Re: Issue with durations and roman numeral analysis tool
David and Aaron:
Thank you for your prompt response and for resolving the issue.
Joe Srednicki
Sent from the all new AOL app for iOS
On Tuesday, April 30, 2024, 8:12 PM, David Nalesnik
wrote:
Hi Joe,
On Tue, Apr 30, 2024 at 6:55 PM Joseph Srednicki
wrote:
Based on the input, I expect the vi 6 4 to appear beneath the final sixteenth
note of the second beat of the measure. However, the vi 6 4 appears under the
first note of the third beat in the measure.
Can anyone please help detect the error that I am making?
By using \lyricsto, you override the specified durations. See the change I
made inline below:
\version "2.24.0"\language "english"% Change the following line to the path of
the roman numeral analysis tool on your computer\include
"C:/docs/frescobaldi/roman_num/roman_numeral_analysis_tool.ily"
global = { \key ef \major \time 3/4}
right = \relative c'' { \global r4 r2}
leftOne = \relative c'' { \global \clef treble r4 g8. af16 f8.\prall e32 f }
leftTwo = \relative c' { \global r4 bf8. c16 af8._\prall g32 af | % 1}
pedal = \relative c { \global \clef bass ef,4 ef' bf | % 1}
analysis = \lyricmode { \override LyricText.self-alignment-X = #-0.6 \offset
StanzaNumber.X-offset #-3 \set stanza = \markup{E \flat:} \skip 4 \markup
\rN { I }8. \markup \rN { vi 6 4 }16 % 1}
\score { << \new PianoStaff << \new Staff = "right" \right \new
Staff = "left" { \clef bass << \leftOne \\ \leftTwo >> } >> \context
Staff = "pedal" << \context Voice = pedal { << \pedal >> } %% \new
Lyrics \with { %% } \lyricsto "pedal" { \analysis }
\new Lyrics \analysis
>> >>}
Re: Issue with durations and roman numeral analysis tool
Hi Joe,
On Tue, Apr 30, 2024 at 6:55 PM Joseph Srednicki
wrote:
>
> Based on the input, I expect the vi 6 4 to appear beneath the final
> sixteenth note of the second beat of the measure. However, the vi 6 4
> appears under the first note of the third beat in the measure.
>
> Can anyone please help detect the error that I am making?
>
By using \lyricsto, you override the specified durations. See the change I
made inline below:
> \version "2.24.0"
> \language "english"
> % Change the following line to the path of the roman numeral analysis tool
> on your computer
> \include "C:/docs/frescobaldi/roman_num/roman_numeral_analysis_tool.ily"
>
> global = {
> \key ef \major
> \time 3/4
> }
>
> right = \relative c'' {
> \global
>r4 r2
> }
>
> leftOne = \relative c'' {
> \global \clef treble
> r4 g8. af16 f8.\prall e32 f
> }
>
> leftTwo = \relative c' {
> \global
> r4 bf8. c16 af8._\prall g32 af | % 1
> }
>
> pedal = \relative c {
> \global
> \clef bass
> ef,4 ef' bf | % 1
> }
>
> analysis = \lyricmode {
> \override LyricText.self-alignment-X = #-0.6
> \offset StanzaNumber.X-offset #-3
> \set stanza = \markup{E \flat:}
> \skip 4 \markup \rN { I }8. \markup \rN { vi 6 4 }16 % 1
> }
>
> \score {
> <<
> \new PianoStaff <<
> \new Staff = "right" \right
> \new Staff = "left" { \clef bass << \leftOne \\ \leftTwo >> }
> >>
> \context Staff = "pedal"
> <<
> \context Voice = pedal { << \pedal >> }
> %% \new Lyrics \with {
> %% } \lyricsto "pedal" { \analysis }
>
\new Lyrics \analysis
> >>
> >>
> }
>
>
Re: Issue with durations and roman numeral analysis tool
On 2024-04-30 4:54 pm, Joseph Srednicki wrote:
Hello:
I am having difficulty with durations and the roman numeral analysis
tool roman_numeral_analysis_tool.ily, which I downloaded from GitHub -
lyp-packages/roman-numerals: LilyPond typesetter for Roman numeral
harmonic analysis
See the tiny example below.
In this example, I have used beat durations in the analysis section of
the source code.
Based on the input, I expect the vi 6 4 to appear beneath the final
sixteenth note of the second beat of the measure. However, the vi 6 4
appears under the first note of the third beat in the measure.
Can anyone please help detect the error that I am making?
Thanks for your help.
Joe Srednicki
-
\version "2.24.0"\language "english"% Change the following line to the
path of the roman numeral analysis tool on your computer\include
"C:/docs/frescobaldi/roman_num/roman_numeral_analysis_tool.ily"
global = { \key ef \major \time 3/4}
right = \relative c'' { \global r4 r2}
leftOne = \relative c'' { \global \clef treble r4 g8. af16 f8.\prall
e32 f }
leftTwo = \relative c' { \global r4 bf8. c16 af8._\prall g32 af | %
1}
pedal = \relative c { \global \clef bass ef,4 ef' bf | % 1}
analysis = \lyricmode { \override LyricText.self-alignment-X = #-0.6
\offset StanzaNumber.X-offset #-3 \set stanza = \markup{E \flat:}
\skip 4 \markup \rN { I }8. \markup \rN { vi 6 4 }16 % 1}
\score { << \new PianoStaff << \new Staff = "right" \right
\new Staff = "left" { \clef bass << \leftOne \\ \leftTwo >> } >>
\context Staff = "pedal" << \context Voice = pedal { <<
\pedal >> } \new Lyrics \with { } \lyricsto "pedal" {
\analysis } >> >>}
It appears you are using \lyricsto which ignores the durations specified
and instead associates each syllable with a note in the named voice.
You should just reference the lyrics variable directly: \new Lyrics {
\analysis }
-- Aaron Hill
Issue with durations and roman numeral analysis tool
Hello:
I am having difficulty with durations and the roman numeral analysis tool
roman_numeral_analysis_tool.ily, which I downloaded from GitHub -
lyp-packages/roman-numerals: LilyPond typesetter for Roman numeral harmonic
analysis
See the tiny example below.
In this example, I have used beat durations in the analysis section of the
source code.
Based on the input, I expect the vi 6 4 to appear beneath the final sixteenth
note of the second beat of the measure. However, the vi 6 4 appears under the
first note of the third beat in the measure.
Can anyone please help detect the error that I am making?
Thanks for your help.
Joe Srednicki
-
\version "2.24.0"\language "english"% Change the following line to the path of
the roman numeral analysis tool on your computer\include
"C:/docs/frescobaldi/roman_num/roman_numeral_analysis_tool.ily"
global = { \key ef \major \time 3/4}
right = \relative c'' { \global r4 r2}
leftOne = \relative c'' { \global \clef treble r4 g8. af16 f8.\prall e32 f }
leftTwo = \relative c' { \global r4 bf8. c16 af8._\prall g32 af | % 1}
pedal = \relative c { \global \clef bass ef,4 ef' bf | % 1}
analysis = \lyricmode { \override LyricText.self-alignment-X = #-0.6 \offset
StanzaNumber.X-offset #-3 \set stanza = \markup{E \flat:} \skip 4 \markup
\rN { I }8. \markup \rN { vi 6 4 }16 % 1}
\score { << \new PianoStaff << \new Staff = "right" \right \new
Staff = "left" { \clef bass << \leftOne \\ \leftTwo >> } >> \context
Staff = "pedal" << \context Voice = pedal { << \pedal >> } \new
Lyrics \with { } \lyricsto "pedal" { \analysis } >> >>}
