Re: collision \breathe with accidentals
> Could https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/issues/1006 be what > you’re looking for? It is, thanks! Werner
Re: collision \breathe with accidentals
Werner, Could [1]https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/issues/1006 be what you’re looking for? Jean References 1. https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/issues/1006
Re: collision \breathe with accidentals
>> > the breathing sign is non-musical, and the accidental is musical, >> > so this should be prevented by the skyline distancing. It would >> > be interesting to see what lily thinks the skylines look like. >> >> Here it is. >> > these are the skylines for vertical spacing. You need the ones for > horizontal spacing. Look at the commented out stencil callback for > PaperColumn in define-grobs.scm. Commenting this out I get the attached image. Is this the right one? Werner
Re: collision \breathe with accidentals
On Fri, Aug 7, 2020 at 5:30 PM Werner LEMBERG wrote:
>
> >> Look at the following code.
> >>
> >> \relative c'' {
> >> f2 \breathe |
> >> g2 \breathe }
> >>
> >> As the attached images show, the breathing sign *sometimes*
> >> collides with accidentals. Looks like a bug. If you agree I'll
> >> add it to the tracker.
> >
> > the breathing sign is non-musical, and the accidental is musical, so
> > this should be prevented by the skyline distancing. It would be
> > interesting to see what lily thinks the skylines look like.
>
> Here it is.
>
>
>
these are the skylines for vertical spacing. You need the ones for
horizontal spacing. Look at the commented out stencil callback for
PaperColumn in define-grobs.scm.
> Werner
>
--
Han-Wen Nienhuys - hanw...@gmail.com - http://www.xs4all.nl/~hanwen
Re: collision \breathe with accidentals
>> Attached I've added some more tests. LilyPond's behaviour >> w.r.t. accidentals looks very erratical... > > Is this another manifestation of that age-old dotted rest problem > that plagued the reg tests for years that was fixed end of last year > (but I forget by who - Thomas?) where the dot would move sometimes > and sometimes not affecting random reg tests? I don't think so, but I'm just a mere mortal :-) Werner
Re: collision \breathe with accidentals
>> Look at the following code.
>>
>> \relative c'' {
>> f2 \breathe |
>> g2 \breathe }
>>
>> As the attached images show, the breathing sign *sometimes*
>> collides with accidentals. Looks like a bug. If you agree I'll
>> add it to the tracker.
>
> the breathing sign is non-musical, and the accidental is musical, so
> this should be prevented by the skyline distancing. It would be
> interesting to see what lily thinks the skylines look like.
Here it is.
Werner
Re: collision \breathe with accidentals
> On 7 Aug 2020, at 08:17, Werner LEMBERG wrote: > > As the attached images show, the breathing sign *sometimes* collides > with accidentals. Looks like a bug. If you agree I'll add it to the > tracker. > > Any idea how to circumvent that? In addition to that, I place the breath mark above the ledger lines, and all sources I could find do likewise.
Re: collision \breathe with accidentals
On Fri, Aug 7, 2020 at 8:17 AM Werner LEMBERG wrote:
>
> [lilypond e16a5ec 2020-Aug-06]
>
>
> Look at the following code.
>
> \relative c'' {
> f2 \breathe |
> g2 \breathe }
>
> As the attached images show, the breathing sign *sometimes* collides
> with accidentals. Looks like a bug. If you agree I'll add it to the
> tracker.
>
> Any idea how to circumvent that?
>
the breathing sign is non-musical, and the accidental is musical, so this
should be prevented by the skyline distancing. It would be interesting to
see what lily thinks the skylines look like.
--
Han-Wen Nienhuys - hanw...@gmail.com - http://www.xs4all.nl/~hanwen
Re: collision \breathe with accidentals
On 07/08/2020 10:37, Werner LEMBERG wrote: As the attached images show, the breathing sign *sometimes* collides with accidentals. Looks like a bug. Attached I've added some more tests. LilyPond's behaviour w.r.t. accidentals looks very erratical... Werner Is this another manifestation of that age-old dotted rest problem that plagued the reg tests for years that was fixed end of last year (but I forget by who - Thomas?) where the dot would move sometimes and sometimes not affecting random reg tests? James
Re: collision \breathe with accidentals
>> As the attached images show, the breathing sign *sometimes*
>> collides with accidentals. Looks like a bug. If you agree I'll
>> add it to the tracker.
>>
>> Any idea how to circumvent that?
>
> Adjusting the vertical bounds of the BreathingSign appears to help:
>
>
> \relative c'' {
> \override BreathingSign.extra-spacing-height = #'(0 . 2)
> f2 \breathe |
> e2 \breathe |
> d2 \breathe |
> c2 \breathe |
> g2 \breathe
> }
>
Indeed, this makes even my larger set of tests work, see attached
image. Thanks! Shall this be added to LilyPond's default values?
Werner
Re: collision \breathe with accidentals
> As the attached images show, the breathing sign *sometimes* collides
> with accidentals. Looks like a bug.
Attached I've added some more tests. LilyPond's behaviour
w.r.t. accidentals looks very erratical...
Werner
\paper {
indent = 0
ragged-right = ##t
}
\relative c'' {
\omit Score.TimeSignature
\omit Score.BarNumber
f2 \breathe f |
f2 \breathe g |
f2 \breathe a |
f2 \breathe b | \break
f2 \breathe fis |
f2 \breathe gis |
f2 \breathe ais |
f2 \breathe bis | \break
f2 \breathe f! |
f2 \breathe g! |
f2 \breathe a! |
f2 \breathe b! | \break
f2 \breathe fes |
f2 \breathe ges |
f2 \breathe aes |
f2 \breathe bes }
Re: collision \breathe with accidentals
On 2020-08-06 11:17 pm, Werner LEMBERG wrote:
[lilypond e16a5ec 2020-Aug-06]
Look at the following code.
\relative c'' {
f2 \breathe |
g2 \breathe }
As the attached images show, the breathing sign *sometimes* collides
with accidentals. Looks like a bug. If you agree I'll add it to the
tracker.
Any idea how to circumvent that?
Adjusting the vertical bounds of the BreathingSign appears to help:
\relative c'' {
\override BreathingSign.extra-spacing-height = #'(0 . 2)
f2 \breathe |
e2 \breathe |
d2 \breathe |
c2 \breathe |
g2 \breathe
}
-- Aaron Hill
collision \breathe with accidentals
[lilypond e16a5ec 2020-Aug-06]
Look at the following code.
\relative c'' {
f2 \breathe |
g2 \breathe }
As the attached images show, the breathing sign *sometimes* collides
with accidentals. Looks like a bug. If you agree I'll add it to the
tracker.
Any idea how to circumvent that?
Werner
