any 
discussion should be posted back to the list
- Good opportunity to discuss issues with the technical teams
- Useful for raising awareness and finding owners for stability, orange factor 
bugs
- This meeting is a forcing function for the activities listed above

Specific suggestions:
- a concise summary of this meeting or decisions should be posted to 
dev-planning or a blog post
- revert the meeting agenda back to focus on technical teams (the meeting 
changed in Oct 2012) not products - we have the product meeting for product 
discussions
- provide a section in the agenda for others to ask questions of individual 
teams

Based on this feedback...

I will take a stab at defining the purpose of the meeting as:
A weekly time for engineering teams to share information with and ask questions 
of one another.

I will make the following changes, effective next week:
1. Modify the agenda to focus on engineering teams and activities.
2. Work on summarizing discussions or vague items in the agenda so that the 
notes can be understood by people who don't attend the meeting

In support of these changes, I will speak with as many engineering team 
managers as possible before next week in an attempt to bring the content inline 
with what is desired.

Of course, this is a work in progress. This being your meeting, do these 
changes make sense to you? Please share your suggestions either by replying to 
the list or to me individually.

Thanks for reading.

Lawrence
___
dev-platform mailing list
dev-platform@lists.mozilla.org
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-platform


Re: Platform meeting changes effective June 2013

2013-05-28 Thread Lawrence Mandel


- Original Message -
 I'd really like to see the agenda for this meeting to be finalized a
 day
 or so in advance so that I can decide whether what's going to be
 discussed in the meeting interests me or not.  Do you think doing
 that
 would make sense?

I would also prefer an agenda that is set before the meeting and need to 
discuss this with those who will be contributing to the agenda. I think a day 
in advance might be pushing it given when I see most Mozilla meeting agendas 
take shape. I would be happy with a fairly solid agenda a couple of hours in 
advance of the meeting. Would that be enough time to let you decide if you want 
to attend?

Lawrence

 
 Cheers,
 Ehsan
 
 On 2013-05-28 5:10 PM, Lawrence Mandel wrote:
  tl;dr The platform meeting will revert to focus on engineering
  teams as of next week.
 
  We discussed the platform meeting's use during today's platform
  meeting. The consensus of the people who attended the meeting is
  that the platform meeting is useful and should be continued. Here
  is my summary of the key points from the discussion.
 
  - releng and relman both find this a useful venue to disseminate
  information
  - People like the team status updates - suggestion to hear from
  more of the technical teams
  - Useful venue for flagging topics on mailing lists - summaries of
  any discussion should be posted back to the list
  - Good opportunity to discuss issues with the technical teams
  - Useful for raising awareness and finding owners for stability,
  orange factor bugs
  - This meeting is a forcing function for the activities listed
  above
 
  Specific suggestions:
  - a concise summary of this meeting or decisions should be posted
  to dev-planning or a blog post
  - revert the meeting agenda back to focus on technical teams (the
  meeting changed in Oct 2012) not products - we have the product
  meeting for product discussions
  - provide a section in the agenda for others to ask questions of
  individual teams
 
  Based on this feedback...
 
  I will take a stab at defining the purpose of the meeting as:
  A weekly time for engineering teams to share information with and
  ask questions of one another.
 
  I will make the following changes, effective next week:
  1. Modify the agenda to focus on engineering teams and activities.
  2. Work on summarizing discussions or vague items in the agenda so
  that the notes can be understood by people who don't attend the
  meeting
 
  In support of these changes, I will speak with as many engineering
  team managers as possible before next week in an attempt to bring
  the content inline with what is desired.
 
  Of course, this is a work in progress. This being your meeting, do
  these changes make sense to you? Please share your suggestions
  either by replying to the list or to me individually.
 
  Thanks for reading.
 
  Lawrence
  ___
  dev-platform mailing list
  dev-platform@lists.mozilla.org
  https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-platform
 
 
 
___
dev-platform mailing list
dev-platform@lists.mozilla.org
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-platform