Re: RfC: pre-LC version of Screen Orientation; deadline August 18

[Marcos Caceres]

On August 14, 2014 at 3:23:23 AM, Dominique Hazael-Massieux (d...@w3.org) wrote:
> > HTH,

It does! thank you. I've filed a bug for each on GH. 

https://github.com/w3c/screen-orientation/issues/

Hope to fix 'em up soon! 

Re: RfC: pre-LC version of Screen Orientation; deadline August 18

[Dominique Hazael-Massieux]

Le lundi 04 août 2014 à 08:19 -0400, Arthur Barstow a écrit :
> Marcos and Mounir, the Editors of WebApps' Screen Orientation API, 
> consider their spec feature complete with only a few minor [Bugs] open. 
> As such, we seek wide review on their "pre-LC" version:
> 
>
> 
> If you have any comments, please send them to public-webapps by August 
> 18 (and if you and/or your group need more time, please let me know.) We 
> also welcome data about "silent reviews", f.ex. "I reviewed section N.N 
> and have no comments".

A few comments:
* Promise should be Promise from my reading of WebIDL

* in the last paragraph of 5.1, the phrase "the screen as it is drawn"
was unclear to me until I read the lock orientation algorithm where the
phrase "the viewport is drawn" made it clearer; maybe the two can be
alined

* shouldn't the "apply an orientation lock" algorithm make reference to
the event firing? I was having trouble understanding steps 8.2 and 8.3
in the former until I arrived to the latter

* while I understand there is ongoing discussion on alignments with
DeviceOrientation, I'm less clear there is work to ensure consistency
with css-device-adapt; in particular, it seems like it would be useful
to understand how the two approaches work together when use
simultaneously

HTH,

Dom

RfC: pre-LC version of Screen Orientation; deadline August 18

[Arthur Barstow]

[ Bcc: www-tag, public-script-coord, public-web-security, 
public-web-mobile ; please Reply-to: public-webapps ]


Hi All,

Marcos and Mounir, the Editors of WebApps' Screen Orientation API, 
consider their spec feature complete with only a few minor [Bugs] open. 
As such, we seek wide review on their "pre-LC" version:


  

If you have any comments, please send them to public-webapps by August 
18 (and if you and/or your group need more time, please let me know.) We 
also welcome data about "silent reviews", f.ex. "I reviewed section N.N 
and have no comments".


TAG, TC-39, Web Security IG, Web Mobile IG - we are especially 
interested in your feedback.


-Thanks, AB

[Bugs]