Re: Value in histogram

2001-02-08 Thread Nick Lamb

On Thu, Feb 08, 2001 at 01:36:10PM +0100, Roel Schroeven wrote:
 The value in the gimp histogram is calculated as the maximum of the red,
 green and blue channels now. Wouldn't it be better to use the average of the
 three color channels?

We discussed this when I was fixing the histogram for 1.2.x BRANCH (btw,
did that fix go into 1.2.1, or did it just rot? Maybe I should look for
myself) and I can't remember what the arguments were for leaving it as
it is, but that's what we decided to do in 1.2 at least.

Nick.



Re: Value in histogram

2001-02-08 Thread Sven Neumann

Hi,

Nick Lamb [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:

 On Thu, Feb 08, 2001 at 01:36:10PM +0100, Roel Schroeven wrote:
  The value in the gimp histogram is calculated as the maximum of the red,
  green and blue channels now. Wouldn't it be better to use the average of the
  three color channels?
 
 We discussed this when I was fixing the histogram for 1.2.x BRANCH (btw,
 did that fix go into 1.2.1, or did it just rot? Maybe I should look for
 myself) and I can't remember what the arguments were for leaving it as
 it is, but that's what we decided to do in 1.2 at least.

Well, max (r,g,b) is the correct formula for calculating the value of a 
color (assuming that value corresponds to the V in HSV). The average of the 
three channels is a somewhat useless number, but it might make sense to add 
intensity (mostly defined as 0.3 r + 0.59 g + 0.11 b) as an option.


Salut, Sven