Re: [Goanet]An essay on legalising Prostitution - from Non-Trivial.Com

2003-10-01 Thread Frederick Noronha (FN)
On Wed, 1 Oct 2003, Floriano wrote:

 I used to like to read  the New Testament in my younger days.
 And I may be wrong, but I think there is a passage therein, somewheres which
 says something to this effect.
 
 If you are passing by your neighbour's house, and the neighbour's wife
 should be beckoning to you.  Do not fall for the trap, for it is sin. You
 might as well pay for the services of a prostitute.

Just since the issue was raised:

Jesus told a group of his countrymen in the temple that
the hated tax-collector and the despised harlots would
enter the kingdom of God before they did (Matt, 21:31).

In the parable of the prodigal son (Luke 15), Jesus has
the older brother complain that the wayward son had
spent his time, money, and energy on harlots (15:30).

For Paul, prostitutes are listed with immoral people
(1 Cor. 6:14 f.)

The story of Rahab the harlot was used by Christian
writers as a model of a person who was saved by faith
and by works (James 2: 25-26).

Having noted this, this issue has nothing to do with religion, and is 
connected with what approach we take towards a social concern, one that 
concerns the human rights of a couple of thousand women.

If one recalls right the issue started with Cyp's query on what kind of 
support would help to solve the problem at Baina. We seem to have moved 
far from it

What one could perhaps ask is whether anyone discussing this issue has 
actually been to see the situation at Baina? Neither the Goan chauvinism 
(they're non-Goans, so by definition, not our problem) nor the 
legalise-and-get-done-with-it approach seems anywhere relevant to the 
ground level reality. Hats off to people like the nuns from Sancoale, for 
whom living their belief doesn't mean just a few pious statements, but 
living in the grime and squalour to work towards finding a solution. 

Anyone interested in getting a better understanding could also check with 
the ARZ team, which works with children in the area, and has its office 
right in the midst of this area. FN

##
# Send submissions for Goanet to [EMAIL PROTECTED]   #   
# PLEASE remember to stay on-topic (related to Goa), and avoid top-posts #
# More details on Goanet at http://joingoanet.shorturl.com/  #  
# Please keep your discussion/tone polite, to reflect respect to others  #
##


Re: [Goanet]An essay on legalising Prostitution - from Non-Trivial.Com

2003-10-01 Thread Floriano
I used to like to read  the New Testament in my younger days.
And I may be wrong, but I think there is a passage therein, somewheres which
says something to this effect.

If you are passing by your neighbour's house, and the neighbour's wife
should be beckoning to you.  Do not fall for the trap, for it is sin. You
might as well pay for the services of a prostitute.

No offence meant , nor this is meant to hurt any religious feelings. Those
of you who are bible readers may correct me if I am wrong.

Cheers Floriano.

- Original Message -
From: Cecil Pinto [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Wednesday, October 01, 2003 7:43 PM
Subject: [Goanet]An essay on legalising Prostitution - from Non-Trivial.Com


 I don't use prostitutes. Yet, I find it a fascinating topic. I have been
 wondering why I am so interested. I have finally come up with these
reasons:

 - I have an incurable admiration for sexually liberated women.




##
# Send submissions for Goanet to [EMAIL PROTECTED]   #   
# PLEASE remember to stay on-topic (related to Goa), and avoid top-posts #
# More details on Goanet at http://joingoanet.shorturl.com/  #  
# Please keep your discussion/tone polite, to reflect respect to others  #
##


[Goanet]An essay on legalising Prostitution - from Non-Trivial.Com

2003-10-01 Thread Cecil Pinto
I don't use prostitutes. Yet, I find it a fascinating topic. I have been 
wondering why I am so interested. I have finally come up with these reasons:

- I have an incurable admiration for sexually liberated women.

- Prostitutes typically fit that description. If they were not comfortable 
with sex, it would be highly unlikely that they would try to turn it into a 
profession.

- The concept makes sense. I look around, and I see many people craving 
good sex.

- In these times of rampant hypocrisy, there is something refreshing, 
genuine, almost admirable about a prostitute.

- A prostitute is the antithesis of a hypocrite. A prostitute make no 
claims of being morally right. But what you see is what you get. Sometimes, 
the customers are the hypocrites. And quite often, people in power who are 
prosecuting prostitutes, are hypocrites.

- Prostitution, at least at the upper end of the scale, is about glamour. 
In some forms, it is only a step away from modeling. I believe it is Gucci, 
who ran ads in Elle, showing prostitutes walking the streets. Glamour is 
fascinating.

- Prostitution is as old as the world. Yet, these days, it is suddenly an 
idea whose time has come again.

A Few Thoughts

In its most basic form, prostitution is nothing but a contract between 
consenting people. A contract to provide sex in exchange for payment.

Since sex is not inherently immoral, and neither is the exchange of money, 
prostitution is not inherently immoral.

It has been said that prostitution is as old as the world. It has also been 
said that prostitution occurs between animals; it has been observed amongst 
chimpanzees and penguins.

Some marriages involve a situation where one party provides most of the 
money, and the other party is expected to consent to sex. In some cases, 
very little sex is exchanged for access to a lot of money.

Divorce is not illegal. But in many cases, divorce is immoral.

In some marriages, the use of prostitutes by one of the spouses, is 
tolerated by the other spouse. The prostitute provides a function one of 
the spouses is not willing to provide. The prostitute is not much different 
from the maid.

This used to be quite common in the upper classes of more traditional 
societies, like traditional Europe, England, South-America and even the 
American South. In all cases, respectable women were not encouraged to be 
too expert or knowledgeable about sex. It was widely considered more 
convenient if husbands who could afford it, went looking for it somewhere 
else.

The Need

Prostitution does fulfill an identifiable societal function. In some cases, 
it can be a substitute for psychological or marriage counseling. It might 
even prevent divorce. Although usually an imperfect solution, it can be a 
cost- effective one. Shrinks are expensive. So are lawyers and settlements.

Prostitution provides a safety valve against frustration, especially for 
people who are not attractive or have few social skills. Also in couples 
that have very different sex drives and might otherwise be headed for 
affairs or divorce.

Prostitution tends to be prevalent in societies where sex is repressed. It 
was quite popular in Victorian England.

Closer to home, in a society where sexual advances can carry very negative 
legal consequences, in a society where an exposed marital infidelity can 
destroy a career, prostitution should be expected to become an alternative 
of choice.

The fact that prostitution is illegal, may sometimes encourage it. It 
guarantees a measure of anonymity and silence, which may not otherwise be 
feasible.

Oversexed Males and Undersexed Females

In most cases, prostitutes tend to be women, while clients tend to be men. 
This may be partially due to the fact that men may have easier access to 
money. But it probably also means that in this society, there is a deficit 
of sexually available females with respect to sexually needy males.

Changing Perceptions

It used to be that prostitution was for losers. For those men who could not 
find a woman in any other way. Using a prostitute was something nobody 
would normally admit to.
That perception is changing. I was at a party the other day, with some very 
promising young lawyers (as well as a number of attractive women). One 
lawyer was talking to the other: Hey, let's go to Vancouver next weekend, 
and see some girls...

Why Illegal?

The justification for making prostitution illegal, usually has to do with 
the protection of women, and the control of sexually transmitted diseases. 
That could make sense if as a result of the law, prostitution completely 
ceased to exist.

In practice however, the fact that prostitution is illegal, normally 
results in the exploitation or abuse of prostitutes, and does contribute to 
the spread of sexually transmitted diseases.

Illegal prostitutes may be the target of violence or rape, and will be 
hesitant to contact the police. Or else, they may simply disappear, and 
nobody may ever know.