Re: Jetty Vs Tomcat (Performance issue)
Upayavira:: Just to be sure, are you installing Solr inside a different Jetty, or using the Jetty that comes with Solr? *Behzad:: *Jetty that comes with solr. Jetty-8.1.10.v20130312 Embedded Solr 4.10.3 Also used Jetty9 but not embedded. Tried solr 4.10.3 with Jetty 9 but still facing same issue. Ishan:: Also, what are the specific performance issues you are observing? *Behzad:: *Elapsed time (QTime) of SOLR with Jetty is more than Elapsed time of Tomcat. Timothy:: I hope 256MB of Xss is a typo and you really meant 256k right? *Behzad:: *Right. My bad. On Tue, Nov 17, 2015 at 3:17 AM, Timothy Potter wrote: > I hope 256MB of Xss is a typo and you really meant 256k right? > > > On Mon, Nov 16, 2015 at 4:58 AM, Behzad Qureshi > wrote: > > Hi All, > > > > I am using Tomcat server with solr 4.10.3. I want to shift to Jetty as > > replacement of Tomcat server but I am not getting any good results with > > respect to performance. I have tried solr 4.10.3 on both Jetty 8 and > Jetty > > 9 with java 8. Below are configurations I have used. > > > > Can anyone please tell me if I am missing anything? > > > > *Jetty:* > > > > Xms: 5GB > > Xmx: 50GB > > Xss: 256MB > > > > > > *Tomcat:* > > > > Xms: 5GB > > Xmx: 50GB > > Xss: Default > > > > > > *Index Size:* > > > > 1TB (20 cores) > > > > > > > > -- > > > > Regards, > > > > Behzad Qureshi > -- Regards, Behzad Qureshi Senior Software Engineer | NorthBay Solutions (Pvt.) Ltd 410-G4, Johar Town, Lahore, Pakistan Ph: +92 42 35290152-56 Skype ID: behzadqureshi.nbs
Re: Jetty Vs Tomcat (Performance issue)
I hope 256MB of Xss is a typo and you really meant 256k right? On Mon, Nov 16, 2015 at 4:58 AM, Behzad Qureshi wrote: > Hi All, > > I am using Tomcat server with solr 4.10.3. I want to shift to Jetty as > replacement of Tomcat server but I am not getting any good results with > respect to performance. I have tried solr 4.10.3 on both Jetty 8 and Jetty > 9 with java 8. Below are configurations I have used. > > Can anyone please tell me if I am missing anything? > > *Jetty:* > > Xms: 5GB > Xmx: 50GB > Xss: 256MB > > > *Tomcat:* > > Xms: 5GB > Xmx: 50GB > Xss: Default > > > *Index Size:* > > 1TB (20 cores) > > > > -- > > Regards, > > Behzad Qureshi
Re: Jetty Vs Tomcat (Performance issue)
Also, what are the specific performance issues you are observing? On Mon, Nov 16, 2015 at 6:41 PM, Upayavira wrote: > Just to be sure, are you installing Solr inside a different Jetty, or > using the Jetty that comes with Solr? > > You would be expected to use the one installed and managed by Solr. > > Upayavira > > On Mon, Nov 16, 2015, at 11:58 AM, Behzad Qureshi wrote: > > Hi All, > > > > I am using Tomcat server with solr 4.10.3. I want to shift to Jetty as > > replacement of Tomcat server but I am not getting any good results with > > respect to performance. I have tried solr 4.10.3 on both Jetty 8 and > > Jetty > > 9 with java 8. Below are configurations I have used. > > > > Can anyone please tell me if I am missing anything? > > > > *Jetty:* > > > > Xms: 5GB > > Xmx: 50GB > > Xss: 256MB > > > > > > *Tomcat:* > > > > Xms: 5GB > > Xmx: 50GB > > Xss: Default > > > > > > *Index Size:* > > > > 1TB (20 cores) > > > > > > > > -- > > > > Regards, > > > > Behzad Qureshi >
Re: Jetty Vs Tomcat (Performance issue)
Just to be sure, are you installing Solr inside a different Jetty, or using the Jetty that comes with Solr? You would be expected to use the one installed and managed by Solr. Upayavira On Mon, Nov 16, 2015, at 11:58 AM, Behzad Qureshi wrote: > Hi All, > > I am using Tomcat server with solr 4.10.3. I want to shift to Jetty as > replacement of Tomcat server but I am not getting any good results with > respect to performance. I have tried solr 4.10.3 on both Jetty 8 and > Jetty > 9 with java 8. Below are configurations I have used. > > Can anyone please tell me if I am missing anything? > > *Jetty:* > > Xms: 5GB > Xmx: 50GB > Xss: 256MB > > > *Tomcat:* > > Xms: 5GB > Xmx: 50GB > Xss: Default > > > *Index Size:* > > 1TB (20 cores) > > > > -- > > Regards, > > Behzad Qureshi
Jetty Vs Tomcat (Performance issue)
Hi All, I am using Tomcat server with solr 4.10.3. I want to shift to Jetty as replacement of Tomcat server but I am not getting any good results with respect to performance. I have tried solr 4.10.3 on both Jetty 8 and Jetty 9 with java 8. Below are configurations I have used. Can anyone please tell me if I am missing anything? *Jetty:* Xms: 5GB Xmx: 50GB Xss: 256MB *Tomcat:* Xms: 5GB Xmx: 50GB Xss: Default *Index Size:* 1TB (20 cores) -- Regards, Behzad Qureshi
