Re: [H] memtest86+: How long?

2010-01-18 Thread Thane Sherrington

At 12:40 AM 1/16/2010, Anthony Q. Martin wrote:

It's been running now for 8 hours, 26 minutes, 5 passes, no errors.

Is there really any point in letting this run more?  It's testing 8 
GB of ram, those these runs take forever.  I can't image it would 
suddenly uncover some bad ram.


I never would have run this in the first place, but I did have one 
stick that was bad.  Prime96 and OCCT would uncover the bad ram 
immediately...it just took a bit of testing to isolate which stick 
was bad.  Once I found it and get a replacement stick, they then 
gave no further errors.  Now, after 8.5+ hours of memtest, I think 
this is ram should be blessed as ok.


Right?


I used to figure two complete passes was safe but I've since tested 
to 10 complete passes and found errors out on pass 7 and 9, so I'm 
not completely sold on MemTest.  But I'd base how long on number of 
passes rather than time.  The more you can live with, the more 
accurate.  I'd say 5 would be a bare minimum.


T 





Re: [H] memtest86+: How long?

2010-01-18 Thread Anthony Q. Martin
I think it unwise to use just one prog to determine anything. I finally 
did end up letting it run to 7 passes with the good ram before killing 
it...but both prime96 and OCCT bombed out almost immediately on the bad 
ram...whereas with 8 GB installed, it took memtest a while to find 
it...although it did find problems on the first pass (with the bad 
ram).  I think the ram I have in here now is fine.  How many systems get 
subjected to 10 passes of memtest anyhow?  8GB systems take forever with 
memtest86+.


On 1/18/2010 7:00 AM, Thane Sherrington wrote:

At 12:40 AM 1/16/2010, Anthony Q. Martin wrote:

It's been running now for 8 hours, 26 minutes, 5 passes, no errors.

Is there really any point in letting this run more?  It's testing 8 
GB of ram, those these runs take forever.  I can't image it would 
suddenly uncover some bad ram.


I never would have run this in the first place, but I did have one 
stick that was bad.  Prime96 and OCCT would uncover the bad ram 
immediately...it just took a bit of testing to isolate which stick 
was bad.  Once I found it and get a replacement stick, they then gave 
no further errors.  Now, after 8.5+ hours of memtest, I think this is 
ram should be blessed as ok.


Right?


I used to figure two complete passes was safe but I've since tested 
to 10 complete passes and found errors out on pass 7 and 9, so I'm not 
completely sold on MemTest.  But I'd base how long on number of passes 
rather than time.  The more you can live with, the more accurate.  I'd 
say 5 would be a bare minimum.


T



No virus found in this incoming message.
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
Version: 9.0.725 / Virus Database: 270.14.148/2629 - Release Date: 01/17/10 
14:35:00

   


Re: [H] memtest86+: How long?

2010-01-18 Thread Thane Sherrington

At 08:55 AM 1/18/2010, Anthony Q. Martin wrote:
I think it unwise to use just one prog to determine anything. I 
finally did end up letting it run to 7 passes with the good ram 
before killing it...but both prime96 and OCCT bombed out almost 
immediately on the bad ram...whereas with 8 GB installed, it took 
memtest a while to find it...although it did find problems on the 
first pass (with the bad ram).  I think the ram I have in here now 
is fine.  How many systems get subjected to 10 passes of memtest 
anyhow?  8GB systems take forever with memtest86+.


Depends on how important getting a good test is. :)  If you are 
getting faster fail results with Prime96 and OCCT, then I'd use those.


T 





Re: [H] memtest86+: How long?

2010-01-18 Thread Anthony Q. Martin
Yes. For example, when trying to track down the bad stick of ram, either 
prime95 or OCCT were best as they crashed immediately. However, once you 
get the good/bad sticks sorted out, it's probably best to let them all 
run for many hours in the hope to have the best chances of ending up 
with a perfectly stable system.


On 1/18/2010 11:30 AM, Thane Sherrington wrote:

At 08:55 AM 1/18/2010, Anthony Q. Martin wrote:
I think it unwise to use just one prog to determine anything. I 
finally did end up letting it run to 7 passes with the good ram 
before killing it...but both prime96 and OCCT bombed out almost 
immediately on the bad ram...whereas with 8 GB installed, it took 
memtest a while to find it...although it did find problems on the 
first pass (with the bad ram).  I think the ram I have in here now is 
fine.  How many systems get subjected to 10 passes of memtest 
anyhow?  8GB systems take forever with memtest86+.


Depends on how important getting a good test is. :)  If you are 
getting faster fail results with Prime96 and OCCT, then I'd use those.


T



No virus found in this incoming message.
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
Version: 9.0.730 / Virus Database: 270.14.149/2630 - Release Date: 01/18/10 
02:35:00

   


Re: [H] memtest86+: How long?

2010-01-18 Thread Joe User
Hello Anthony,

Friday, January 15, 2010, 10:40:13 PM, you wrote:

 further errors.  Now, after 8.5+ hours of memtest, I think this is ram
 should be blessed as ok.

 Right?


I let it run for a day minimum, but if there is a transient issue...

-- 
Regards,
 joeuser - Still looking for the 'any' key...

...now these points of data make a beautiful line...



[H] memtest86+: How long?

2010-01-15 Thread Anthony Q. Martin

It's been running now for 8 hours, 26 minutes, 5 passes, no errors.

Is there really any point in letting this run more?  It's testing 8 GB 
of ram, those these runs take forever.  I can't image it would suddenly 
uncover some bad ram.


I never would have run this in the first place, but I did have one stick 
that was bad.  Prime96 and OCCT would uncover the bad ram 
immediately...it just took a bit of testing to isolate which stick was 
bad.  Once I found it and get a replacement stick, they then gave no 
further errors.  Now, after 8.5+ hours of memtest, I think this is ram 
should be blessed as ok.


Right?



Re: [H] memtest86+: How long?

2010-01-15 Thread tmservo
I'd assume so.  Newest version of memtest?
Sent via BlackBerry 

-Original Message-
From: Anthony Q. Martin amar...@charter.net
Date: Fri, 15 Jan 2010 23:40:13 
To: hardware@hardwaregroup.com
Subject: [H] memtest86+: How long?

It's been running now for 8 hours, 26 minutes, 5 passes, no errors.

Is there really any point in letting this run more?  It's testing 8 GB 
of ram, those these runs take forever.  I can't image it would suddenly 
uncover some bad ram.

I never would have run this in the first place, but I did have one stick 
that was bad.  Prime96 and OCCT would uncover the bad ram 
immediately...it just took a bit of testing to isolate which stick was 
bad.  Once I found it and get a replacement stick, they then gave no 
further errors.  Now, after 8.5+ hours of memtest, I think this is ram 
should be blessed as ok.

Right?


Re: [H] memtest86+: How long?

2010-01-15 Thread Anthony Martin
I think so. Version 
4.0. 
Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

-Original Message-
From: tmse...@rlrnews.com
Date: Sat, 16 Jan 2010 04:52:26 
To: hardware@hardwaregroup.com
Subject: Re: [H] memtest86+: How long?

I'd assume so.  Newest version of memtest?
Sent via BlackBerry 

-Original Message-
From: Anthony Q. Martin amar...@charter.net
Date: Fri, 15 Jan 2010 23:40:13 
To: hardware@hardwaregroup.com
Subject: [H] memtest86+: How long?

It's been running now for 8 hours, 26 minutes, 5 passes, no errors.

Is there really any point in letting this run more?  It's testing 8 GB 
of ram, those these runs take forever.  I can't image it would suddenly 
uncover some bad ram.

I never would have run this in the first place, but I did have one stick 
that was bad.  Prime96 and OCCT would uncover the bad ram 
immediately...it just took a bit of testing to isolate which stick was 
bad.  Once I found it and get a replacement stick, they then gave no 
further errors.  Now, after 8.5+ hours of memtest, I think this is ram 
should be blessed as ok.

Right?