Re: In TabVoice - how to avoid: "programming error: side-axis not set for grob StrokeFinger"
>> Or maybe there is a bug somewhere? I think not having to think >> about the order would be quite beneficial. > > I totally agree there, but the New_fingering_engraver has been > designed that way and it's complicated enough. It'd be great of > course if someone had a good idea how to get rid of these > dependencies. Please file a bug report :-) Werner
Re: In TabVoice - how to avoid: "programming error: side-axis not set for grob StrokeFinger"
Am Di., 10. März 2020 um 00:07 Uhr schrieb Torsten Hämmerle
:
>
> Thomas Morley-2 wrote
> > Any hints why this error is generated and how to avoid?
>
>
> Hi Harm,
>
> Unfortunately, applying \consists "New_fingering_engraver" does not quite do
> the trick yet, because there's a problem of sequence: it needs to come
> *before* Script_column_engraver, that's why just appending it at the end
> will not work.
>
> In order to avoid this problem of sequence, I've first removed
> Script_column_engraver and appended it again /after/ New_fingering_engraver.
> Looks funny but actually solves the problem.
>
> Alternatively, you could just completely \remove the Script_column_engraver
> if you don't need it.
>
> %
> \version "2.20.0"
>
> \layout {
> \context {
> \TabVoice
> \remove "Script_column_engraver"
> \consists "New_fingering_engraver" % *before* Script_column_engraver!
> \consists "Script_column_engraver"
> }
> }
>
> \new TabVoice
> { b-\rightHandFinger 1 -"foo" }
> %
>
> That way, all the side-axis properties needed will have been set.
>
> HTH,
> Torsten
Hi Torsten,
many thanks!
Cheers,
Harm
Re: In TabVoice - how to avoid: "programming error: side-axis not set for grob StrokeFinger"
Werner LEMBERG wrote > Interesting. Is it documented somewhere that the order of `\consists` > calls is relevant (sometimes)? Hi Werner, I couldn't find anything about that in the documentation. When experimenting with Voice and TabVoice, I noticed that Voice worked without a problem and, most notably, the fingering routines were called before the script routines. In *ly/engraver-init.ly*, the Voice context definition contains a comment: […] \consists "Auto_beam_engraver" \consists "Grace_auto_beam_engraver" %% must come before Script_column_engraver. \consists "New_fingering_engraver" \consists "Chord_tremolo_engraver" \consists "Double_percent_repeat_engraver" […] TabVoice, finally, is based on Voice but with New_fingerning_engraver removed (but Script_column_engraver still being there). When appending it again by using "\consists…", the order is messed up. Werner LEMBERG wrote > Or maybe there is a bug somewhere? I think not having to think about > the order would be quite beneficial. I totally agree there, but the New_fingering_engraver has been designed that way and it's complicated enough. It'd be great of course if someone had a good idea how to get rid of these dependencies. Regards, Torsten -- Sent from: http://lilypond.1069038.n5.nabble.com/User-f3.html
Re: In TabVoice - how to avoid: "programming error: side-axis not set for grob StrokeFinger"
> In order to avoid this problem of sequence, I've first removed > Script_column_engraver and appended it again /after/ > New_fingering_engraver. Looks funny but actually solves the > problem. > > [...] > \remove "Script_column_engraver" > \consists "New_fingering_engraver" % *before* Script_column_engraver! > \consists "Script_column_engraver" Interesting. Is it documented somewhere that the order of `\consists` calls is relevant (sometimes)? Or rather, is there an example in the documentation or the regression test suite that demonstrates the importance of the right order? Or maybe there is a bug somewhere? I think not having to think about the order would be quite beneficial. I think I would prefer setting a property or the like to get the desired result. Werner
Re: In TabVoice - how to avoid: "programming error: side-axis not set for grob StrokeFinger"
Thomas Morley-2 wrote
> Any hints why this error is generated and how to avoid?
Hi Harm,
Unfortunately, applying \consists "New_fingering_engraver" does not quite do
the trick yet, because there's a problem of sequence: it needs to come
*before* Script_column_engraver, that's why just appending it at the end
will not work.
In order to avoid this problem of sequence, I've first removed
Script_column_engraver and appended it again /after/ New_fingering_engraver.
Looks funny but actually solves the problem.
Alternatively, you could just completely \remove the Script_column_engraver
if you don't need it.
%
\version "2.20.0"
\layout {
\context {
\TabVoice
\remove "Script_column_engraver"
\consists "New_fingering_engraver" % *before* Script_column_engraver!
\consists "Script_column_engraver"
}
}
\new TabVoice
{ b-\rightHandFinger 1 -"foo" }
%
That way, all the side-axis properties needed will have been set.
HTH,
Torsten
--
Sent from: http://lilypond.1069038.n5.nabble.com/User-f3.html
In TabVoice - how to avoid: "programming error: side-axis not set for grob StrokeFinger"
Hi all,
if I want to print StrokeFinger in TabStaff I need to consist
"New_fingering_engraver". And it works fine, at first sight...
Alas, if there is an additional markup then I get a programming error
(even if the markup isn't printed at all).
\version "2.20.0"
\new TabVoice \with { \consists "New_fingering_engraver" }
{ b-\rightHandFinger 1 -"foo" }
>From terminal:
[...]
atest-100.ly:269:6: programming error: side-axis not set for grob StrokeFinger.
{ b
-\rightHandFinger 1 -"foo" }
atest-100.ly:269:6: continuing, cross fingers
[...]
Any hints why this error is generated and how to avoid?
Thanks,
Harm
