Re: Uniqueness of WHOIS handles

2002-10-16 Thread Harald Tveit Alvestrand

unfortunately WHOIS is a protocol, and a rather simple one.

handles are part of the service that some registries/registrars have chosen 
to implement on top of the WHOIS protocol. (Others provide similar 
services, but don't use handles; others use the WHOIS protocol for 
completely unrelated services.)

For more discussion on issues related to access to registries/registrars, I 
suggest the CRISP working group.

  Harald

--On 12. oktober 2002 14:22 -0700 Einar Stefferud [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
wrote:

 I suspect that a better answer was desired.

 I suggest that the local WHOIS handles be distinguished by the global
 WHOIS database name.  I am assuming that no two WHOIS database providers
 use the same global handle for their WHOIS servers.

 Then your database searches can find the instances of local name and
 report back with all the WHOIS sources available to help resolve the
 query.  Most of the time, the results will be singular, but when not
 singular, the query response offers a way to resolve the ambiguity.

 Then I think the proposal has a chance of working.

 Cheers...\Stef


 Rick Wesson [EMAIL PROTECTED] posted:

 Florian,

 there is no guarantee the uniqueness of WHOIS handles. there is no name
 space for whois, nor an entity to register such.

 pick any prefix you wish.

 -rick

 On Sat, 12 Oct 2002, Florian Weimer wrote:

  Is there some method to guarantee the uniqueness of WHOIS handles?
  Can I register affixes somehwere?
 
  I'm currently creating a WHOIS-like database (which might be publicly
  accessible one day), and I'd like to avoid handle collisions with
  other WHOIS databases.
 
  (I asked a similar question on some IETF WHOIS list a few months ago,
  but this list appears to be dead.)
 

 -
 This message was passed through [EMAIL PROTECTED], which
 is a sublist of [EMAIL PROTECTED] Not all messages are passed.
 Decisions on what to pass are made solely by Raffaele D'Albenzio.







Re: Uniqueness of WHOIS handles

2002-10-12 Thread Rick Wesson

Florian,

there is no guarantee the uniqueness of WHOIS handles. there is no name
space for whois, nor an entity to register such.

pick any prefix you wish.

-rick

On Sat, 12 Oct 2002, Florian Weimer wrote:

 Is there some method to guarantee the uniqueness of WHOIS handles?
 Can I register affixes somehwere?

 I'm currently creating a WHOIS-like database (which might be publicly
 accessible one day), and I'd like to avoid handle collisions with
 other WHOIS databases.

 (I asked a similar question on some IETF WHOIS list a few months ago,
 but this list appears to be dead.)