Release process ( Was Re: [vote] Request approval to declare Woden 1.0.0 M3 Candidate by EOD Jan. 24)
In http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/incubator-general/200601.mbox/[EMAIL PROTECTED] Roy T. Fielding wrote: On Jan 24, 2006, at 3:50 PM, Lawrence Mandel wrote: Sanjiva, Sorry about violating Apache netiquette. This was not intentional. I had previously been asked to send this vote to the incubator and ws pmc lists and was advised to send it to the [EMAIL PROTECTED] list as well. To be honest, I'm feeling pretty lost wrt the correct process to release a milestone driver from an incubator project and would appreciate guidance from the community. The information I have is to: 1. Hold a vote amongst the project's committers on the project's mailing list. 2. Request approval from the incubator and, in Woden's case, WS pmcs by sending an e-mail requesting a vote to [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], and [EMAIL PROTECTED] All release votes must be made on public lists. Even if people say yes in private, they still need to vote in public. So, you should hold a vote on woden-dev and then send a summary of that vote to [EMAIL PROTECTED], saying pointedly that you need X more +1 votes from incubator PMC members within 72 hours. Assuming no negative votes, the milestone can be released. Minimum three binding (official PMC) +1 votes and a majority of all votes being positive. Releases do not need consensus. I logged INCUBATOR-14 to remind myself to improve the info at http://incubator.apache.org/incubation/Incubation_Policy.html#Releases . I think even a little more clarification in this section would be helpful. I'll start a [doc] thread for this after the Incubator site conversion [1] settles down. (Existence of the Jira issue will keep me from forgetting.) -jean [1] http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/incubator-general/200601.mbox/[EMAIL PROTECTED] - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [vote] Request approval to declare Woden 1.0.0 M3 Candidate by EOD Jan. 24
+1 from me Paul On 1/25/06, Roy T. Fielding [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Jan 24, 2006, at 3:50 PM, Lawrence Mandel wrote: Sanjiva, Sorry about violating Apache netiquette. This was not intentional. I had previously been asked to send this vote to the incubator and ws pmc lists and was advised to send it to the [EMAIL PROTECTED] list as well. To be honest, I'm feeling pretty lost wrt the correct process to release a milestone driver from an incubator project and would appreciate guidance from the community. The information I have is to: 1. Hold a vote amongst the project's committers on the project's mailing list. 2. Request approval from the incubator and, in Woden's case, WS pmcs by sending an e-mail requesting a vote to [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], and [EMAIL PROTECTED] All release votes must be made on public lists. Even if people say yes in private, they still need to vote in public. So, you should hold a vote on woden-dev and then send a summary of that vote to [EMAIL PROTECTED], saying pointedly that you need X more +1 votes from incubator PMC members within 72 hours. Assuming no negative votes, the milestone can be released. Minimum three binding (official PMC) +1 votes and a majority of all votes being positive. Releases do not need consensus. Roy - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] -- Paul Fremantle VP/Technology, WSO2 and OASIS WS-RX TC Co-chair http://bloglines.com/blog/paulfremantle [EMAIL PROTECTED] Oxygenating the Web Service Platform, www.wso2.com
[vote] Request approval to declare Woden 1.0.0 M3 Candidate by EOD Jan. 24
*note: I'm resending this message as I don't believe it showed up on [EMAIL PROTECTED] Lawrence Mandel Following the release process for projects in incubation, I'd like to request approval for Woden to declare milestone 3. A vote was held on the woden-dev list where M3 received 5 +1 votes and no negative votes. The votes collected are as follows: John Kaputin +1 Lawrence Mandel +1 Dims +1 Jeremy Hughes +1 Arthur Ryman +1 As required of releases from projects in incubation, the distributable archives contain incubating in their names. The M3 archives can be found at http://cvs.apache.org/dist/ws/woden/milestones/1.0.0M3-incubating/. My original post summarizing Woden 1.0.0 M3 is below. Please vote by 5pm EST, Tuesday, Jan. 24, 2006. Thanks, Lawrence Mandel - Forwarded by Lawrence Mandel/Toronto/IBM on 01/22/2006 03:22 PM - Lawrence Mandel/Toronto/[EMAIL PROTECTED] 01/18/2006 04:55 PM Please respond to woden-dev To woden-dev@ws.apache.org cc [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject Woden 1.0.0 M3 Candidate - please vote by EOD Thursday, Jan. 19 Woden committers, I'd like to request your vote on the status of M3. I've placed a Woden 1.0.0 M3 Candidate build at http://cvs.apache.org/dist/ws/woden/milestones/1.0.0M3-incubating/ The Woden M3 candidate includes the major work items from the M3 plan. Specifically, the following items are complete in the M3 Candidate: Parsing of WSDL 2.0 import and include (DOM) WSDL 2.0 Service parsing (DOM) Implement validation logic for Binding Unit tests for validation logic for Binding Integrate W3C WSDL 2.0 Binding tests into Woden test suite The following items are incomplete in the M2 plan: Unit tests for import and include parsing (DOM) WSDL 2.0 HTTP Binding extension (DOM) Unit tests for HTTP Binding extension (DOM) Unit tests for Service parsing (DOM) Investigate WSDL 2.0 parsing with StAX Update technical documentation about Woden design and implementation on Wiki Create initial user documentation In an effort to make Woden more immediately usable, we deferred HTTP Binding extension work to M4 in favour of adding support for WSDL import and include elements. StAX will continue to be an investigation item until the DOM implementation is close to complete or we get more development help. John and I are working on user documentation and should have it ready for the Woden site around the proposed M3 release on Friday. Automated tests for the parser continue to require attention but, as John has conducted manual testing and the W3C test suite has been integrated into the Woden automated test suite, we are in good shape for M3. Both John and I think Woden is in good shape to declare M3 as solid progress has been made on the parser and the validator. At this point we'd like to ask the Woden committers to vote on the status of M3. John and I both vote +1 (so +2). Please vote ASAP. We will collect votes until EOD (5pm EST) Thursday, Jan. 19. If there are no negative votes I will then request WS and Incubator PMC approval to release M3 by EOD Friday, Jan. 20. Once the PMCs approve, M3 will be declared and a link will be placed on the Woden site. (Feel free to reply to this note with any concerns over this process.) Thanks, Lawrence Mandel
Re: [vote] Request approval to declare Woden 1.0.0 M3 Candidate by EOD Jan. 24
Sanjiva, Sorry about violating Apache netiquette. This was not intentional. I had previously been asked to send this vote to the incubator and ws pmc lists and was advised to send it to the [EMAIL PROTECTED] list as well. To be honest, I'm feeling pretty lost wrt the correct process to release a milestone driver from an incubator project and would appreciate guidance from the community. The information I have is to: 1. Hold a vote amongst the project's committers on the project's mailing list. 2. Request approval from the incubator and, in Woden's case, WS pmcs by sending an e-mail requesting a vote to [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], and [EMAIL PROTECTED] Assuming no negative votes, the milestone can be released. I think it would be useful to formally declare this process on the incubator site so all incubator projects have a defined process to follow. BTW, as you said that my mail did make it to [EMAIL PROTECTED] and [EMAIL PROTECTED], have you seen any replies? I have yet to see one. Thanks, Lawrence Mandel Sanjiva Weerawarana [EMAIL PROTECTED] 01/24/2006 06:40 PM Please respond to woden-dev To general@incubator.apache.org cc woden-dev@ws.apache.org woden-dev@ws.apache.org Subject Re: [vote] Request approval to declare Woden 1.0.0 M3 Candidate by EOD Jan. 24 On Tue, 2006-01-24 at 13:54 -0500, Lawrence Mandel wrote: *note: I'm resending this message as I don't believe it showed up on [EMAIL PROTECTED] Lawrence please don't send to general@ and a private list (the PMC lists). That's against Apache email netiquette .. Unless I am mistaken your mail did make it to [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sanjiva. - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
