Re: Solr 8.3 Solrj streaming expressions do not return all field values
I created a JIRA for this:
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SOLR-13894
On Wed, Nov 6, 2019 at 10:45 AM Jörn Franke wrote:
> I have checked now Solr 8.3 server in admin UI. Same issue.
>
> Reproduction:
> select(search(testcollection,q=“test”,df=“Default”,defType=“edismax”,fl=“id”,
> qt=“/export”, sort=“id asc”),id,if(eq(1,1),Y,N) as found)
>
> In 8.3 it returns only the id field.
> In 8.2 it returns id,found field.
>
> Since found is generated by select (and not coming from the collection)
> there must be an issue with select.
>
> Any idea why this is happening.
>
> Debug logs do not show any error and the expression is correctly received
> by Solr.
>
> Thank you.
>
> Best regards
>
> > Am 05.11.2019 um 14:59 schrieb Jörn Franke :
> >
> > Thanks I will check and come back to you. As far as I remember (but
> have to check) the queries generated by Solr were correct
> >
> > Just to be clear the same thing works with Solr 8.2 server and Solr 8.2
> client.
> >
> > It show the odd behaviour with Solr 8.2 server and Solr 8.3 client.
> >
> >> Am 05.11.2019 um 14:49 schrieb Joel Bernstein :
> >>
> >> I'll probably need some more details. One thing that's useful is to
> look at
> >> the logs and see the underlying Solr queries that are generated. Then
> try
> >> those underlying queries against the Solr index and see what comes
> back. If
> >> you're not seeing the fields with the plain Solr queries then we know
> it's
> >> something going on below streaming expressions. If you are seeing the
> >> fields then it's the expressions themselves that are not handling the
> data
> >> as expected.
> >>
> >>
> >> Joel Bernstein
> >> http://joelsolr.blogspot.com/
> >>
> >>
> On Mon, Nov 4, 2019 at 9:09 AM Jörn Franke
> wrote:
> >>>
> >>> Most likely this issue can bei also reproduced in the admin UI for the
> >>> streaming handler of a collection.
> >>>
> > Am 04.11.2019 um 13:32 schrieb Jörn Franke :
>
> Hi,
>
> I use streaming expressions, e.g.
> Sort(Select(search(...),id,if(eq(1,1),Y,N) as found), by=“field A
> asc”)
> (Using export handler, sort is not really mandatory , I will remove it
> >>> later anyway)
>
> This works perfectly fine if I use Solr 8.2.0 (server + client). It
> >>> returns Tuples in the form { “id”,”12345”, “found”:”Y”}
>
> However, if I use Solr 8.2.0 as server and Solr 8.3.0 as client then
> the
> >>> above statement only returns the id field, but not the found field.
>
> Questions:
> 1) is this expected behavior, ie Solr client 8.3.0 is in this case not
> >>> compatible with Solr 8.2.0 and server upgrade to Solr 8.3.0 will fix
> this?
> 2) has the syntax for the above expression changed? If so how?
> 3) is this not expected behavior and I should create a Jira for it?
>
> Thank you.
> Best regards
> >>>
>
Re: Solr 8.3 Solrj streaming expressions do not return all field values
I have checked now Solr 8.3 server in admin UI. Same issue.
Reproduction:
select(search(testcollection,q=“test”,df=“Default”,defType=“edismax”,fl=“id”,
qt=“/export”, sort=“id asc”),id,if(eq(1,1),Y,N) as found)
In 8.3 it returns only the id field.
In 8.2 it returns id,found field.
Since found is generated by select (and not coming from the collection) there
must be an issue with select.
Any idea why this is happening.
Debug logs do not show any error and the expression is correctly received by
Solr.
Thank you.
Best regards
> Am 05.11.2019 um 14:59 schrieb Jörn Franke :
>
> Thanks I will check and come back to you. As far as I remember (but have to
> check) the queries generated by Solr were correct
>
> Just to be clear the same thing works with Solr 8.2 server and Solr 8.2
> client.
>
> It show the odd behaviour with Solr 8.2 server and Solr 8.3 client.
>
>> Am 05.11.2019 um 14:49 schrieb Joel Bernstein :
>>
>> I'll probably need some more details. One thing that's useful is to look at
>> the logs and see the underlying Solr queries that are generated. Then try
>> those underlying queries against the Solr index and see what comes back. If
>> you're not seeing the fields with the plain Solr queries then we know it's
>> something going on below streaming expressions. If you are seeing the
>> fields then it's the expressions themselves that are not handling the data
>> as expected.
>>
>>
>> Joel Bernstein
>> http://joelsolr.blogspot.com/
>>
>>
On Mon, Nov 4, 2019 at 9:09 AM Jörn Franke wrote:
>>>
>>> Most likely this issue can bei also reproduced in the admin UI for the
>>> streaming handler of a collection.
>>>
> Am 04.11.2019 um 13:32 schrieb Jörn Franke :
Hi,
I use streaming expressions, e.g.
Sort(Select(search(...),id,if(eq(1,1),Y,N) as found), by=“field A asc”)
(Using export handler, sort is not really mandatory , I will remove it
>>> later anyway)
This works perfectly fine if I use Solr 8.2.0 (server + client). It
>>> returns Tuples in the form { “id”,”12345”, “found”:”Y”}
However, if I use Solr 8.2.0 as server and Solr 8.3.0 as client then the
>>> above statement only returns the id field, but not the found field.
Questions:
1) is this expected behavior, ie Solr client 8.3.0 is in this case not
>>> compatible with Solr 8.2.0 and server upgrade to Solr 8.3.0 will fix this?
2) has the syntax for the above expression changed? If so how?
3) is this not expected behavior and I should create a Jira for it?
Thank you.
Best regards
>>>
Re: Solr 8.3 Solrj streaming expressions do not return all field values
Thanks I will check and come back to you. As far as I remember (but have to
check) the queries generated by Solr were correct
Just to be clear the same thing works with Solr 8.2 server and Solr 8.2 client.
It show the odd behaviour with Solr 8.2 server and Solr 8.3 client.
> Am 05.11.2019 um 14:49 schrieb Joel Bernstein :
>
> I'll probably need some more details. One thing that's useful is to look at
> the logs and see the underlying Solr queries that are generated. Then try
> those underlying queries against the Solr index and see what comes back. If
> you're not seeing the fields with the plain Solr queries then we know it's
> something going on below streaming expressions. If you are seeing the
> fields then it's the expressions themselves that are not handling the data
> as expected.
>
>
> Joel Bernstein
> http://joelsolr.blogspot.com/
>
>
>> On Mon, Nov 4, 2019 at 9:09 AM Jörn Franke wrote:
>>
>> Most likely this issue can bei also reproduced in the admin UI for the
>> streaming handler of a collection.
>>
Am 04.11.2019 um 13:32 schrieb Jörn Franke :
>>>
>>> Hi,
>>>
>>> I use streaming expressions, e.g.
>>> Sort(Select(search(...),id,if(eq(1,1),Y,N) as found), by=“field A asc”)
>>> (Using export handler, sort is not really mandatory , I will remove it
>> later anyway)
>>>
>>> This works perfectly fine if I use Solr 8.2.0 (server + client). It
>> returns Tuples in the form { “id”,”12345”, “found”:”Y”}
>>>
>>> However, if I use Solr 8.2.0 as server and Solr 8.3.0 as client then the
>> above statement only returns the id field, but not the found field.
>>>
>>> Questions:
>>> 1) is this expected behavior, ie Solr client 8.3.0 is in this case not
>> compatible with Solr 8.2.0 and server upgrade to Solr 8.3.0 will fix this?
>>> 2) has the syntax for the above expression changed? If so how?
>>> 3) is this not expected behavior and I should create a Jira for it?
>>>
>>> Thank you.
>>> Best regards
>>
Re: Solr 8.3 Solrj streaming expressions do not return all field values
I'll probably need some more details. One thing that's useful is to look at
the logs and see the underlying Solr queries that are generated. Then try
those underlying queries against the Solr index and see what comes back. If
you're not seeing the fields with the plain Solr queries then we know it's
something going on below streaming expressions. If you are seeing the
fields then it's the expressions themselves that are not handling the data
as expected.
Joel Bernstein
http://joelsolr.blogspot.com/
On Mon, Nov 4, 2019 at 9:09 AM Jörn Franke wrote:
> Most likely this issue can bei also reproduced in the admin UI for the
> streaming handler of a collection.
>
> > Am 04.11.2019 um 13:32 schrieb Jörn Franke :
> >
> > Hi,
> >
> > I use streaming expressions, e.g.
> > Sort(Select(search(...),id,if(eq(1,1),Y,N) as found), by=“field A asc”)
> > (Using export handler, sort is not really mandatory , I will remove it
> later anyway)
> >
> > This works perfectly fine if I use Solr 8.2.0 (server + client). It
> returns Tuples in the form { “id”,”12345”, “found”:”Y”}
> >
> > However, if I use Solr 8.2.0 as server and Solr 8.3.0 as client then the
> above statement only returns the id field, but not the found field.
> >
> > Questions:
> > 1) is this expected behavior, ie Solr client 8.3.0 is in this case not
> compatible with Solr 8.2.0 and server upgrade to Solr 8.3.0 will fix this?
> > 2) has the syntax for the above expression changed? If so how?
> > 3) is this not expected behavior and I should create a Jira for it?
> >
> > Thank you.
> > Best regards
>
Re: Solr 8.3 Solrj streaming expressions do not return all field values
Most likely this issue can bei also reproduced in the admin UI for the
streaming handler of a collection.
> Am 04.11.2019 um 13:32 schrieb Jörn Franke :
>
> Hi,
>
> I use streaming expressions, e.g.
> Sort(Select(search(...),id,if(eq(1,1),Y,N) as found), by=“field A asc”)
> (Using export handler, sort is not really mandatory , I will remove it later
> anyway)
>
> This works perfectly fine if I use Solr 8.2.0 (server + client). It returns
> Tuples in the form { “id”,”12345”, “found”:”Y”}
>
> However, if I use Solr 8.2.0 as server and Solr 8.3.0 as client then the
> above statement only returns the id field, but not the found field.
>
> Questions:
> 1) is this expected behavior, ie Solr client 8.3.0 is in this case not
> compatible with Solr 8.2.0 and server upgrade to Solr 8.3.0 will fix this?
> 2) has the syntax for the above expression changed? If so how?
> 3) is this not expected behavior and I should create a Jira for it?
>
> Thank you.
> Best regards
Solr 8.3 Solrj streaming expressions do not return all field values
Hi,
I use streaming expressions, e.g.
Sort(Select(search(...),id,if(eq(1,1),Y,N) as found), by=“field A asc”)
(Using export handler, sort is not really mandatory , I will remove it later
anyway)
This works perfectly fine if I use Solr 8.2.0 (server + client). It returns
Tuples in the form { “id”,”12345”, “found”:”Y”}
However, if I use Solr 8.2.0 as server and Solr 8.3.0 as client then the above
statement only returns the id field, but not the found field.
Questions:
1) is this expected behavior, ie Solr client 8.3.0 is in this case not
compatible with Solr 8.2.0 and server upgrade to Solr 8.3.0 will fix this?
2) has the syntax for the above expression changed? If so how?
3) is this not expected behavior and I should create a Jira for it?
Thank you.
Best regards
