Re: [Goanet] RACISTS! - WHO? by Fr. Cedric Prakash, sj

2009-06-04 Thread Gabriel de Figueiredo

The truth is that for a few years now, since 1999 when State govt changed from 
Liberal (conservative-equivalent) to Labor (they removed the U from Labour in 
more ways than one), discipline and policing went down the drain in Victoria 
(for those who don't know, Melbourne is the capital of the State of Victoria).  
We had a Police chief, an import from New South Wales, who followed a softly, 
softly approach, which, IMHO, led to this degeneration. 

It just happens that a few of the attacked, in recent days, happened to be 
Indians.  A couple of years ago the AMA (Australian Medical Association) 
ex-president, Dr Mukherjea, was attacked at late hours of the night as he was 
returning to his car after withdrawing money from an ATM - he was one of the 
six attacked that night by the same gang. Other people attacked were of 
different backgrounds 
(http://www.theage.com.au/national/bashed-doctors-prognosis-positive-20080930-4qrl.html ).
 There were no racial overtones to the attack - just senseless, opportunistic 
sadism or persons high on drugs IMHO.  

Recent attacks were similar.  In fact the attackers in a case that took place 
recently in a train were not Anglo-saxons, but appear to be of Pacific-Islander 
origin (short, broad-shouldered). There are notorious areas around Melbourne, 
and a number of attackers in certain parts have African origins, others have 
anglo-saxon roots, and yet others, Middle-eastern.  And anyone can get 
attacked. Proliferation of mobile phones and the ease with which one can 
group-SMS has made piranha attacks easy and unsettlingly common-place 
(Brazilians know what piranha attacks are - in Rio, I understand that all of 
a sudden a person can get surrounded and robbed of everything - not even 
sparing underwear - hence the term).  Recollecting the past, a colleague of 
mine who was studying architecture at JJ College in Bombay, also suffered a 
piranha attack in Bombay way back in 1982.  

AFAIK, the attacks in Melbourne are not racial - just opportunistic.  The 
idiots see a lone guy - most often oblivious to his surroundings as usually 
he's listening to his iPod, an then pounce on him.  

My advice, after being mugged in London by persons of different origins way 
back in 1980, is to be aware of what is happening around you. 

PS A few months back, a young Indian student just a couple of months in 
Melbourne, was run-over by a tram, as she crossed the tracks and didn't hear 
the tram approaching despite the dings of the tram-bell - she was busy 
listening to her iPod.  



- Original Message 
From: Prashant sjprash...@gmail.com
To: Prashant sjprash...@gmail.com
Sent: Tuesday, 2 June, 2009 10:07:09 PM
Subject: [Goanet] RACISTS! - WHO? by Fr. Cedric Prakash, sj


-
“RACISTS!” – WHO?

                                                                                
                *Fr. Cedric Prakash, sj



The cry could not have been shriller!  “You are racist!” was the message loud 
and clear, as thousands of Indians (mainly students) gathered in Melbourne, 
Australia, on Sunday, 31st May, to protest the wave of attacks on Indian 
students in various parts of Australia.  The protest was legitimate.  The 
growing feeling of insecurity was palpable and the genuine desire to live in a 
peaceful and integrated manner, in a multi-cultural society, can be denied by 
none.



At home, the media is definitely up in arms repeatedly highlighting the plight 
of Indian students in Australia.  There are heart rending visuals of those 
brutally bashed up.  The media are on the offensive and for good measure, yet 
another reality is made very emotive.  



Xenophobia, racism, segregation, apartheid, discrimination, in any form is non 
acceptable.  Civil society, all over the world needs to take a bold stand on 
this malaise and to nip it in the bud whenever its ugly head rears itself.  A 
case in point, is the way Raj Thackeray and his MNS have decided that those 
from UP and Bihar do not “belong” to Bombay.



In Gujarat, the lines of division are even more pronounced where the Muslims 
are concerned.  In several parts of the State, there are huge billboards 
erected which loudly proclaim a “Hindu Rashtra”.  In several cities and 
villages, across the State, Muslims have been confined to ghettoes or have to 
live in the peripheral areas.  Juhapura, on the outskirts of Ahmedabad is home 
to over four hundred thousand Muslims, which makes it one of the biggest Muslim 
ghettoes in the country.  Inspite of the people’s demands, there are hardly any 
public facilities and utilities for the citizens there.  Muslims in Gujarat are 
still treated as second class citizens with little or no access to quality 
education and employment opportunities. 



Christians too in many parts of Gujarat are subject to the same fate.  However, 
in the latter case, the intimidations and harassments are in more subtle 
forms.  Dalits in Gujarat still continue to live in a very marginalized 
situation

[Goanet] RACISTS! - WHO? by Fr. Cedric Prakash, sj

2009-06-04 Thread Dr. U. G. Barad
 

I feel the post by Fr Cedric trivializes the racist attacks being faced by
Indians in Australia.  He does this by bringing in issues relating to what
is happening in India, and asking for first putting our house in order.

 

On the same criteria, would it not be appropriate for India to ask other
countries to put their own house in order before criticizing India on
various issues?

 

I think it would have served Fr Cedric's agenda not to have written this
article.  If he had not, I do not think anyone on this list would have
noticed his silence.  But by writing it, he has exposed his agenda.

 

Best wishes

 

Dr U. G. Barad