atlas G5 upgrade issue?

2011-05-11 Thread Ivan Kawaler
When I went to upgrade atlas, I found it claiming it would be  
compiling for the G4 architecture (ppc) on a G5 (ppc64) machine, and  
that it would lead to inferior performance.  I do not recall seeing  
this on previous install/upgrades of atlas.  Does atlas have support  
for the G5 architecture?  If it does, what is preventing it from  
compiling for a G5?  Does anyone know of a workaround?  I'm on a G5,  
obviously, with MacPorts 1.9.2, and gcc 4.4.6.

___
macports-users mailing list
macports-users@lists.macosforge.org
http://lists.macosforge.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/macports-users


Re: atlas G5 upgrade issue?

2011-05-11 Thread vincent habchi
Hi Ivan,

 When I went to upgrade atlas, I found it claiming it would be compiling for 
 the G4 architecture (ppc) on a G5 (ppc64) machine, and that it would lead to 
 inferior performance.  I do not recall seeing this on previous 
 install/upgrades of atlas.  Does atlas have support for the G5 architecture?  
 If it does, what is preventing it from compiling for a G5?  Does anyone know 
 of a workaround?  I'm on a G5, obviously, with MacPorts 1.9.2, and gcc 4.4.6.

I wrote a G5 support (ppc64) for Atlas, but it was difficult to debug. At a 
certain point in time, somebody pointed out that G5 floating point performance 
was not so different from G4, and that 64-bit instructions would fill the cache 
more quickly and maybe result in inferior performance. That's why I quit the 
ppc64 idea and fused both into a single ppc option. But if somebody is able to 
settle the G4/G5 dispute with definitive data about FP computing, I'll be happy 
to try to raise the ppc64 options from the deads.

Vincent

___
macports-users mailing list
macports-users@lists.macosforge.org
http://lists.macosforge.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/macports-users