Lawrence Horvath wrote:
have you considered percentages?
Using percentages is equivalent to using the corresponding values.
It doesn't solve my problem.
or using a script to inject ips into
a tables based queue setup?
I already use a script to generate the pf.conf file, but I cannot
understand what do you mean with tables based queue.
How can it change the way the bandwidth in excess is distributed between
queues?
Bye.
On 16/04/07, Federico Giannici [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
As there was no reply to this email of mine, anybody can tell me if
there is some other place where I can submit this question?
At least, anybody can tell me if my theory about bandwidth assignments
is wrong?
Thanks.
Federico Giannici wrote:
I have a problem creating a policy to make a fair use of available
bandwidth in a situation with a lot of potential users.
We have a certain number of users, each one with a committed bandwidth
of X or Y. We setup a queue system with an HFSC queue for each user,
with a bandwidth (linkshare parameter) proportional to X or Y.
This system doesn't seem to work in a fair way: when an user does a
HUGE
download with a very large number of packets and bytes per second, it
steals almost all bandwidth to the other users requiring only a little
of bandwidth.
It seems that the borrowed bandwidth is distributed to the queues based
on the amount of required packets (or bytes). Indeed I'd like that the
bandwidth is distributed strictly proportional to the assigned
bandwidth.
Let's make and example:
Both users A and B have an assigned bandwidth of 1 bps.
User A currently requires 4 bps.
User B currently requires 100 bps.
There are currently available 10 bps.
I'd like that the 10 bps would be equally distributed to both users (as
they have the same assigned bandwidth), so both had 5 bps. User A
uses 4
bps and leaves 1 bps to user B that so uses 6 bps.
Indeed it seems that, as user B requires 25 times more bandwidth of
user
A, then it is assigned almost ALL bandwidth, and user A is not able to
use more then it's committed 1 bps, and so 3 out of 4 bits are dropped!
Is this true?
Is there a way to obtain my desired behavior?
Please note that I cannot simply increase the commited bandwidth of
both
users to 5 bps because there are a lot of other potential users (that
currently are not using bandwidth) so the sum of bandwidths would
exceeds the bandwidth of the parent queue.
Thanks.
--
___
__
|- [EMAIL PROTECTED]
|ederico Giannici http://www.neomedia.it
___
