Re: Is 213.215.28.0/23 (AS 49463) announced through AS 12670 and AS 13193

2009-09-07 Thread Laurent CARON
On Sat, Sep 05, 2009 at 04:04:33PM +0200, Laurent CARON wrote:
 Hi,

 I did set-up this netblock behind two pipes.

 One on AS13193 (which is working flawlessy), and ahother on AS12670  
 (which I doubt of).

 Can please any of you tell me if from your location 213.215.28.0 is  
 reachable through AS12670 ?

Hi,

It seems the netblock 213.215.28.0/23 is now reachable through AS13193
and AS12670.

Thanks

Laurent



Re: Is 213.215.28.0/23 (AS 49463) announced through AS 12670 and AS 13193

2009-09-07 Thread Suresh Ramasubramanian
Yup. Compare this current radb lookup -

sur...@frodo 09:53:21 :~$ whois -h whois.radb.net 213.215.28.0/23
route:  213.215.28.0/23
descr:  LNC-1
origin: AS49463
mnt-by: NERIM-MNT
changed:boua...@nerim.net 20090907
source: RIPE

with the previous one -

sur...@frodo 19:59:40 :~$ whois -h whois.radb.net 213.215.28.0
route:  213.215.0.0/18
descr:  NERIM-213-215
origin: AS13193
holes:  213.215.38.0/24
mnt-by: NERIM-MNT
changed:boua...@nerim.net 20020827
changed:boua...@nerim.net 20081107
source: RIPE


On Mon, Sep 7, 2009 at 9:17 PM, Laurent CARONlca...@unix-scripts.info wrote:
 On Sat, Sep 05, 2009 at 04:04:33PM +0200, Laurent CARON wrote:
 Hi,

 I did set-up this netblock behind two pipes.

 One on AS13193 (which is working flawlessy), and ahother on AS12670
 (which I doubt of).

 Can please any of you tell me if from your location 213.215.28.0 is
 reachable through AS12670 ?

 Hi,

 It seems the netblock 213.215.28.0/23 is now reachable through AS13193
 and AS12670.

 Thanks

 Laurent





-- 
Suresh Ramasubramanian (ops.li...@gmail.com)



Re: Is 213.215.28.0/23 (AS 49463) announced through AS 12670 and AS 13193

2009-09-07 Thread Laurent CARON

On 07/09/2009 19:01, Suresh Ramasubramanian wrote:

Yup. Compare this current radb lookup -

sur...@frodo 09:53:21 :~$ whois -h whois.radb.net 213.215.28.0/23
route:  213.215.28.0/23
descr:  LNC-1
origin: AS49463
mnt-by: NERIM-MNT
changed:boua...@nerim.net 20090907
source: RIPE

with the previous one -

sur...@frodo 19:59:40 :~$ whois -h whois.radb.net 213.215.28.0
route:  213.215.0.0/18
descr:  NERIM-213-215
origin: AS13193
holes:  213.215.38.0/24
mnt-by: NERIM-MNT
changed:boua...@nerim.net 20020827
changed:boua...@nerim.net 20081107
source: RIPE


A hole in 213.215.0.0/18 was missing and has been added by the 1st ISP.



Is 213.215.28.0/23 (AS 49463) announced through AS 12670 and AS 13193

2009-09-05 Thread Laurent CARON

Hi,

I did set-up this netblock behind two pipes.

One on AS13193 (which is working flawlessy), and ahother on AS12670 
(which I doubt of).


Can please any of you tell me if from your location 213.215.28.0 is 
reachable through AS12670 ?


Thanks

Laurent



Re: Is 213.215.28.0/23 (AS 49463) announced through AS 12670 and AS 13193

2009-09-05 Thread Nicolas DEFFAYET
On Sat, 2009-09-05 at 16:04 +0200, Laurent CARON wrote:
Hi Laurent,

 I did set-up this netblock behind two pipes.
 
 One on AS13193 (which is working flawlessy), and ahother on AS12670 
 (which I doubt of).
 
 Can please any of you tell me if from your location 213.215.28.0 is 
 reachable through AS12670 ?

We, Novso AS25358, see only your route through Nerim AS13193.

frpar-msr4sh ip bgp 213.215.28.0
BGP routing table entry for 213.215.28.0/23, version 16779890
Paths: (3 available, best #3, table Default-IP-Routing-Table)
  Not advertised to any peer
  13193 49463
194.68.129.181 from 194.68.129.181 (194.79.131.249)
  Origin IGP, metric 240, localpref 200, valid, external
  Community: 25358:2000 25358:2020 25358:7000 25358:8000 25358:9000
  13193 49463, (received-only)
194.68.129.181 from 194.68.129.181 (194.79.131.249)
  Origin IGP, metric 100, localpref 100, valid, external
  13193 49463, (received  used)
195.140.149.5 (metric 200) from 195.140.149.5 (195.140.149.5)
  Origin IGP, metric 200, localpref 200, valid, internal, best
  Community: 25358:2000 25358:2050 25358:7000 25358:8000 25358:9000

Our peering session with Completel AS12670:
frpar-msr4sh ip bgp sum | i 12670
194.68.129.188  4 12670  104682  103276 1933504600 1d08h
195
frpar-msr4sh ip bgp nei 194.68.129.188 received-routes | i 213.215.28.0
frpar-msr4

Our peering session with Nerim AS13193:
frpar-msr4sh ip bgp sum | i 13193
194.68.129.181  4 13193  103945  103222 1933504600 1d08h
33

frpar-msr4sh ip bgp nei 194.68.129.181 received-routes | i 213.215.28.0
*  213.215.28.0/23  194.68.129.181 100 0 13193 49463
i
frpar-msr4


Completel AS12670 don't announce your route 213.215.28.0/23 to their
peers so your route is only visible through Nerim AS13193.

Did you announce your route 213.215.28.0/23 to Completel AS12670 ?


Best Regards,

-- 
Nicolas DEFFAYET (AS25358)




Re: Is 213.215.28.0/23 (AS 49463) announced through AS 12670 and AS 13193

2009-09-05 Thread Laurent CARON

On 05/09/2009 16:30, Nicolas DEFFAYET wrote:

Completel AS12670 don't announce your route 213.215.28.0/23 to their
peers so your route is only visible through Nerim AS13193.

Did you announce your route 213.215.28.0/23 to Completel AS12670 ?


Hi,

I'm of course announcing it to their upstream router.

If their upstream router actually forwards it to its neighbors is 
another question...which I can't unfortunately not answer. But I guess 
the announce is not propagated outside of their network...


Thanks for your help.

Laurent



Re: Is 213.215.28.0/23 (AS 49463) announced through AS 12670 and AS 13193

2009-09-05 Thread Suresh Ramasubramanian
This might explain it ..

sur...@frodo 19:59:40 :~$ whois -h whois.radb.net 213.215.28.0
route:  213.215.0.0/18
descr:  NERIM-213-215
origin: AS13193
holes:  213.215.38.0/24
mnt-by: NERIM-MNT
changed:boua...@nerim.net 20020827
changed:boua...@nerim.net 20081107
source: RIPE

You need to update radb with your other prefix.  See
http://www.radb.net/rfc2622.html

On Sat, Sep 5, 2009 at 10:02 PM, Laurent CARONlca...@unix-scripts.info wrote:
 On 05/09/2009 16:30, Nicolas DEFFAYET wrote:

 Completel AS12670 don't announce your route 213.215.28.0/23 to their
 peers so your route is only visible through Nerim AS13193.

 Did you announce your route 213.215.28.0/23 to Completel AS12670 ?

 Hi,

 I'm of course announcing it to their upstream router.

 If their upstream router actually forwards it to its neighbors is another
 question...which I can't unfortunately not answer. But I guess the announce
 is not propagated outside of their network...

 Thanks for your help.

 Laurent





-- 
Suresh Ramasubramanian (ops.li...@gmail.com)