[jira] [Commented] (SPARK-13863) TPCDS query 66 returns wrong results compared to TPC official result set
[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13863?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel=15200053#comment-15200053
]
Xin Wu commented on SPARK-13863:
Jesse, after I modified the DDL to use "decimal(7,2)" for the "double" colums
as documented in the tpc-ds specs and the query return the following results
both from Hive and Spark SQL:
Spark SQL:
{code}
NULLNULLFairviewWilliamson County TN United States
DHL,BARIAN 20019597806.95 11121820.57 8670867.91
8994786.04 10887248.09 14187671.36 9732598.41 19798897.07
21007842.34 21495513.67 34795669.17 33122997.94 NULLNULL
NULLNULLNULLNULLNULLNULLNULLNULLNULLNULL
21913594.59 32518476.51 24885662.72 25698343.86 33735910.61
35527031.58 25465193.48 53623238.66 51409986.76 54159173.9
92227043.25 83435390.84
Bad cards must make.621234 FairviewWilliamson County TN
United States DHL,BARIAN 20019506753.46 8008140.33
6116769.63 11973045.15 7756254.92 5352978.49 13733996.1
16418794.37 17212743.32 17042707.41 34304935.61 35324164.21
15.303015385507 12.89069871 9.846160432301 19.273003650798 12.485238927683
8.616686288902 22.107605346777 26.429323523825 27.707342676029 27.433635972918
55.220634430827 56.861286101534 30534943.77 24481685.94 22178710.81
25695798.18 29954903.78 18084140.05 30805576.13 47156887.22
51158588.86 55759942.8 86253544.16 83451555.63
Conventional childr 977787 FairviewWilliamson County TN
United States DHL,BARIAN 20018860645.55 14415813.74
6761497.23 11820654.76 8246260.69 6636877.49 11434492.25
25673812.14 23074206.96 21834581.94 26894900.53 33575091.74
9.061938387399 14.743306814265 6.915102399603 12.089191981484 8.433596161537
6.787651594877 11.694256775759 26.257060218637 23.598398178745 22.330611820366
27.50538776 34.337838138572 23836085.83 32073313.37 25037904.18
22659895.86 21757401.03 24451608.1 21933001.85 55996703.43
57371880.44 62087214.51 82849910.15 88970319.31
Doors canno 294242 FairviewWilliamson County TN United
States DHL,BARIAN 20016355232.31 10198920.36 10246200.97
12209716.5 8566998.28 8806316.81 9789405.6 16466584.88
26443785.61 27016047.8 33660589.67 27462468.62
21.598657941422 34.66167426812 34.822360404021 41.495491806065 29.115484125312
29.928823247531 33.269912520986 55.962727550791 89.870873668613 91.815742823934
114.39763755684193.332932144289 22645143.09 24487254.6
24925759.42 30503655.27 26558160.29 20976233.52 29895796.09
56002198.38 53488158.53 76287235.46 82483747.59 88088266.69
Important issues liv138504 FairviewWilliamson County TN
United States DHL,BARIAN 200111748784.55 14351305.77
9896470.93 7990874.78 8879247.9 7362383.09 10011144.75
17741201.32 21346976.05 18074978.16 29675125.64 32545325.29
84.826319456478 103.61654370992971.452600141512 57.694180529082
64.108241639231 53.156465445041 72.280546049212 128.091616993011
154.12533970138 130.501488476867214.254647086005
234.97751176861427204167.15 25980378.13 19943398.93
25710421.13 19484481.03 26346611.48 25075158.43 54094778.13
41066732.11 54547058.28 72465962.92 92770328.27
{code}
Hive:
{code}
NULLNULLFairviewWilliamson County TN United States
DHL,BARIAN 20019597806.95 11121820.57 8670867.91
8994786.04 10887248.09 14187671.36 9732598.41 19798897.07
21007842.34 21495513.67 34795669.17 33122997.94 NULLNULL
NULLNULLNULLNULLNULLNULLNULLNULLNULLNULL
21913594.59 32518476.51 24885662.72 25698343.86 33735910.61
35527031.58 25465193.48 53623238.66 51409986.76 54159173.9
92227043.25 83435390.84
Bad cards must make.621234 FairviewWilliamson County TN
United States DHL,BARIAN 20019506753.46 8008140.33
6116769.63 11973045.15 7756254.92 5352978.49 13733996.1
16418794.37 17212743.32 17042707.41 34304935.61 35324164.21
15.303015385507 12.89069871 9.846160432301 19.273003650798 12.485238927683
8.616686288902 22.107605346777 26.429323523825 27.707342676029 27.433635972918
55.220634430827 56.861286101534 30534943.77
[jira] [Commented] (SPARK-13863) TPCDS query 66 returns wrong results compared to TPC official result set
[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13863?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel=15200160#comment-15200160
]
Xin Wu commented on SPARK-13863:
In terms of the ordering. the only difference is that the row with Null value
for the order by column (w_warehouse_name) is placed at the top for HIve and
Spark SQL, while the expected result has it at the bottom. Other rows are OK.
So the it seems the expected results have NULL row in the wrong place.
> TPCDS query 66 returns wrong results compared to TPC official result set
> -
>
> Key: SPARK-13863
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13863
> Project: Spark
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: SQL
>Affects Versions: 1.6.0
>Reporter: JESSE CHEN
> Labels: tpcds-result-mismatch
>
> Testing Spark SQL using TPC queries. Query 66 returns wrong results compared
> to official result set. This is at 1GB SF (validation run).
> Aggregations slightly off -- eg. JAN_SALES column of "Doors canno" row -
> SparkSQL returns 6355232.185385704, expected 6355232.31
> Actual results:
> {noformat}
> [null,null,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,9597806.850651741,1.1121820530080795E7,8670867.81564045,8994785.945689201,1.088724806326294E7,1.4187671518377304E7,9732598.460139751,1.9798897020946026E7,2.1007842467959404E7,2.149551364927292E7,3.479566905774999E7,3.3122997954660416E7,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,2.191359469742E7,3.2518476414670944E7,2.48856624883976E7,2.5698343830046654E7,3.373591080598068E7,3.552703167087555E7,2.5465193481492043E7,5.362323870799959E7,5.1409986978201866E7,5.415917383586836E7,9.222704311805725E7,8.343539111531019E7]
> [Bad cards must make.,621234,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,9506753.593884468,8008140.429557085,6116769.711647987,1.1973045160133362E7,7756254.925520897,5352978.574095726,1.373399613500309E7,1.6418794411203384E7,1.7212743279764652E7,1.704270732417488E7,3.43049358570323E7,3.532416421229005E7,15.30301560102066,12.890698882477594,9.846160563729589,19.273003667109915,12.485238936569628,8.61668642427125,22.107605403121994,26.429323590150222,27.707342611261865,27.433635834765774,55.22063482847413,56.86128610521969,3.0534943928382874E7,2.4481686250203133E7,2.217871080008793E7,2.569579825610423E7,2.995490355044937E7,1.8084140250833035E7,3.0805576178061485E7,4.7156887432252884E7,5.115858869637826E7,5.5759943171424866E7,8.625354428184557E7,8.345155532035494E7]
> [Conventional childr,977787,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,8860645.460736752,1.441581376543355E7,6761497.232810497,1.1820654735879421E7,8246260.600341797,6636877.482845306,1.1434492123092413E7,2.5673812070380323E7,2.307420611785E7,2.1834582007320404E7,2.6894900596512794E7,3.357509177109933E7,9.061938296108202,14.743306840276613,6.9151024024767125,12.08919195681618,8.43359606984118,6.787651587559771,11.694256645969329,26.257060147435304,23.598398219562938,22.330611889215547,27.505888906799534,34.337838170377935,2.3836085704864502E7,3.20733132298584E7,2.503790437837982E7,2.2659895963564873E7,2.175740087420273E7,2.4451608012176514E7,2.1933001734852314E7,5.59967034604629E7,5.737188052299309E7,6.208721474336243E7,8.284991027382469E7,8.897031933202875E7]
> [Doors canno,294242,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,6355232.185385704,1.0198920296742141E7,1.0246200903741479E7,1.2209716492156029E7,8566998.262890816,8806316.75278151,9789405.6993227,1.646658496404171E7,2.6443785668474197E7,2.701604788320923E7,3.366058958298761E7,2.7462468750599384E7,21.59865751791282,34.66167405313361,34.822360178837414,41.495491779406166,29.115484067165177,29.928823053070296,33.26991285854059,55.96272783641258,89.87087386734116,91.81574310672585,114.39763726112386,93.33293258813964,2.2645142994330406E7,2.448725452685547E7,2.4925759290207863E7,3.0503655031727314E7,2.6558160276379585E7,2.0976233452690125E7,2.9895796101181984E7,5.600219855566597E7,5.348815865275085E7,7.628723580410767E7,8.248374754962921E7,8.808826726185608E7]
> [Important issues liv,138504,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
>
[jira] [Commented] (SPARK-13863) TPCDS query 66 returns wrong results compared to TPC official result set
[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13863?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel=15198607#comment-15198607
]
Xiao Li commented on SPARK-13863:
-
It could be the same issue like
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13861
> TPCDS query 66 returns wrong results compared to TPC official result set
> -
>
> Key: SPARK-13863
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13863
> Project: Spark
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: SQL
>Affects Versions: 1.6.0
>Reporter: JESSE CHEN
> Labels: tpcds-result-mismatch
>
> Testing Spark SQL using TPC queries. Query 66 returns wrong results compared
> to official result set. This is at 1GB SF (validation run).
> Aggregations slightly off -- eg. JAN_SALES column of "Doors canno" row -
> SparkSQL returns 6355232.185385704, expected 6355232.31
> Actual results:
> {noformat}
> [null,null,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,9597806.850651741,1.1121820530080795E7,8670867.81564045,8994785.945689201,1.088724806326294E7,1.4187671518377304E7,9732598.460139751,1.9798897020946026E7,2.1007842467959404E7,2.149551364927292E7,3.479566905774999E7,3.3122997954660416E7,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,2.191359469742E7,3.2518476414670944E7,2.48856624883976E7,2.5698343830046654E7,3.373591080598068E7,3.552703167087555E7,2.5465193481492043E7,5.362323870799959E7,5.1409986978201866E7,5.415917383586836E7,9.222704311805725E7,8.343539111531019E7]
> [Bad cards must make.,621234,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,9506753.593884468,8008140.429557085,6116769.711647987,1.1973045160133362E7,7756254.925520897,5352978.574095726,1.373399613500309E7,1.6418794411203384E7,1.7212743279764652E7,1.704270732417488E7,3.43049358570323E7,3.532416421229005E7,15.30301560102066,12.890698882477594,9.846160563729589,19.273003667109915,12.485238936569628,8.61668642427125,22.107605403121994,26.429323590150222,27.707342611261865,27.433635834765774,55.22063482847413,56.86128610521969,3.0534943928382874E7,2.4481686250203133E7,2.217871080008793E7,2.569579825610423E7,2.995490355044937E7,1.8084140250833035E7,3.0805576178061485E7,4.7156887432252884E7,5.115858869637826E7,5.5759943171424866E7,8.625354428184557E7,8.345155532035494E7]
> [Conventional childr,977787,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,8860645.460736752,1.441581376543355E7,6761497.232810497,1.1820654735879421E7,8246260.600341797,6636877.482845306,1.1434492123092413E7,2.5673812070380323E7,2.307420611785E7,2.1834582007320404E7,2.6894900596512794E7,3.357509177109933E7,9.061938296108202,14.743306840276613,6.9151024024767125,12.08919195681618,8.43359606984118,6.787651587559771,11.694256645969329,26.257060147435304,23.598398219562938,22.330611889215547,27.505888906799534,34.337838170377935,2.3836085704864502E7,3.20733132298584E7,2.503790437837982E7,2.2659895963564873E7,2.175740087420273E7,2.4451608012176514E7,2.1933001734852314E7,5.59967034604629E7,5.737188052299309E7,6.208721474336243E7,8.284991027382469E7,8.897031933202875E7]
> [Doors canno,294242,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,6355232.185385704,1.0198920296742141E7,1.0246200903741479E7,1.2209716492156029E7,8566998.262890816,8806316.75278151,9789405.6993227,1.646658496404171E7,2.6443785668474197E7,2.701604788320923E7,3.366058958298761E7,2.7462468750599384E7,21.59865751791282,34.66167405313361,34.822360178837414,41.495491779406166,29.115484067165177,29.928823053070296,33.26991285854059,55.96272783641258,89.87087386734116,91.81574310672585,114.39763726112386,93.33293258813964,2.2645142994330406E7,2.448725452685547E7,2.4925759290207863E7,3.0503655031727314E7,2.6558160276379585E7,2.0976233452690125E7,2.9895796101181984E7,5.600219855566597E7,5.348815865275085E7,7.628723580410767E7,8.248374754962921E7,8.808826726185608E7]
> [Important issues liv,138504,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,1.1748784594717264E7,1.435130566355586E7,9896470.867572784,7990874.805492401,8879247.840401173,7362383.04259038,1.0011144724414349E7,1.7741201390372872E7,2.1346976135887742E7,1.8074978020030975E7,2.967512567988676E7,3.2545325348875403E7,84.8263197793368,103.6165429414014,71.45259969078715,57.694180713137534,64.10824120892663,53.156465102743454,72.28054586448297,128.09161750110374,154.12534032149065,130.5014874662896,214.25464737398747,234.97751219369408,2.7204167203903973E7,2.598037822457385E7,1.9943398915802002E7,2.5710421112384796E7,1.948448105346489E7,2.6346611484448195E7,2.5075158296625137E7,5.409477817043829E7,4.106673223178029E7,5.454705814340496E7,7.246596285337901E7,9.277032812079096E7]
> {noformat}
> Expected results:
> {noformat}
>
[jira] [Commented] (SPARK-13863) TPCDS query 66 returns wrong results compared to TPC official result set
[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13863?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel=15200149#comment-15200149
]
JESSE CHEN commented on SPARK-13863:
Going to validate this also on my cluster. Nice find.
> TPCDS query 66 returns wrong results compared to TPC official result set
> -
>
> Key: SPARK-13863
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13863
> Project: Spark
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: SQL
>Affects Versions: 1.6.0
>Reporter: JESSE CHEN
> Labels: tpcds-result-mismatch
>
> Testing Spark SQL using TPC queries. Query 66 returns wrong results compared
> to official result set. This is at 1GB SF (validation run).
> Aggregations slightly off -- eg. JAN_SALES column of "Doors canno" row -
> SparkSQL returns 6355232.185385704, expected 6355232.31
> Actual results:
> {noformat}
> [null,null,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,9597806.850651741,1.1121820530080795E7,8670867.81564045,8994785.945689201,1.088724806326294E7,1.4187671518377304E7,9732598.460139751,1.9798897020946026E7,2.1007842467959404E7,2.149551364927292E7,3.479566905774999E7,3.3122997954660416E7,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,2.191359469742E7,3.2518476414670944E7,2.48856624883976E7,2.5698343830046654E7,3.373591080598068E7,3.552703167087555E7,2.5465193481492043E7,5.362323870799959E7,5.1409986978201866E7,5.415917383586836E7,9.222704311805725E7,8.343539111531019E7]
> [Bad cards must make.,621234,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,9506753.593884468,8008140.429557085,6116769.711647987,1.1973045160133362E7,7756254.925520897,5352978.574095726,1.373399613500309E7,1.6418794411203384E7,1.7212743279764652E7,1.704270732417488E7,3.43049358570323E7,3.532416421229005E7,15.30301560102066,12.890698882477594,9.846160563729589,19.273003667109915,12.485238936569628,8.61668642427125,22.107605403121994,26.429323590150222,27.707342611261865,27.433635834765774,55.22063482847413,56.86128610521969,3.0534943928382874E7,2.4481686250203133E7,2.217871080008793E7,2.569579825610423E7,2.995490355044937E7,1.8084140250833035E7,3.0805576178061485E7,4.7156887432252884E7,5.115858869637826E7,5.5759943171424866E7,8.625354428184557E7,8.345155532035494E7]
> [Conventional childr,977787,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,8860645.460736752,1.441581376543355E7,6761497.232810497,1.1820654735879421E7,8246260.600341797,6636877.482845306,1.1434492123092413E7,2.5673812070380323E7,2.307420611785E7,2.1834582007320404E7,2.6894900596512794E7,3.357509177109933E7,9.061938296108202,14.743306840276613,6.9151024024767125,12.08919195681618,8.43359606984118,6.787651587559771,11.694256645969329,26.257060147435304,23.598398219562938,22.330611889215547,27.505888906799534,34.337838170377935,2.3836085704864502E7,3.20733132298584E7,2.503790437837982E7,2.2659895963564873E7,2.175740087420273E7,2.4451608012176514E7,2.1933001734852314E7,5.59967034604629E7,5.737188052299309E7,6.208721474336243E7,8.284991027382469E7,8.897031933202875E7]
> [Doors canno,294242,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,6355232.185385704,1.0198920296742141E7,1.0246200903741479E7,1.2209716492156029E7,8566998.262890816,8806316.75278151,9789405.6993227,1.646658496404171E7,2.6443785668474197E7,2.701604788320923E7,3.366058958298761E7,2.7462468750599384E7,21.59865751791282,34.66167405313361,34.822360178837414,41.495491779406166,29.115484067165177,29.928823053070296,33.26991285854059,55.96272783641258,89.87087386734116,91.81574310672585,114.39763726112386,93.33293258813964,2.2645142994330406E7,2.448725452685547E7,2.4925759290207863E7,3.0503655031727314E7,2.6558160276379585E7,2.0976233452690125E7,2.9895796101181984E7,5.600219855566597E7,5.348815865275085E7,7.628723580410767E7,8.248374754962921E7,8.808826726185608E7]
> [Important issues liv,138504,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,1.1748784594717264E7,1.435130566355586E7,9896470.867572784,7990874.805492401,8879247.840401173,7362383.04259038,1.0011144724414349E7,1.7741201390372872E7,2.1346976135887742E7,1.8074978020030975E7,2.967512567988676E7,3.2545325348875403E7,84.8263197793368,103.6165429414014,71.45259969078715,57.694180713137534,64.10824120892663,53.156465102743454,72.28054586448297,128.09161750110374,154.12534032149065,130.5014874662896,214.25464737398747,234.97751219369408,2.7204167203903973E7,2.598037822457385E7,1.9943398915802002E7,2.5710421112384796E7,1.948448105346489E7,2.6346611484448195E7,2.5075158296625137E7,5.409477817043829E7,4.106673223178029E7,5.454705814340496E7,7.246596285337901E7,9.277032812079096E7]
> {noformat}
> Expected results:
> {noformat}
>
[jira] [Commented] (SPARK-13863) TPCDS query 66 returns wrong results compared to TPC official result set
[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13863?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel=15198605#comment-15198605
]
Xiao Li commented on SPARK-13863:
-
Please check if the table definition is different.
> TPCDS query 66 returns wrong results compared to TPC official result set
> -
>
> Key: SPARK-13863
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13863
> Project: Spark
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: SQL
>Affects Versions: 1.6.0
>Reporter: JESSE CHEN
> Labels: tpcds-result-mismatch
>
> Testing Spark SQL using TPC queries. Query 66 returns wrong results compared
> to official result set. This is at 1GB SF (validation run).
> Aggregations slightly off -- eg. JAN_SALES column of "Doors canno" row -
> SparkSQL returns 6355232.185385704, expected 6355232.31
> Actual results:
> {noformat}
> [null,null,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,9597806.850651741,1.1121820530080795E7,8670867.81564045,8994785.945689201,1.088724806326294E7,1.4187671518377304E7,9732598.460139751,1.9798897020946026E7,2.1007842467959404E7,2.149551364927292E7,3.479566905774999E7,3.3122997954660416E7,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,2.191359469742E7,3.2518476414670944E7,2.48856624883976E7,2.5698343830046654E7,3.373591080598068E7,3.552703167087555E7,2.5465193481492043E7,5.362323870799959E7,5.1409986978201866E7,5.415917383586836E7,9.222704311805725E7,8.343539111531019E7]
> [Bad cards must make.,621234,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,9506753.593884468,8008140.429557085,6116769.711647987,1.1973045160133362E7,7756254.925520897,5352978.574095726,1.373399613500309E7,1.6418794411203384E7,1.7212743279764652E7,1.704270732417488E7,3.43049358570323E7,3.532416421229005E7,15.30301560102066,12.890698882477594,9.846160563729589,19.273003667109915,12.485238936569628,8.61668642427125,22.107605403121994,26.429323590150222,27.707342611261865,27.433635834765774,55.22063482847413,56.86128610521969,3.0534943928382874E7,2.4481686250203133E7,2.217871080008793E7,2.569579825610423E7,2.995490355044937E7,1.8084140250833035E7,3.0805576178061485E7,4.7156887432252884E7,5.115858869637826E7,5.5759943171424866E7,8.625354428184557E7,8.345155532035494E7]
> [Conventional childr,977787,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,8860645.460736752,1.441581376543355E7,6761497.232810497,1.1820654735879421E7,8246260.600341797,6636877.482845306,1.1434492123092413E7,2.5673812070380323E7,2.307420611785E7,2.1834582007320404E7,2.6894900596512794E7,3.357509177109933E7,9.061938296108202,14.743306840276613,6.9151024024767125,12.08919195681618,8.43359606984118,6.787651587559771,11.694256645969329,26.257060147435304,23.598398219562938,22.330611889215547,27.505888906799534,34.337838170377935,2.3836085704864502E7,3.20733132298584E7,2.503790437837982E7,2.2659895963564873E7,2.175740087420273E7,2.4451608012176514E7,2.1933001734852314E7,5.59967034604629E7,5.737188052299309E7,6.208721474336243E7,8.284991027382469E7,8.897031933202875E7]
> [Doors canno,294242,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,6355232.185385704,1.0198920296742141E7,1.0246200903741479E7,1.2209716492156029E7,8566998.262890816,8806316.75278151,9789405.6993227,1.646658496404171E7,2.6443785668474197E7,2.701604788320923E7,3.366058958298761E7,2.7462468750599384E7,21.59865751791282,34.66167405313361,34.822360178837414,41.495491779406166,29.115484067165177,29.928823053070296,33.26991285854059,55.96272783641258,89.87087386734116,91.81574310672585,114.39763726112386,93.33293258813964,2.2645142994330406E7,2.448725452685547E7,2.4925759290207863E7,3.0503655031727314E7,2.6558160276379585E7,2.0976233452690125E7,2.9895796101181984E7,5.600219855566597E7,5.348815865275085E7,7.628723580410767E7,8.248374754962921E7,8.808826726185608E7]
> [Important issues liv,138504,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,1.1748784594717264E7,1.435130566355586E7,9896470.867572784,7990874.805492401,8879247.840401173,7362383.04259038,1.0011144724414349E7,1.7741201390372872E7,2.1346976135887742E7,1.8074978020030975E7,2.967512567988676E7,3.2545325348875403E7,84.8263197793368,103.6165429414014,71.45259969078715,57.694180713137534,64.10824120892663,53.156465102743454,72.28054586448297,128.09161750110374,154.12534032149065,130.5014874662896,214.25464737398747,234.97751219369408,2.7204167203903973E7,2.598037822457385E7,1.9943398915802002E7,2.5710421112384796E7,1.948448105346489E7,2.6346611484448195E7,2.5075158296625137E7,5.409477817043829E7,4.106673223178029E7,5.454705814340496E7,7.246596285337901E7,9.277032812079096E7]
> {noformat}
> Expected results:
> {noformat}
>
[jira] [Commented] (SPARK-13863) TPCDS query 66 returns wrong results compared to TPC official result set
[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13863?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel=15198643#comment-15198643
]
Xiao Li commented on SPARK-13863:
-
cs_sales_price is also used in this query. Thus, the accuracy could be caused
by the wrong table definition too.
> TPCDS query 66 returns wrong results compared to TPC official result set
> -
>
> Key: SPARK-13863
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13863
> Project: Spark
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: SQL
>Affects Versions: 1.6.0
>Reporter: JESSE CHEN
> Labels: tpcds-result-mismatch
>
> Testing Spark SQL using TPC queries. Query 66 returns wrong results compared
> to official result set. This is at 1GB SF (validation run).
> Aggregations slightly off -- eg. JAN_SALES column of "Doors canno" row -
> SparkSQL returns 6355232.185385704, expected 6355232.31
> Actual results:
> {noformat}
> [null,null,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,9597806.850651741,1.1121820530080795E7,8670867.81564045,8994785.945689201,1.088724806326294E7,1.4187671518377304E7,9732598.460139751,1.9798897020946026E7,2.1007842467959404E7,2.149551364927292E7,3.479566905774999E7,3.3122997954660416E7,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,2.191359469742E7,3.2518476414670944E7,2.48856624883976E7,2.5698343830046654E7,3.373591080598068E7,3.552703167087555E7,2.5465193481492043E7,5.362323870799959E7,5.1409986978201866E7,5.415917383586836E7,9.222704311805725E7,8.343539111531019E7]
> [Bad cards must make.,621234,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,9506753.593884468,8008140.429557085,6116769.711647987,1.1973045160133362E7,7756254.925520897,5352978.574095726,1.373399613500309E7,1.6418794411203384E7,1.7212743279764652E7,1.704270732417488E7,3.43049358570323E7,3.532416421229005E7,15.30301560102066,12.890698882477594,9.846160563729589,19.273003667109915,12.485238936569628,8.61668642427125,22.107605403121994,26.429323590150222,27.707342611261865,27.433635834765774,55.22063482847413,56.86128610521969,3.0534943928382874E7,2.4481686250203133E7,2.217871080008793E7,2.569579825610423E7,2.995490355044937E7,1.8084140250833035E7,3.0805576178061485E7,4.7156887432252884E7,5.115858869637826E7,5.5759943171424866E7,8.625354428184557E7,8.345155532035494E7]
> [Conventional childr,977787,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,8860645.460736752,1.441581376543355E7,6761497.232810497,1.1820654735879421E7,8246260.600341797,6636877.482845306,1.1434492123092413E7,2.5673812070380323E7,2.307420611785E7,2.1834582007320404E7,2.6894900596512794E7,3.357509177109933E7,9.061938296108202,14.743306840276613,6.9151024024767125,12.08919195681618,8.43359606984118,6.787651587559771,11.694256645969329,26.257060147435304,23.598398219562938,22.330611889215547,27.505888906799534,34.337838170377935,2.3836085704864502E7,3.20733132298584E7,2.503790437837982E7,2.2659895963564873E7,2.175740087420273E7,2.4451608012176514E7,2.1933001734852314E7,5.59967034604629E7,5.737188052299309E7,6.208721474336243E7,8.284991027382469E7,8.897031933202875E7]
> [Doors canno,294242,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,6355232.185385704,1.0198920296742141E7,1.0246200903741479E7,1.2209716492156029E7,8566998.262890816,8806316.75278151,9789405.6993227,1.646658496404171E7,2.6443785668474197E7,2.701604788320923E7,3.366058958298761E7,2.7462468750599384E7,21.59865751791282,34.66167405313361,34.822360178837414,41.495491779406166,29.115484067165177,29.928823053070296,33.26991285854059,55.96272783641258,89.87087386734116,91.81574310672585,114.39763726112386,93.33293258813964,2.2645142994330406E7,2.448725452685547E7,2.4925759290207863E7,3.0503655031727314E7,2.6558160276379585E7,2.0976233452690125E7,2.9895796101181984E7,5.600219855566597E7,5.348815865275085E7,7.628723580410767E7,8.248374754962921E7,8.808826726185608E7]
> [Important issues liv,138504,Fairview,Williamson County,TN,United
> States,DHL,BARIAN,2001,1.1748784594717264E7,1.435130566355586E7,9896470.867572784,7990874.805492401,8879247.840401173,7362383.04259038,1.0011144724414349E7,1.7741201390372872E7,2.1346976135887742E7,1.8074978020030975E7,2.967512567988676E7,3.2545325348875403E7,84.8263197793368,103.6165429414014,71.45259969078715,57.694180713137534,64.10824120892663,53.156465102743454,72.28054586448297,128.09161750110374,154.12534032149065,130.5014874662896,214.25464737398747,234.97751219369408,2.7204167203903973E7,2.598037822457385E7,1.9943398915802002E7,2.5710421112384796E7,1.948448105346489E7,2.6346611484448195E7,2.5075158296625137E7,5.409477817043829E7,4.106673223178029E7,5.454705814340496E7,7.246596285337901E7,9.277032812079096E7]
> {noformat}
> Expected results:
> {noformat}
>
