Michèle, thank you for your response. I'm Cc'ing the macports-users
mailing list again to try to direct the discussion back there.
On Jul 5, 2007, at 20:52, Michèle Garoche wrote:
Le 5 juil. 2007 à 23:46, Ryan Schmidt a écrit :
On Jul 5, 2007, at 15:56, Mack Johnson wrote:
Hi, could someone please update bluefish-1.0.7 thank you.
That would typically be the maintainer's job. I'm Cc'ing the
bluefish maintainer on this email.
I'm sorry, but I'm not the maintainer of the bluefish macport. I
was only mentionned by the previous maintainer, because I shared
the patches made for the Fink port with him.
Actually, there seems to be no more maintainer for the bluefish
macport. There is also no more Fink port maintainer and French
translator for bluefish, as I have no more time for both jobs.
Well, you were made a comaintainer of bluefish in December 2005:
http://trac.macosforge.org/projects/macports/changeset/15530
And the other maintainer dropped maintainership of most (all?) of his
ports in March 2006:
http://trac.macosforge.org/projects/macports/changeset/17264
Leaving you as the only maintainer of bluefish. But if you don't have
time to maintain it and did not want to be its maintainer, then I'll
set it to nomaintainer.
http://trac.macosforge.org/projects/macports/changeset/26756
Here a recent reply about the same request:
quote
Le 3 juil. 2007 à 01:06, Malcolm Fitzgerald a écrit :
Hi Michele,
I've just downloaded the source code for bluefish v1.0.7 and
compiled it. No alterations or special configuration required on
my iBook PPC G3 600MHz OSX10.3.9
I wonder if it can be included in MacPorts?
Well, as you want.
What I can say about it after thorough testing, is that it is has
critical bugs, leading to data loss; that's why I refused to port
it to Fink. Example: try to open in two different instances of
bluefish the same file and change one of them. Or try to open two
windows in the same instance of bluefish, load the same file in
them, and make changes in one of it. Very weird for translators
job. Etc... Play extensively with plugins, images, remote
connection and you will see what I mean.
Moreover, if you dare to inspect the configuration files in depth,
you will find that instead of using standard process, it reinvents
the wheel and make drunky-man (to say it mildy) assumption of
where libraries or binaries are.
And last the UI, though completely internationalized, does not
load properly when using non English system. Just to give an
example: about screen, thus leading to ignore translators credits,
that is not respecting the licence. Severe bug to me.
All of these problems you mentioned -- have they just appeared in
bluefish 1.0.6 or 1.0.7? or do they exist in 1.0.5 too? If these
problems just appeared in recent versions, then sure, that would be a
reason that we should not update the port.
You may think I'm too restrictive, but for me a good-to-be-ported
software is not only one which compiles (that's a minimal
requirement, is not it?), but also one which runs correctly under
any system configuration.
If you look for alternative, screem is far better. Perhaps not so
polished, but at least it does not crash every five minutes. It
needs some tweakings in configuration files from cvs, but nothing
difficult.
Also tea is interesting as having special features I've never
encountered in any software. It needs some rewriting in graphics
parts, but nothing especially difficult.
/quote
For me the latest stable and good running version of bluefish was
1.0.5, more recent versions are too buggy for my taste. Obviously,
that should not impede anybody other than me to port it to MacPort
and why not to Fink while at it if so desired :-)
Thank you, Michèle, for the detailed explanation. Though I'll admit
I'm not reading it very closely since I don't even know what bluefish
is; I was just responding to a request on the mailing list to get the
port updated, and attempted to forward it on to the responsible party.
So, Mack: is there a specific reason why you need bluefish 1.0.7, or
would 1.0.5 be enough? Or have you already tried 1.0.7 and found it
to work properly?
___
macports-users mailing list
macports-users@lists.macosforge.org
http://lists.macosforge.org/mailman/listinfo/macports-users
