[SR-Users] Weird IPv6 Registration Issue

2011-02-02 Thread Jon Farmer
Hi

I am experimenting with a dual homed (IPv4 and IPv6) Openser 1.1.0-tls server.

If I register using a IPv6 address then the initial registration works
and the details are saved in the location table. However when the UA
trys to re-register on expiry the SIP returns a 200 OK but the
location data is not updated in the table. Looking at the syslog it is
reporting that it didn't save the data as there was an existing entry
on index with key 1. This is referring I presume to the primary index
on username, domain, contact) on the location table.

So what happens is the first location entry expires and gets deleted
from the table and thus there is no record for the subsequent register
and thus openser thinks the UA has dropped off until the next
re-register when because there is no longer a location record the data
gets saved correctly.

This doesn't happen if I register the same UA on IPv4 on the same
openser server.

Anyone got any ideas why this is happening?

Regards

Jon


-- 
Jon Farmer
Tel: 07795 118140
Email: viperdud...@gmail.com
Twitter: @viperdudeuk

___
SIP Express Router (SER) and Kamailio (OpenSER) - sr-users mailing list
sr-users@lists.sip-router.org
http://lists.sip-router.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sr-users


Re: [SR-Users] Weird IPv6 Registration Issue

2011-02-02 Thread Klaus Darilion


Am 02.02.2011 14:11, schrieb Jon Farmer:
 Hi
 
 I am experimenting with a dual homed (IPv4 and IPv6)
 Openser 1.1.0-tls server.

  ^^ that's weird

There were lot's of fixes (some quite recently) since then for IPv6,
e.g. regarding the format of an IPv6 socket stored in DB.

You really should use Kamailio 3.1.

regards
klaus



 
 If I register using a IPv6 address then the initial registration works
 and the details are saved in the location table. However when the UA
 trys to re-register on expiry the SIP returns a 200 OK but the
 location data is not updated in the table. Looking at the syslog it is
 reporting that it didn't save the data as there was an existing entry
 on index with key 1. This is referring I presume to the primary index
 on username, domain, contact) on the location table.
 
 So what happens is the first location entry expires and gets deleted
 from the table and thus there is no record for the subsequent register
 and thus openser thinks the UA has dropped off until the next
 re-register when because there is no longer a location record the data
 gets saved correctly.
 
 This doesn't happen if I register the same UA on IPv4 on the same
 openser server.
 
 Anyone got any ideas why this is happening?
 
 Regards
 
 Jon
 
 

___
SIP Express Router (SER) and Kamailio (OpenSER) - sr-users mailing list
sr-users@lists.sip-router.org
http://lists.sip-router.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sr-users


Re: [SR-Users] Weird IPv6 Registration Issue

2011-02-02 Thread Daniel-Constantin Mierla

Hello,

On 2/2/11 2:11 PM, Jon Farmer wrote:

Hi

I am experimenting with a dual homed (IPv4 and IPv6) Openser 1.1.0-tls server.
1.1.0 is way too old :-) . If you try it right now, I recommend using 
3.1.x, I have tested it a SIPit and location was working fine.


Core and SIP routing are also ok. To my knowledge the permissions module 
has a too small column size in database address table (on my todo list 
to fix in this devel cycle). Probably the same is with lcr module.

If I register using a IPv6 address then the initial registration works
and the details are saved in the location table. However when the UA
trys to re-register on expiry the SIP returns a 200 OK but the
location data is not updated in the table. Looking at the syslog it is
reporting that it didn't save the data as there was an existing entry
on index with key 1. This is referring I presume to the primary index
on username, domain, contact) on the location table.

So what happens is the first location entry expires and gets deleted
from the table and thus there is no record for the subsequent register
and thus openser thinks the UA has dropped off until the next
re-register when because there is no longer a location record the data
gets saved correctly.

This doesn't happen if I register the same UA on IPv4 on the same
openser server.

Anyone got any ideas why this is happening?
Being that old, I cannot remember if there were other issues. If you 
want to continue with this one, run it in debug mode, also enable mysql 
query logs and try to figure out what was wrong there. Then maybe there 
was a fix for that. Anyhow, iirc, there was an issue with storage of 
ipv6 address in one of the location fields, probably not done in 1.1.x 
at all since was done more recently.


Cheers,
Daniel

--
Daniel-Constantin Mierla
http://www.asipto.com


___
SIP Express Router (SER) and Kamailio (OpenSER) - sr-users mailing list
sr-users@lists.sip-router.org
http://lists.sip-router.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sr-users