Re: [Foundation-l] Board statement on Wikimedia trademarks

2009-05-04 Thread Florence Devouard
Robert Rohde wrote:
 On Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 9:37 AM, Florence Devouard anthe...@yahoo.com wrote:
 Michael Snow wrote:
 This is the statement on trademarks mentioned earlier. It both states
 the approach we want the Wikimedia Foundation to take and directs the
 staff to carry it out. It basically sums up what our understanding has
 been for a long time, but hadn't really been formally stated anywhere.
 The board also voted unanimously to approve this. The statement follows:

 The Wikimedia Foundation is committed to enabling our mission through a
 wide network of chapters, community members, and organizational partners
 who are all able to better achieve their goals by identifying themselves
 with the Wikimedia community. Because of these efforts, there is a large
 amount of value and goodwill associated with the name and marks.
 Trademark law in the United States and internationally requires that the
 holder of a mark take affirmative steps to protect the integrity of the
 mark. However, because of our commitment to openness and community
 empowerment, we wish to do this in a way that allows chapters and
 community members to be able to continue to identify themselves with
 Wikimedia marks without being unnecessarily restrictive.

 Because of this, we ask the Wikimedia staff to take appropriate steps to
 register and protect the Wikimedia marks, develop a set of policies and
 practices, and develop a strategy to allow uses by the chapters and
 community for activities in line with the Wikimedia mission.

 --Michael Snow
 Thank you Board.

 Ant

 
 I'd also like to express my thanks.  Not having any usage guidelines
 for most Wikimedia marks has been a pet peeve of mine for, oh, 3-4
 years now.
 
 -Robert Rohde

Hold on Robert.

Michael provided us with the wish of the board.

That does not mean that this is done.
That does not warranty either that the implementation proposed by the 
staff actually follow the guidelines offered by the board.
We are still a LONG way before actually seeing usage guidelines that 
would enable community and chapters to further our common mission.
But at least, the board statement is a start.

Since community elections are next corner, I guess this topic will have 
to come back on the plate very soon.

Ant



PS: see also

http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Mission
The mission of the Wikimedia Foundation is to empower and engage people 
around the world to collect and develop educational content under a free 
license or in the public domain, and to disseminate it effectively and 
globally.
In collaboration with a network of chapters, the Foundation provides the 
essential infrastructure and an organizational framework for the support 
and development of multilingual wiki projects and other endeavors which 
serve this mission. The Foundation will make and keep useful information 
from its projects available on the Internet free of charge, in perpetuity.


http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Values

Freedom
An essential part of the Wikimedia Foundation's mission is encouraging 
the development of free-content educational resources that may be 
created, used, and reused by the entire human community. We believe that 
this mission requires thriving open formats and open standards on the 
web to allow the creation of content not subject to restrictions on 
creation, use, and reuse.
At the creation level, we want to provide the editing community with 
freely-licensed tools for participation and collaboration. Our community 
should also have the freedom to fork thanks to freely available dumps.
The community will in turn create a body of knowledge which can be 
distributed freely throughout the world, viewable or playable by free 
software tools.

Accessibility and quality
All the legal freedom to modify or distribute educational content is 
useless if users cannot get access to it.
We try our best to give online access to high quality Wikimedia project 
content 24 hours a day and 7 days a week, as well as provide access to 
regularly updated, user-friendly, and free dumps of Wikimedia project 
content.
We try, through partnerships if necessary, to ensure the widest 
distribution, through DVD's, books, PDF's, or other non-internet based 
means.
To ensure world-wide, unrestricted, dissemination of knowledge, we do 
not enter into exclusive partnerships, with regards to access to our 
content or use of our trademarks.

Independence
As a non-profit, we mostly depend on gifts to operate (donations, 
grants, sponsorship, etc.). It is very important to us to ensure our 
organization stays free of influence in the way it operates. For this 
reason, we strictly follow a donation policy, reserve the right to 
refuse donations which could generate constraints, and try to multiply 
the diversity of revenue sources.

Commitment to openness and diversity
Though US-based, the organization is international in its nature. Our 
board of trustees, staff members, and volunteers are involved without 

Re: [Foundation-l] Board statement on Wikimedia trademarks

2009-05-04 Thread Andre Engels
On Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 8:27 AM, Michael Snow wikipe...@verizon.net wrote:

 Because of this, we ask the Wikimedia staff to take appropriate steps to
 register and protect the Wikimedia marks, develop a set of policies and
 practices, and develop a strategy to allow uses by the chapters and
 community for activities in line with the Wikimedia mission.

I agree with the first part about registering and protecting the
trademarks, but would not 'developing a set of policies [...] and a
strategy' be more logically something the board does itself, or at
least is actively involved in?


-- 
André Engels, andreeng...@gmail.com

___
foundation-l mailing list
foundation-l@lists.wikimedia.org
Unsubscribe: https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/foundation-l


Re: [Foundation-l] Board statement on Wikimedia trademarks

2009-05-04 Thread Robert Rohde
On Mon, May 4, 2009 at 3:04 AM, Florence Devouard anthe...@yahoo.com wrote:
 Hold on Robert.

 Michael provided us with the wish of the board.
snip

After so many years they get my thanks simply by calling attention to
this as an issue of concern.  I realize there is still more to do, but
this increases my confidence that maybe someone on the inside actually
cares.

-Robert

___
foundation-l mailing list
foundation-l@lists.wikimedia.org
Unsubscribe: https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/foundation-l


Re: [Foundation-l] Board statement on Wikimedia trademarks

2009-05-01 Thread Robert Rohde
On Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 9:37 AM, Florence Devouard anthe...@yahoo.com wrote:
 Michael Snow wrote:
 This is the statement on trademarks mentioned earlier. It both states
 the approach we want the Wikimedia Foundation to take and directs the
 staff to carry it out. It basically sums up what our understanding has
 been for a long time, but hadn't really been formally stated anywhere.
 The board also voted unanimously to approve this. The statement follows:

 The Wikimedia Foundation is committed to enabling our mission through a
 wide network of chapters, community members, and organizational partners
 who are all able to better achieve their goals by identifying themselves
 with the Wikimedia community. Because of these efforts, there is a large
 amount of value and goodwill associated with the name and marks.
 Trademark law in the United States and internationally requires that the
 holder of a mark take affirmative steps to protect the integrity of the
 mark. However, because of our commitment to openness and community
 empowerment, we wish to do this in a way that allows chapters and
 community members to be able to continue to identify themselves with
 Wikimedia marks without being unnecessarily restrictive.

 Because of this, we ask the Wikimedia staff to take appropriate steps to
 register and protect the Wikimedia marks, develop a set of policies and
 practices, and develop a strategy to allow uses by the chapters and
 community for activities in line with the Wikimedia mission.

 --Michael Snow

 Thank you Board.

 Ant


I'd also like to express my thanks.  Not having any usage guidelines
for most Wikimedia marks has been a pet peeve of mine for, oh, 3-4
years now.

-Robert Rohde

___
foundation-l mailing list
foundation-l@lists.wikimedia.org
Unsubscribe: https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/foundation-l