Re: [O] Remove redundant tags of headlines
Bastien wrote: I tried Edebugging it, but Edebug does not jump into the execution of the anonymous function... Just give a name to the anonymous function... and you're back on edebugging. :) OK, of course! Thanks for the tip. Back to the problem... The root cause is that, with the following example: --8---cut here---start-8--- #+TITLE: ECM Inherited tags #+FILETAGS: :org: * Test ** TODO Vérifier pourquoi les tags redondants ne sont plus effacés:FLAGGED: Lorsqu'ils correspondent à un tag hérité. *** TODO Test :FLAGGED: --8---cut here---end---8--- when point is somewhere on the outline-3 heading TODO Test, the following expression: (org-entry-get (point) ALLTAGS) returns #(:org:FLAGGED: 1 4 (inherited t)) IOW, FLAGGED is not shown as inherited! Hence, all the mechanics which follows never removes it! Best regards, Seb -- Sebastien Vauban
Re: [O] Remove redundant tags of headlines
Sebastien Vauban sva-news-D0wtAvR13HarG/idocf...@public.gmane.org I tried Edebugging it, but Edebug does not jump into the execution of the anonymous function... edebug can only jump to the anonymous function if it knows that it is a function, which means : don't quote the lambda (or quote using #'). I fixed it on worg. (btw, I noticed that worg says remote: No such file: /home/emacs/git/worg/org-tutorials/../code/awk/ical2org.awk src awk when I push to it. I *guess* it comes from org-tutorials/org-google-sync.org which tries to #+INCLUDE the above, but I'm unsure how to fix it. I didn't touch that file.) -- Nico.
Re: [O] Remove redundant tags of headlines
Hi Sébastien, Sebastien Vauban sva-news-D0wtAvR13HarG/idocf...@public.gmane.org writes: #(:org:FLAGGED: 1 4 (inherited t)) IOW, FLAGGED is not shown as inherited! Because it is not inherited, it is present in the headline. Am I missing something? Hence, all the mechanics which follows never removes it! You mean the mechanics of the function on Worg? Or is there any real Org bug hidden somewhere here? -- Bastien
Re: [O] Remove redundant tags of headlines
Hi Nicolas, Nicolas Richard theonewiththeevill...@yahoo.fr writes: (btw, I noticed that worg says remote: No such file: /home/emacs/git/worg/org-tutorials/../code/awk/ical2org.awk src awk when I push to it. I *guess* it comes from org-tutorials/org-google-sync.org which tries to #+INCLUDE the above, but I'm unsure how to fix it. I didn't touch that file.) I've created a link to ical2org.awk, including such a big file looks wrong. This does not fix the problem, it only circumvent it. -- Bastien
Re: [O] Remove redundant tags of headlines
Hi Bastien, Bastien wrote: Sebastien Vauban writes: #(:org:FLAGGED: 1 4 (inherited t)) IOW, FLAGGED is not shown as inherited! Because it is not inherited, it is present in the headline. Am I missing something? From my point of view and the point of that function (IIUC), yes. Look again: --8---cut here---start-8--- #+FILETAGS: :org: * List of projects ** TODO Project A :FLAGGED: *** TODO Task 1 :FLAGGED: --8---cut here---end---8--- Of course, FLAGGED is present in the headline but, at the same time, it is inherited. IIUC, the goal of the function written by David was to remove redundant tags. In the above case, FLAGGED should be removed from Task 1 because it is superfluous (redundant with its parent entry). Hence, all the mechanics which follows never removes it! You mean the mechanics of the function on Worg? Yes, as explicited above. Or is there any real Org bug hidden somewhere here? I'd think that asking for all tags of Task 1 should output both a local FLAGGED tag and an inherited FLAGGED one. Am I wrong? Best regards, Seb -- Sebastien Vauban
Re: [O] Remove redundant tags of headlines
Hi Sébastien, Sebastien Vauban sva-news-D0wtAvR13HarG/idocf...@public.gmane.org writes: ** TODO Project A :FLAGGED: *** TODO Task 1 :FLAGGED: Of course, FLAGGED is present in the headline but, at the same time, it is inherited. It means Org favors explicit tags over inherited ones when presenting them through `org-entry-get'. IIUC, the goal of the function written by David was to remove redundant tags. In the above case, FLAGGED should be removed from Task 1 because it is superfluous (redundant with its parent entry). Can you find when David's function was still functional for you? I'd think that asking for all tags of Task 1 should output both a local FLAGGED tag and an inherited FLAGGED one. Well, ALLTAGS means all distinct tags for me, and I don't see how outputting all duplicate tags would be useful. You'll have to find another use-case than just David's function to convince me :) -- Bastien
Re: [O] Remove redundant tags of headlines
Hi Bastien, ** TODO Project A :FLAGGED: *** TODO Task 1 :FLAGGED: Of course, FLAGGED is present in the headline but, at the same time, it is inherited. It means Org favors explicit tags over inherited ones when presenting them through `org-entry-get'. Yes, that's what I thought. That makes sense. IIUC, the goal of the function written by David was to remove redundant tags. In the above case, FLAGGED should be removed from Task 1 because it is superfluous (redundant with its parent entry). Can you find when David's function was still functional for you? No, and, honestly, I won't try, because I remember seeing that not functioning for a very long time, certainly well above 1 year. And so many things changed in my config (Emacs, Org mode) and in Org mode, that I'm not sure at all to come back to a previously working state -- if it did [1]. I'd think that asking for all tags of Task 1 should output both a local FLAGGED tag and an inherited FLAGGED one. Well, ALLTAGS means all distinct tags for me, and I don't see how outputting all duplicate tags would be useful. Well, here, it would be useful that ALLTAGS would really report ALL TAGS... (even if it wasn't its default behavior) You'll have to find another use-case than just David's function to convince me :) Then, I won't. But such a cleaning (in `before-save-hook') is not possible, then? Best regards, Seb [1] I can't exclude that my mind would play me tricks. -- Sebastien Vauban
[O] Remove redundant tags of headlines
Hello, FYI, the code to Remove redundant tags of headlines (see http://orgmode.org/worg/org-hacks.html#sec-1-8-1) is not functioning anymore. --8---cut here---start-8--- (defun dmj/org-remove-redundant-tags () Remove redundant tags of headlines in current buffer. A tag is considered redundant if it is local to a headline and inherited by a parent headline. (interactive) (when (eq major-mode 'org-mode) (save-excursion (org-map-entries '(lambda () (let ((alltags (split-string (or (org-entry-get (point) ALLTAGS) ) :)) local inherited tag) (dolist (tag alltags) (if (get-text-property 0 'inherited tag) (push tag inherited) (push tag local))) (dolist (tag local) (if (member tag inherited) (org-toggle-tag tag 'off) t nil --8---cut here---end---8--- The problem seems to be that `org-map-entries' return a sequence of `nil'. I tried Edebugging it, but Edebug does not jump into the execution of the anonymous function... Best regards, Seb -- Sebastien Vauban
Re: [O] Remove redundant tags of headlines
Sebastien Vauban sva-news-D0wtAvR13HarG/idocf...@public.gmane.org writes: I tried Edebugging it, but Edebug does not jump into the execution of the anonymous function... Just give a name to the anonymous function... and you're back on edebugging. :) -- Bastien
