Interesting perspective. The interview questions were well-researched and posed
quite pointedly as one might expect.
Otherwise, it seemed that both generals had their own biases, some ideological.
Chauhan was clearly either an apologist for Russia or badly informed ("We don’t
know what the Ukrainians think about their President." It seems clear we do
know that Ukrainains, even those who opposed him, are resisting the invasion
and supporting Zelinsky. "30% of Eastern Ukrainians are pro-Russian." Actually
they are Russian speakers: so is Zelinsky. That doesn’t make them sympathetic
to a Russian invasion. This is almost a Putin talking point.) That said,
Chauhan, while an apologist for Russian military failure, did make a plausible
argument that this first invasion force, was simply a reconnaissance force and
that the main invasion would be launched later. If I am recalling correctly, he
was dead wrong about the impression that Russian bombing campaigns are making
abroad; he was right that they are designed to wreak havoc on the Ukrainian
population. How finely calibrated they are, is up for grabs. Putin has not
appeared “rational,” by offering humanitarian corridors leading to Russia,
though his larger strategy has proved formidable.
I was especially interested in the discussion of Indian military procurement.
What happens if Russia can’t supply parts for Indian Migs? General Hasnain
suggested that Russia was having problems sourcing parts for its own aircraft
in Ukraine. General Chauhan simply asserted that the supply to India was
guaranteed. Hasnain seemed a bit more skeptical about Russian military
competence; not sure if that makes him “pro-western.” He certainly made a point
of disavowing “western” strategic analysis of the situation in Ukraine. In any
case, India has been constrained by military dependence on Russia for arms on
joining any international boycott. There will certainly be some longterm price
to pay for that, especially as India tries to ramp up its homegrown tech
industry. I would predict a slow-down in US technology transfer, though there
are other places they can go. And what’s the future of US visas for Indian
engineers? In these matters, financial considerations will likely take
precedence over morality. India has a surfeit of highly trained engineers with
inadequate employment opportunities at home. That can be a formula for civil
discontent as we have seen in North Africa.
Ironically, both generals agreed that military procurement and military
self-sufficiency were long-terms issues and the difficult point of Pakistan as
part of the Euriasian/Belt and Road initiative also provided insights.
So far, India has been relying on Russia’s support against China in their
border disputes, at least in the form of weapons I think they sense that
support is tenuous as Pakistan is central to the Eurasian project as well as
stability in Russian client states with large Muslim populations. Who knows who
is going to get played; the Pakistani military have been playing the US for
years. Russia is not in a position of strength here, nor is China, though
Pakistan has bought in to Belt and Road. One has to wonder about blow-back in
Pakistan concerning the Chinese treatment of Uighur Muslims. Pakistan is a
country where blasphemy (against Islam) carries the death penalty, even if it’s
seldom enforced. What happens if Pakistan launches an offensive in Kashmir at
the same time China attacks in its disputed border regions with India? Neither
regions are particularly hospitable to Russian made tank warfare, if I am not
mistaken.
One final point: Did Putin’s threat to use nuclear weapons effectively
“checkmate" a military response from Europe and NATO, as the interviewer
suggests? Perhaps it's simply a gambit, in short, a bluff. What if the US or
Europe were to call that bluff, or make military countermoves, like those
Polish Migs. Whoops.
Guess it’s time to remove my armchair general’s uniform.
Keith
> On Mar 10, 2022, at 1:21 PM, patrice riemens wrote:
>
> नमस्ते ,
>
> "When India speaks, the world listens" -Jawaharlal Nehru
>
> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mwj3WtrQZaw
>
>
> (20m46s)
>
> (with thanks to Harv S)
>
> सत्यमेव जयते !
> p+7D!
> # distributed via : no commercial use without permission
> #is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
> # collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
> # more info: http://mx.kein.org/mailman/listinfo/nettime-l
> # archive: http://www.nettime.org contact: nett...@kein.org
> # @nettime_bot tweets mail w/ sender unless #ANON is in Subject:
# distributed via : no commercial use without permission
#is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
# collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
# more info: http://mx.kein.org/mailman/listinfo/nettime-l
# archive: http://www.nettime.org contact:
