Re: EMC Prosecution in UK - Safety??? Saving money on Enforcement

2002-09-28 Thread Alan E Hutley
Hi Greg

The newly formed EMC Industries Association www.emcia.org is already in contact 
with UK Trading Standards and will be offering seminars.

With regards to the threads on test houses Greg Galluccio and others I will 
find out more about the details of this product.
Will also seek comments from an eminent UK lawyer on these matters. (but I will 
not be paying him)

Cheers
Alan E Hutley
EMC Compliance Journal
www.compliance-club.com
 
  - Original Message - 
  From: Gregg Kervill 
  To: 'Emc-Pstc Discussion Group' 
  Sent: Friday, September 27, 2002 5:17 PM
  Subject: RE: EMC Prosecution in UK - Safety??? Saving money on Enforcement


  There have been many good issues raised in this thread - in particular the 
issue of 'bad' case-law being set. I remember a very good UK lawyer friend of 
mine predicting that initial case-law would be suspect and based upon 
incomplete knowledge and understanding of the issues. And that until cases were 
taken to the High Court where a knowledgeable technical defense was made the 
law would remain unsound.

   

  HOWEVER.  If the product failed EMC I would bet a dollar to a doughnut that 
it would also fail safety!

   

  I also know that in some countries there are few resources for training 
Enforcement Officer and therefore I will offer to make a short 
multimedia-training program available (free of charge) to ANY Eu Enforcement 
Officer that contacts me directly.

   

  EMC requires expensive testing equipment - BUT most Product Safety 
non-compliances can be identified with a physical inspection. - Hence this is 
an opportunity for the enforcement services to save money.

   

   

   

   

  Best regards

   

  Gregg

  Gregg Kervill DipIM, MIMgt, MIEEE

  VP Engineering
  Test4Safety.com Inc
  PO Box 310, 
  Reedville, VA 
  22539. USA

  Phone  ( 804) 453-3141 
  Fax(804) 453-9039

  http://www.test4safety.com/

   

   



RE: EMC Prosecution in UK - Safety??? Saving money on Enforcement

2002-09-27 Thread Gregg Kervill
There have been many good issues raised in this thread – in particular the
issue of ‘bad’ case-law being set. I remember a very good UK lawyer friend
of mine predicting that initial case-law would be suspect and based upon
incomplete knowledge and understanding of the issues. And that until cases
were taken to the High Court where a knowledgeable technical defense was
made the law would remain unsound.

HOWEVER.  If the product failed EMC I would bet a dollar to a doughnut that
it would also fail safety!

I also know that in some countries there are few resources for training
Enforcement Officer and therefore I will offer to make a short
multimedia-training program available (free of charge) to ANY Eu Enforcement
Officer that contacts me directly.

EMC requires expensive testing equipment – BUT most Product Safety
non-compliances can be identified with a physical inspection. – Hence this
is an opportunity for the enforcement services to save money.




Best regards

Gregg
Gregg Kervill DipIM, MIMgt, MIEEE
mailto:gr...@test4safety.com?subject=Valid%20Reply
VP Engineering
Test4Safety.com Inc
PO Box 310,
Reedville, VA
22539. USA mailto:gr...@test4safety.com?subject=Valid%20Reply
Phone  ( 804) 453-3141
Fax(804) 453-9039
mailto:gr...@test4safety.com?subject=Valid%20Reply
http://www.test4safety.com/
mailto:gr...@test4safety.com?subject=Valid%20Reply