Alec Koumjian akoumj...@gmail.com added the comment:
I apologize if this is the wrong place for this message. I did not see the link
to a separate list.
First let me explain what I am trying to accomplish. I would like to be able to
take an unknown regular expression that contains both named and unnamed groups
and tag their location in the original string where a match was found. Take the
following redundantly simple example:
a_string = rThis is a demo sentence.
pattern = r(?a_thing\w+) (\w+) (?another_thing\w+)
m = regex.search(pattern, a_string)
What I want is a way to insert named/numbered tags into the original string, so
that it looks something like this:
ra_thingThis/a_thing 2is/2 another_thinga/another_thing demo
sentence.
The syntax doesn't have to be exactly like that, but you get the place. I have
inserted the names and/or indices of the groups into the original string,
around the span that the groups occupy.
This task is exceedingly difficult with the current implementation, unless I am
missing something obvious. We could call the groups by index, the groups as a
tuple, or the groupdict:
m.group(1)
'This'
m.groups()
('This', 'is', 'a')
m.groupdict()
{'another_thing': 'a', 'a_thing': 'This'}
If all I wanted was to tag the groups by index, it would be a simple function.
I would be able to call m.spans() for each index in the length of m.groups()
and insert the and / tags around the right indices.
The hard part is finding out how to find the spans of the named groups. Do any
of you have a suggestion?
It would make more sense from my perspective, if each group was an object that
had its own .span property. It would work like this with the above example:
first = m.group(1)
first.name()
'a_thing'
second = m.group(2)
second.name()
None
You could still call .spans() on the Match object itself, but it would query
its children group objects for the data. Overall I think this would be a much
more Pythonic approach, especially given that you have added subscripting and
key lookup.
So instead of this:
m['a_thing']
'This'
type(m['a_thing'])
type 'str'
You could have:
m['a_thing']
'This'
type(m['a_thing'])
'regex.Match.Group object'
With the noted benefit of this:
m['a_thing'].span()
(0, 4)
m['a_thing'].index()
1
Maybe I'm missing a major point or functionality here, but I've been pouring
over the docs and don't currently think what I'm trying to achieve is possible.
Thank you for taking the time to read all this.
-Alec
--
nosy: +akoumjian
versions: -Python 3.3
___
Python tracker rep...@bugs.python.org
http://bugs.python.org/issue2636
___
___
Python-bugs-list mailing list
Unsubscribe:
http://mail.python.org/mailman/options/python-bugs-list/archive%40mail-archive.com
