Re: Please help me articulate this query
Excellent, thank you! :) -Derek On Mon, Dec 15, 2008 at 8:45 PM, Otis Gospodnetic otis_gospodne...@yahoo.com wrote: Derek, q=+referring:XXX +question:YYY (of course, you'll have to URL-encode that query string0 Otis -- Sematext -- http://sematext.com/ -- Lucene - Solr - Nutch - Original Message From: Derek Springer de...@mahalo.com To: solr-user@lucene.apache.org Sent: Monday, December 15, 2008 3:40:55 PM Subject: Re: Please help me articulate this query Thanks for the tip, I appreciate it! However, does anyone know how to articulate the syntax of (This AND That) OR (Something AND Else) into a query string? i.e. q=referring:### AND question:### On Mon, Dec 15, 2008 at 12:32 PM, Stephen Weiss wrote: I think in this case you would want to index each question with the possible referrers ( by title might be too imprecise, I'd go with filename or ID) and then do a search like this (assuming in this case it's by filename) q=(referring:TomCruise.html) OR (question: Tom AND Cruise) Which seems to be what you're thinking. I would make the referrer a type string though so that you don't accidentally pull in documents from a different subject (Tom Cruise this would work ok, but imagine you need to distinguish between George Washington and George Washington Carver). -- Steve On Dec 15, 2008, at 2:59 PM, Derek Springer wrote: Hey all, I'm having trouble articulating a query and I'm hopeful someone out there can help me out :) My situation is this: I am indexing a series of questions that can either be asked from a main question entry page, or a specific subject page. I have a field called referring which indexes the title of the specific subject page, plus the regular question whenever that document is submitted from a specific specific subject page. Otherwise, every document is indexed with just the question. Specifically, what I am trying to do is when I am on the page specific subject page (e.g. Tom Cruise) I want to search for all of the questions asked from that page, plus any question asked about Tom Cruise. Something like: q=(referring:Tom AND Cruise) OR (question:Tom AND Cruise) Have you ever used a Tom Tom? - Not returned Where is the best place to take a cruise? - Not returned When did he have is first kid? - Returned iff question was asked from Tom Cruise page Do you think that Tom Cruise will make more movies? - Always returned Any thoughts? -Derek
Please help me articulate this query
Hey all, I'm having trouble articulating a query and I'm hopeful someone out there can help me out :) My situation is this: I am indexing a series of questions that can either be asked from a main question entry page, or a specific subject page. I have a field called referring which indexes the title of the specific subject page, plus the regular question whenever that document is submitted from a specific specific subject page. Otherwise, every document is indexed with just the question. Specifically, what I am trying to do is when I am on the page specific subject page (e.g. Tom Cruise) I want to search for all of the questions asked from that page, plus any question asked about Tom Cruise. Something like: q=(referring:Tom AND Cruise) OR (question:Tom AND Cruise) Have you ever used a Tom Tom? - Not returned Where is the best place to take a cruise? - Not returned When did he have is first kid? - Returned iff question was asked from Tom Cruise page Do you think that Tom Cruise will make more movies? - Always returned Any thoughts? -Derek
Re: Please help me articulate this query
I think in this case you would want to index each question with the possible referrers ( by title might be too imprecise, I'd go with filename or ID) and then do a search like this (assuming in this case it's by filename) q=(referring:TomCruise.html) OR (question: Tom AND Cruise) Which seems to be what you're thinking. I would make the referrer a type string though so that you don't accidentally pull in documents from a different subject (Tom Cruise this would work ok, but imagine you need to distinguish between George Washington and George Washington Carver). -- Steve On Dec 15, 2008, at 2:59 PM, Derek Springer wrote: Hey all, I'm having trouble articulating a query and I'm hopeful someone out there can help me out :) My situation is this: I am indexing a series of questions that can either be asked from a main question entry page, or a specific subject page. I have a field called referring which indexes the title of the specific subject page, plus the regular question whenever that document is submitted from a specific specific subject page. Otherwise, every document is indexed with just the question. Specifically, what I am trying to do is when I am on the page specific subject page (e.g. Tom Cruise) I want to search for all of the questions asked from that page, plus any question asked about Tom Cruise. Something like: q=(referring:Tom AND Cruise) OR (question:Tom AND Cruise) Have you ever used a Tom Tom? - Not returned Where is the best place to take a cruise? - Not returned When did he have is first kid? - Returned iff question was asked from Tom Cruise page Do you think that Tom Cruise will make more movies? - Always returned Any thoughts? -Derek
Re: Please help me articulate this query
Thanks for the tip, I appreciate it! However, does anyone know how to articulate the syntax of (This AND That) OR (Something AND Else) into a query string? i.e. q=referring:### AND question:### On Mon, Dec 15, 2008 at 12:32 PM, Stephen Weiss swe...@stylesight.comwrote: I think in this case you would want to index each question with the possible referrers ( by title might be too imprecise, I'd go with filename or ID) and then do a search like this (assuming in this case it's by filename) q=(referring:TomCruise.html) OR (question: Tom AND Cruise) Which seems to be what you're thinking. I would make the referrer a type string though so that you don't accidentally pull in documents from a different subject (Tom Cruise this would work ok, but imagine you need to distinguish between George Washington and George Washington Carver). -- Steve On Dec 15, 2008, at 2:59 PM, Derek Springer wrote: Hey all, I'm having trouble articulating a query and I'm hopeful someone out there can help me out :) My situation is this: I am indexing a series of questions that can either be asked from a main question entry page, or a specific subject page. I have a field called referring which indexes the title of the specific subject page, plus the regular question whenever that document is submitted from a specific specific subject page. Otherwise, every document is indexed with just the question. Specifically, what I am trying to do is when I am on the page specific subject page (e.g. Tom Cruise) I want to search for all of the questions asked from that page, plus any question asked about Tom Cruise. Something like: q=(referring:Tom AND Cruise) OR (question:Tom AND Cruise) Have you ever used a Tom Tom? - Not returned Where is the best place to take a cruise? - Not returned When did he have is first kid? - Returned iff question was asked from Tom Cruise page Do you think that Tom Cruise will make more movies? - Always returned Any thoughts? -Derek
Re: Please help me articulate this query
Derek, q=+referring:XXX +question:YYY (of course, you'll have to URL-encode that query string0 Otis -- Sematext -- http://sematext.com/ -- Lucene - Solr - Nutch - Original Message From: Derek Springer de...@mahalo.com To: solr-user@lucene.apache.org Sent: Monday, December 15, 2008 3:40:55 PM Subject: Re: Please help me articulate this query Thanks for the tip, I appreciate it! However, does anyone know how to articulate the syntax of (This AND That) OR (Something AND Else) into a query string? i.e. q=referring:### AND question:### On Mon, Dec 15, 2008 at 12:32 PM, Stephen Weiss wrote: I think in this case you would want to index each question with the possible referrers ( by title might be too imprecise, I'd go with filename or ID) and then do a search like this (assuming in this case it's by filename) q=(referring:TomCruise.html) OR (question: Tom AND Cruise) Which seems to be what you're thinking. I would make the referrer a type string though so that you don't accidentally pull in documents from a different subject (Tom Cruise this would work ok, but imagine you need to distinguish between George Washington and George Washington Carver). -- Steve On Dec 15, 2008, at 2:59 PM, Derek Springer wrote: Hey all, I'm having trouble articulating a query and I'm hopeful someone out there can help me out :) My situation is this: I am indexing a series of questions that can either be asked from a main question entry page, or a specific subject page. I have a field called referring which indexes the title of the specific subject page, plus the regular question whenever that document is submitted from a specific specific subject page. Otherwise, every document is indexed with just the question. Specifically, what I am trying to do is when I am on the page specific subject page (e.g. Tom Cruise) I want to search for all of the questions asked from that page, plus any question asked about Tom Cruise. Something like: q=(referring:Tom AND Cruise) OR (question:Tom AND Cruise) Have you ever used a Tom Tom? - Not returned Where is the best place to take a cruise? - Not returned When did he have is first kid? - Returned iff question was asked from Tom Cruise page Do you think that Tom Cruise will make more movies? - Always returned Any thoughts? -Derek
