[Finale] finale percussion rip-off of ghent font?

2012-07-04 Thread SN jef chippewa

the finale percussion font is clearly based on -- 
some characters seem to be identical to -- ron 
caltibiano's ghent font.  i have seen no mention 
of this having been purchased anywhere, or, if it 
was indeed purchased by makemusic, no credit 
given to the developer.

of course when a corporation buys your work you 
don't always get the right of recognition in 
return, and maybe i am just being naïve, but i 
would have expected at least a mention somewhere. 
a search for ghent in the user manual brings up 
the finale percussion page as the only hit, but 
only because two symbols use the word ghent in 
their description, in reference to the notation 
conference, not the developer.

corporation buys individual; individual can go suck eggs.

nice one, makemusic.


___
Finale mailing list
Finale@shsu.edu
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale


Re: [Finale] finale percussion rip-off of ghent font?

2012-07-04 Thread Jari Williamsson
On 2012-07-04 14:26, SN jef chippewa wrote:

 the finale percussion font is clearly based on --
 some characters seem to be identical to -- ron
 caltibiano's ghent font.  i have seen no mention
 of this having been purchased anywhere, or, if it
 was indeed purchased by makemusic, no credit
 given to the developer.

MM can license it without the things mentioned above. Do you see any 
mention of my name regarding the Space Systems plug-in in Fin2012?


Best regards,

Jari Williamsson

___
Finale mailing list
Finale@shsu.edu
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale


Re: [Finale] finale percussion rip-off of ghent font?

2012-07-04 Thread SN jef chippewa

MM can license it without the things mentioned 
above. Do you see any mention of my name 
regarding the Space Systems plug-in in Fin2012?

sure, but i don't have to agree with this way of 
doing things.  and i do see a TGTools menu in the 
default PI bundle... MM could acknowledge it 
somewhere, i simply think that is good business 
policy.

i suppose that in the end, it is what you 
negotiate, if you are in the position of doing 
so.  for example, my name and weblink, as well as 
that of the artist who drew the hands from photos 
i took, appear in the new edition of pression 
(lachenmann) that is coming out this month.

in notations 21, i was in fact the person who 
coordinated getting the brice pauset and mathias 
spahlinger examples in the book and simply didn't 
take care to make sure i got mentioned as the 
copyist / designer (i assumed it would be... 
silly, naïve little jeffy).  it would be very 
relevant because the book was about graphic 
notation, not about publishing.

in the case of pauset it is particularly absurd, 
because the example is a page i prepared when 
working on my spacing prefs for new music and 
despite discussions about me making a new version 
of the score, it never came to be; the only 
published example is hand-written, the version 
you can see in notations 21 exists *only* as a 
private example of my work.

--

one summer in a music library job, i took example 
from the book publishing industry, where in good 
editions even the typesetter is mentioned.  i 
started including a copyright page on the 
backside of the title page for various kinds of 
information, because i believe the production of 
the score is dependent on everyone who 
contributed, not just the publisher, to whom the 
composer has signed over their distribution 
rights.

my copyright pages list:
work title, composer name, ensemble type (string trio; large ensemble)
- commissioner
- performers of the premiere
- any agency that somehow contributed (commissioning / festival grant etc.)
- significant awards the piece has won
- copyist

in addition to simply recognizing and documenting 
properly, librarians sometimes have extreme 
difficulty processing music scores if they are 
unfamiliar with the work / composer.

also this way the musicians that come across the 
score immediately have some information about the 
history and context of the piece.


___
Finale mailing list
Finale@shsu.edu
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale