Re: Flame Bait: Using Qmail as a front-line mail server

2001-08-09 Thread Adam Nealis

 --- Sean Chittenden [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: 
 * Exchange box is firewalled and boarded up and placed behind wallboard
Except you can't do that with an NT box because
you'll need access to reboot it every so many days
and you can't do that remotely out of the box ;).


Do You Yahoo!?
Get your free @yahoo.co.uk address at http://mail.yahoo.co.uk
or your free @yahoo.ie address at http://mail.yahoo.ie



Re: Flame Bait: Using Qmail as a front-line mail server

2001-08-09 Thread Ross Cooney



enough anti Microsoft shit and lets get on with life.

Ross
[moved to mutt from Outlook for this listperfer Outlook]


On Thu, Aug 09, 2001 at 09:17:24AM +0100, Adam Nealis wrote:
  --- Sean Chittenden [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: 
  * Exchange box is firewalled and boarded up and placed behind wallboard
 Except you can't do that with an NT box because
 you'll need access to reboot it every so many days
 and you can't do that remotely out of the box ;).
 
 
 Do You Yahoo!?
 Get your free @yahoo.co.uk address at http://mail.yahoo.co.uk
 or your free @yahoo.ie address at http://mail.yahoo.ie



Re: Flame Bait: Using Qmail as a front-line mail server

2001-08-09 Thread Russell Nelson

Steve writes:
  1.  Is it possible to list the Qmail server as the primary MX record and
  still forward the mail to its final destination?  All my research
  says no, but I need to be certain.

Use smtproutes.  It essentially functions as an MX record with
priority -1 (in other words, a stronger priority than any possible MX
record).

The other way you could do it is with split DNS.  djbdns
(http://www.djbdns.org) makes split DNS trivially easy.

-- 
-russ nelson [EMAIL PROTECTED]  http://russnelson.com
Crynwr sells support for free software  | PGPok | 
521 Pleasant Valley Rd. | +1 315 268 1925 voice | All extremists should
Potsdam, NY 13676-3213  | +1 315 268 9201 FAX   | be shot.



Re: Flame Bait: Using Qmail as a front-line mail server

2001-08-08 Thread Alex Pennace

On Mon, Aug 06, 2001 at 09:00:46PM -0400, Steve wrote:
 1.  Is it possible to list the Qmail server as the primary MX record and
 
 still forward the mail to its final destination?  All my research says
 no,
 but I need to be certain.

Yes, use smtproutes. See the manual page for qmail-remote.



Re: Flame Bait: Using Qmail as a front-line mail server

2001-08-08 Thread Sean Chittenden

  1.  Is it possible to list the Qmail server as the primary MX record and
  
  still forward the mail to its final destination?  All my research says
  no,
  but I need to be certain.
 
 Yes, use smtproutes. See the manual page for qmail-remote.

Or create a ton of forwarding rules (.qmail for starters).  
qmail works as a great buffer between the internet and an Exchange 
server.

* [EMAIL PROTECTED]   -  qmail box

* qmail box looks up .qmail file for user

* qmail forwards to [EMAIL PROTECTED]

* corp.example.com is exchange and accepts mail for the user from
corp.example.com

* Exchange routes all outgoing mail to the qmail box as [EMAIL PROTECTED]

* Exchange box is firewalled and boarded up and placed behind wallboard


-sc

-- 
Sean Chittenden

 PGP signature


Flame Bait: Using Qmail as a front-line mail server

2001-08-06 Thread Steve

First, let me say I've searched the archives, Google and numerous other
sources BEFORE I decided to post this.  I do not desire the attacks that
the
qmail list is infamous for.

The company I work for, a mid-sized ISP, uses Sendmail as the primary
MTA
for our clients.  Given the downturn in the economy, my superiors are
very
reluctant to budget any kind of switch to Qmail despite my best
efforts.  As
a result, I am stuck with running Qmail on secondary servers.   Now the
point:

Unfortunately, our systems were extremely overloaded by the SirCam
virus,
and I have been tasked with finding a solution.  While I could simply
find
one that incorporates with Sendmail, I believe this will simply overload
our
primary mail server.  Therefore, I want to use one of the servers
running
Qmail to do the virus scanning and then send the mail to the primary
mail
server.  Both incoming and outgoing mail must be scanned.  Here is my
question:

1.  Is it possible to list the Qmail server as the primary MX record and

still forward the mail to its final destination?  All my research says
no,
but I need to be certain.

2.  If #1 is possible, could your generously provide some real world
suggestions on how this can be done?

Thank you,

-- Steve





Re: Flame Bait: Using Qmail as a front-line mail server

2001-08-06 Thread MarkD

 1.  Is it possible to list the Qmail server as the primary MX record and
 
 still forward the mail to its final destination?  All my research says
 no,
 but I need to be certain.

It's trivial. smtproutes is your friend.

 2.  If #1 is possible, could your generously provide some real world
 suggestions on how this can be done?

It'd be helpful to know the real names of the domains and machines
involved, then we could give you a real world config entry, but
assuming the MX domain is example.com and the ultimate mail server
running sendmail is sendmail.example.com, then:

echo example.com:sendmail.example.com /var/qmail/control/smtproutes

No restarts are needed. Just change your MX to point to the qmail
machine and you're done. Of course you need to make sure that
example.com isn't in locals and virtualdomains.

It'll be interesting to know how you plan to catch Sircam with this
though...


Regards.



Re: Flame Bait: Using Qmail as a front-line mail server

2001-08-06 Thread Dean Staff

On 7 Aug 2001, at 1:09, MarkD wrote:

  1.  Is it possible to list the Qmail server as the primary MX record
  and
  
  still forward the mail to its final destination?  All my research
  says no, but I need to be certain.
 
 It's trivial. smtproutes is your friend.
 

So true! I use it to do just this... We have redundant servers on mutliple net-
links. if one link dies, mail is routed via MX entries to the secondary server, 
which then forwards it via out internal network to the final destination server.

Works like a charm. The other nice thing is that if it's the primary server itself 
that died, then the seconary server will hold the mail until we bring the 
primary back on line.
  

  2.  If #1 is possible, could your generously provide some real world
  suggestions on how this can be done?
 
 It'd be helpful to know the real names of the domains and machines
 involved, then we could give you a real world config entry, but
 assuming the MX domain is example.com and the ultimate mail server
 running sendmail is sendmail.example.com, then:
 
 echo example.com:sendmail.example.com /var/qmail/control/smtproutes
 
 No restarts are needed. Just change your MX to point to the qmail
 machine and you're done. Of course you need to make sure that
 example.com isn't in locals and virtualdomains.
 

Good point... If you have your Sendmail boxes domain listed in the 
secondary servers locals or virtualdomains files, you will end up delivering 
the mail locally to the secondary server. Just remember locals take priority 
over virtualdomains, and virtualdomains take proirity over smtproutes.

 It'll be interesting to know how you plan to catch Sircam with this
 though...
 

Definately, please post!

BTW, for the record, I switched all my primary Sendmail boxes to qmail for 
little or no cost. (I chose to pay to register 3 e-smith servers, but you can 
grab the iso for free from their ftp site) The other nice things is that I find 
qmail can handle running on lower end equipment and still give you the 
same if not better performance than a Sendmail box. 

Cheers
Dean


Dean Staff
Protus IP Solutions
210 - 2379 Holly Lane
Ottawa, ON K1V 7P2 Canada
613-733- ex 546 Fax 613-248-4553
e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Web: http://www.protus.com




Re: Flame Bait: Using Qmail as a front-line mail server

2001-08-06 Thread David Talkington

-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-

Dean Staff wrote:

qmail can handle running on lower end equipment

Except for its unfortunate habit of laying bare the i/o bottlenecks
you never knew you had.

;-)

- -d

- -- 
David Talkington
http://www.spotnet.org

PGP key: http://www.prairienet.org/~dtalk/dt000823.asc

-BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-
Version: PGP 6.5.8
Comment: Made with pgp4pine 1.75-6

iQEVAwUBO2+BNr1ZYOtSwT+tAQHgnAf+LRLuElYi7P7LLjqNH+xfjCalJBlbThtq
7stgiatYclo2AOJZVE1XRft3aDbNr0CzGRRBpJQG99H4tsRF75PlrQ4sjiufti19
jxVC2ZpAEIb3sTm0JNt5W98WZXZqqeUeqgicSYRPNXRgum7rdpIKEYoMNhmge3d9
z5Grm6um+pbBEZWpw3ZynFrLfAwRPfkV7+4Uy9migY6xTfZiuEXnZaT59qrr7nAA
5OlO31P8n4XcATZtzRhVV0sDwyF2F2ktuxRO/PG5qWGcP+/IQvUbrzS4LMfWEmOK
sCruWYoHsmW9ZxgsIz/44PH7hKhImBfCr/5Mm+QO5061XaSIPgiIYA==
=NxFz
-END PGP SIGNATURE-