RE: Ok this is a stupid questions

2019-02-26 Thread Michael Holly
Hello

As a follow up to my previous post,  let me emphasize the size expansion is not 
related to the compression that is applied during encryption.  My issue is that 
I have files that are being transferred to me, and for a cause that I am trying 
to track down, gpg begins to decrypt before the file has fully arrived.  From 
my perspective it appears to send gpg into a tailspin.  The process seems to be 
able to continue for a week or more and does not seem to complete.

>From a design perspective, I expect the usual replies of "if that is not what 
>you want to do then don't do it".   Yes I know. What I am looking to do is to 
>be able to understand why it goes into this race condition instead of erroring 
>out.
My ask of the gpg listers, is has anyone ever seen this behavior?


From: Michael Holly
Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 8:14 AM
To: gnupg-users@gnupg.org
Subject: Ok this is a stupid questions

So I completely preface this question is not a valid use case for gpg.  I know, 
I get it.

I have a potential issue that I'm trying to diagnose.  I'm trying to understand 
how gpg will react to the input file size changing during the encrypt or 
decrypt step.

Right now it appears that the gpg process goes a bit crazy and the 200 MB file 
I am decrypting becomes 1.2 TB or greater.

Here is the order of the events


1.   File lands on my system.

2.   PGP decrypt is invoked on the file.

3.   Since the file is not truly done being sent to me, the file grows in 
size.

4.   GPG seems to expand the decrypted file many times over.

What I suspect is that instead of erroring out, GPG starts the decrypt process 
over and appends the new output to the previous cycle..   I have not tested 
this, but will soon.

I just wanted to see if anyone else has seen this happen.

Thanks

Michael






___
Gnupg-users mailing list
Gnupg-users@gnupg.org
http://lists.gnupg.org/mailman/listinfo/gnupg-users


Ok this is a stupid questions

2019-02-25 Thread Michael Holly
So I completely preface this question is not a valid use case for gpg.  I know, 
I get it.

I have a potential issue that I'm trying to diagnose.  I'm trying to understand 
how gpg will react to the input file size changing during the encrypt or 
decrypt step.

Right now it appears that the gpg process goes a bit crazy and the 200 MB file 
I am decrypting becomes 1.2 TB or greater.

Here is the order of the events


1.   File lands on my system.

2.   PGP decrypt is invoked on the file.

3.   Since the file is not truly done being sent to me, the file grows in 
size.

4.   GPG seems to expand the decrypted file many times over.

What I suspect is that instead of erroring out, GPG starts the decrypt process 
over and appends the new output to the previous cycle..   I have not tested 
this, but will soon.

I just wanted to see if anyone else has seen this happen.

Thanks

Michael






___
Gnupg-users mailing list
Gnupg-users@gnupg.org
http://lists.gnupg.org/mailman/listinfo/gnupg-users