Re: [PATCH v2] scsi: ses: don't get power status of SES device slot on probe

2017-04-06 Thread Martin K. Petersen 

Mauricio,

> The commit 08024885a2a3 ("ses: Add power_status to SES device slot")
> introduced the 'power_status' attribute to enclosure components and
> the associated callbacks.

Applied to 4.12/scsi-queue, thanks!

-- 
Martin K. Petersen  Oracle Linux Engineering

Re: [PATCH v2] scsi: ses: don't get power status of SES device slot on probe

2017-04-05 Thread Mauricio Faria de Oliveira 

On 04/05/2017 01:23 PM, Song Liu wrote:

Reviewed-by: Song Liu 


Thanks for reviewing, Song Liu.

It's good to know this patch doesn't break anything for you.

cheers,


--
Mauricio Faria de Oliveira
IBM Linux Technology Center

Re: [PATCH v2] scsi: ses: don't get power status of SES device slot on probe

2017-04-05 Thread Song Liu 

> On Apr 5, 2017, at 8:18 AM, Mauricio Faria de Oliveira 
>  wrote:
> 
> The commit 08024885a2a3 ("ses: Add power_status to SES device slot")
> introduced the 'power_status' attribute to enclosure components and
> the associated callbacks.
> 
> There are 2 callbacks available to get the power status of a device:
> 1) ses_get_power_status() for 'struct enclosure_component_callbacks'
> 2) get_component_power_status() for the sysfs device attribute
> (these are available for kernel-space and user-space, respectively.)
> 
> However, despite both methods being available to get power status
> on demand, that commit also introduced a call to get power status
> in ses_enclosure_data_process().
> 
> This dramatically increased the total probe time for SCSI devices
> on larger configurations, because ses_enclosure_data_process() is
> called several times during the SCSI devices probe and loops over
> the component devices (but that is another problem, another patch).
> 
> That results in a tremendous continuous hammering of SCSI Receive
> Diagnostics commands to the enclosure-services device, which does
> delay the total probe time for the SCSI devices __significantly__:
> 
>  Originally, ~34 minutes on a system attached to ~170 disks:
> 
>[ 9214.490703] mpt3sas version 13.100.00.00 loaded
>...
>[11256.580231] scsi 17:0:177:0: qdepth(16), tagged(1), simple(0),
>   ordered(0), scsi_level(6), cmd_que(1)
> 
>  With this patch, it decreased to ~2.5 minutes -- a 13.6x faster
> 
>[ 1002.992533] mpt3sas version 13.100.00.00 loaded
>...
>[ 1151.978831] scsi 11:0:177:0: qdepth(16), tagged(1), simple(0),
>   ordered(0), scsi_level(6), cmd_que(1)
> 
> Back to the commit discussion.. on the ses_get_power_status() call
> introduced in ses_enclosure_data_process(): impact of removing it.
> 
> That may possibly be in place to initialize the power status value
> on device probe.  However, those 2 functions available to retrieve
> that value _do_ automatically refresh/update it.  So the potential
> benefit would be a direct access of the 'power_status' field which
> does not use the callbacks...
> 
> But the only reader of 'struct enclosure_component::power_status'
> is the get_component_power_status() callback for sysfs attribute,
> and it _does_ check for and call the .get_power_status callback,
> (which indeed is defined and implemented by that commit), so the
> power status value is, again, automatically updated.
> 
> So, the remaining potential for a direct/non-callback access to
> the power_status attribute would be out-of-tree modules -- well,
> for those, if they are for whatever reason interested in values
> that are set during device probe and not up-to-date by the time
> they need it.. well, that would be curious.
> 
> Well, to handle that more properly, set the initial power state
> value to '-1' (i.e., uninitialized) instead of '1' (power 'on'),
> and check for it in that callback which may do an direct access
> to the field value _if_ a callback function is not defined.
> 
> Signed-off-by: Mauricio Faria de Oliveira 
> Fixes: 08024885a2a3 ("ses: Add power_status to SES device slot")
> ---
> 
> v2:
> - remove module parameter.
> - better return values for -1/uninitalized power_status.
>   (thanks: Dan Williams )
> 
> drivers/misc/enclosure.c | 7 ++-
> drivers/scsi/ses.c   | 1 -
> 2 files changed, 6 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)
> 
> diff --git a/drivers/misc/enclosure.c b/drivers/misc/enclosure.c
> index 65fed7146e9b..d3fe3ea902d4 100644
> --- a/drivers/misc/enclosure.c
> +++ b/drivers/misc/enclosure.c
> @@ -148,7 +148,7 @@ struct enclosure_device *
>   for (i = 0; i < components; i++) {
>   edev->component[i].number = -1;
>   edev->component[i].slot = -1;
> - edev->component[i].power_status = 1;
> + edev->component[i].power_status = -1;
>   }
> 
>   mutex_lock(_list_lock);
> @@ -594,6 +594,11 @@ static ssize_t get_component_power_status(struct device 
> *cdev,
> 
>   if (edev->cb->get_power_status)
>   edev->cb->get_power_status(edev, ecomp);
> +
> + /* If still uninitialized, the callback failed or does not exist. */
> + if (ecomp->power_status == -1)
> + return (edev->cb->get_power_status) ? -EIO : -ENOTTY;
> +
>   return snprintf(buf, 40, "%s\n", ecomp->power_status ? "on" : "off");
> }
> 
> diff --git a/drivers/scsi/ses.c b/drivers/scsi/ses.c
> index 50adabbb5808..f1cdf32d7514 100644
> --- a/drivers/scsi/ses.c
> +++ b/drivers/scsi/ses.c
> @@ -548,7 +548,6 @@ static void ses_enclosure_data_process(struct 
> enclosure_device *edev,
>   ecomp = >component[components++];
> 
>   if (!IS_ERR(ecomp)) {
> - ses_get_power_status(edev, ecomp);
>

Re: [PATCH v2] scsi: ses: don't get power status of SES device slot on probe

2017-04-05 Thread Dan Williams 
On Wed, Apr 5, 2017 at 8:18 AM, Mauricio Faria de Oliveira
 wrote:
> The commit 08024885a2a3 ("ses: Add power_status to SES device slot")
> introduced the 'power_status' attribute to enclosure components and
> the associated callbacks.
>
> There are 2 callbacks available to get the power status of a device:
> 1) ses_get_power_status() for 'struct enclosure_component_callbacks'
> 2) get_component_power_status() for the sysfs device attribute
> (these are available for kernel-space and user-space, respectively.)
>
> However, despite both methods being available to get power status
> on demand, that commit also introduced a call to get power status
> in ses_enclosure_data_process().
>
> This dramatically increased the total probe time for SCSI devices
> on larger configurations, because ses_enclosure_data_process() is
> called several times during the SCSI devices probe and loops over
> the component devices (but that is another problem, another patch).
>
> That results in a tremendous continuous hammering of SCSI Receive
> Diagnostics commands to the enclosure-services device, which does
> delay the total probe time for the SCSI devices __significantly__:
>
>   Originally, ~34 minutes on a system attached to ~170 disks:
>
> [ 9214.490703] mpt3sas version 13.100.00.00 loaded
> ...
> [11256.580231] scsi 17:0:177:0: qdepth(16), tagged(1), simple(0),
>ordered(0), scsi_level(6), cmd_que(1)
>
>   With this patch, it decreased to ~2.5 minutes -- a 13.6x faster
>
> [ 1002.992533] mpt3sas version 13.100.00.00 loaded
> ...
> [ 1151.978831] scsi 11:0:177:0: qdepth(16), tagged(1), simple(0),
>ordered(0), scsi_level(6), cmd_que(1)
>
> Back to the commit discussion.. on the ses_get_power_status() call
> introduced in ses_enclosure_data_process(): impact of removing it.
>
> That may possibly be in place to initialize the power status value
> on device probe.  However, those 2 functions available to retrieve
> that value _do_ automatically refresh/update it.  So the potential
> benefit would be a direct access of the 'power_status' field which
> does not use the callbacks...
>
> But the only reader of 'struct enclosure_component::power_status'
> is the get_component_power_status() callback for sysfs attribute,
> and it _does_ check for and call the .get_power_status callback,
> (which indeed is defined and implemented by that commit), so the
> power status value is, again, automatically updated.
>
> So, the remaining potential for a direct/non-callback access to
> the power_status attribute would be out-of-tree modules -- well,
> for those, if they are for whatever reason interested in values
> that are set during device probe and not up-to-date by the time
> they need it.. well, that would be curious.
>
> Well, to handle that more properly, set the initial power state
> value to '-1' (i.e., uninitialized) instead of '1' (power 'on'),
> and check for it in that callback which may do an direct access
> to the field value _if_ a callback function is not defined.
>
> Signed-off-by: Mauricio Faria de Oliveira 
> Fixes: 08024885a2a3 ("ses: Add power_status to SES device slot")

Reviewed-by: Dan Williams

[PATCH v2] scsi: ses: don't get power status of SES device slot on probe

2017-04-05 Thread Mauricio Faria de Oliveira 
The commit 08024885a2a3 ("ses: Add power_status to SES device slot")
introduced the 'power_status' attribute to enclosure components and
the associated callbacks.

There are 2 callbacks available to get the power status of a device:
1) ses_get_power_status() for 'struct enclosure_component_callbacks'
2) get_component_power_status() for the sysfs device attribute
(these are available for kernel-space and user-space, respectively.)

However, despite both methods being available to get power status
on demand, that commit also introduced a call to get power status
in ses_enclosure_data_process().

This dramatically increased the total probe time for SCSI devices
on larger configurations, because ses_enclosure_data_process() is
called several times during the SCSI devices probe and loops over
the component devices (but that is another problem, another patch).

That results in a tremendous continuous hammering of SCSI Receive
Diagnostics commands to the enclosure-services device, which does
delay the total probe time for the SCSI devices __significantly__:

  Originally, ~34 minutes on a system attached to ~170 disks:

[ 9214.490703] mpt3sas version 13.100.00.00 loaded
...
[11256.580231] scsi 17:0:177:0: qdepth(16), tagged(1), simple(0),
   ordered(0), scsi_level(6), cmd_que(1)

  With this patch, it decreased to ~2.5 minutes -- a 13.6x faster

[ 1002.992533] mpt3sas version 13.100.00.00 loaded
...
[ 1151.978831] scsi 11:0:177:0: qdepth(16), tagged(1), simple(0),
   ordered(0), scsi_level(6), cmd_que(1)

Back to the commit discussion.. on the ses_get_power_status() call
introduced in ses_enclosure_data_process(): impact of removing it.

That may possibly be in place to initialize the power status value
on device probe.  However, those 2 functions available to retrieve
that value _do_ automatically refresh/update it.  So the potential
benefit would be a direct access of the 'power_status' field which
does not use the callbacks...

But the only reader of 'struct enclosure_component::power_status'
is the get_component_power_status() callback for sysfs attribute,
and it _does_ check for and call the .get_power_status callback,
(which indeed is defined and implemented by that commit), so the
power status value is, again, automatically updated.

So, the remaining potential for a direct/non-callback access to
the power_status attribute would be out-of-tree modules -- well,
for those, if they are for whatever reason interested in values
that are set during device probe and not up-to-date by the time
they need it.. well, that would be curious.

Well, to handle that more properly, set the initial power state
value to '-1' (i.e., uninitialized) instead of '1' (power 'on'),
and check for it in that callback which may do an direct access
to the field value _if_ a callback function is not defined.

Signed-off-by: Mauricio Faria de Oliveira 
Fixes: 08024885a2a3 ("ses: Add power_status to SES device slot")
---

v2:
 - remove module parameter.
 - better return values for -1/uninitalized power_status.
   (thanks: Dan Williams )

 drivers/misc/enclosure.c | 7 ++-
 drivers/scsi/ses.c   | 1 -
 2 files changed, 6 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)

diff --git a/drivers/misc/enclosure.c b/drivers/misc/enclosure.c
index 65fed7146e9b..d3fe3ea902d4 100644
--- a/drivers/misc/enclosure.c
+++ b/drivers/misc/enclosure.c
@@ -148,7 +148,7 @@ struct enclosure_device *
for (i = 0; i < components; i++) {
edev->component[i].number = -1;
edev->component[i].slot = -1;
-   edev->component[i].power_status = 1;
+   edev->component[i].power_status = -1;
}
 
mutex_lock(_list_lock);
@@ -594,6 +594,11 @@ static ssize_t get_component_power_status(struct device 
*cdev,
 
if (edev->cb->get_power_status)
edev->cb->get_power_status(edev, ecomp);
+
+   /* If still uninitialized, the callback failed or does not exist. */
+   if (ecomp->power_status == -1)
+   return (edev->cb->get_power_status) ? -EIO : -ENOTTY;
+
return snprintf(buf, 40, "%s\n", ecomp->power_status ? "on" : "off");
 }
 
diff --git a/drivers/scsi/ses.c b/drivers/scsi/ses.c
index 50adabbb5808..f1cdf32d7514 100644
--- a/drivers/scsi/ses.c
+++ b/drivers/scsi/ses.c
@@ -548,7 +548,6 @@ static void ses_enclosure_data_process(struct 
enclosure_device *edev,
ecomp = >component[components++];
 
if (!IS_ERR(ecomp)) {
-   ses_get_power_status(edev, ecomp);
if (addl_desc_ptr)
ses_process_descriptor(
ecomp,
-- 
1.8.3.1