Re: [Talk-GB] OSM point of interest counts in each district as a proportion of FHRS
Could you expand & clarify please? What is an OSM candidate? For Tendring, are you saying there's more entities in OSM with an FHRS tag than there are in the FHRS government data? Why are the results arbitrary? Cheers DaveF On 31/12/2016 10:39, Andrew Hain wrote: As an exercise in measuring OSM’s coverage I have crunched the numbers in GregRS’s CSV output to calculate the number of OSM candidates in each district as a proportion of the number of FHRS entries that the program reports. The figures are a bit arbitrary and values over 100% are not necessarily wrong. The tool doesn’t cover Northern Ireland. The list is: 1 Tendring 135.07% 2 Gravesham 117.93% 3 Isles of Scilly 117.81% 4 Rushcliffe 117.58% 5 Blackpool 108.66% 6 East Northamptonshire 108.17% 7 Wellingborough 107.94% 8 Guildford 107.82% 9 Erewash 106.40% 10 Broxtowe 106.14% 11 Argyll and Bute 105.49% 12 Islington 104.16% 13 Gedling 98.48% 14 South Cambridgeshire 97.83% 15 Edinburgh 97.60% 16 Nottingham 97.45% 17 Derbyshire Dales 97.07% 18 Cambridge 96.83% 19 Allerdale 94.78% 20 Wychavon 94.78% 21 West Devon 94.47% 22 Bath and North East Somerset 93.83% 23 Oxford 93.09% 24 Aberdeenshire 92.90% 25 Ryedale 90.70% 26 Mid Devon 89.31% 27 Central Bedfordshire 88.97% 28 Westminster 87.99% 29 South Norfolk 87.13% 30 South Lakeland 86.94% 31 Amber Valley 86.34% 32 Birmingham 85.27% 33 Poole 84.66% 34 Melton 83.60% 35 Lancaster 82.43% 36 Southampton 82.31% 37 South Ribble 81.76% 38 Basingstoke and Deane 81.49% 39 Sevenoaks 81.44% 40 Staffordshire Moorlands 81.22% 41 Camden 81.09% 42 South Hams 80.09% 43 Copeland 79.87% 44 Carlisle 79.84% 45 Gateshead 79.72% 46 Hart 79.69% 47 New Forest 79.65% 48 Winchester 79.49% 49 High Peak 79.23% 50 Eden 78.69% 51 South Tyneside 78.59% 52 Rutland 78.34% 53 Perth and Kinross 77.14% 54 Derby 77.05% 55 East Cambridgeshire 76.82% 56 Shetland Islands 76.34% 57 Breckland 76.18% 58 North East Derbyshire 76.15% 59 Bristol 75.91% 60 Huntingdonshire 75.45% 61 Rother 75.34% 62 Sir Ynys Mon - Isle of Anglesey 75.00% 63 Malvern Hills 74.92% 64 Chelmsford 74.79% 65 Hambleton 74.79% 66 St. Albans 74.31% 67 Sutton 73.25% (corrected) 68 Shropshire 72.57% 69 Ashfield 72.34% 70 Richmondshire 71.91% 71 Lambeth 71.70% 72 Sir Ddinbych - Denbighshire 71.52% 73 Tewkesbury 71.37% 74 Runnymede 71.23% 75 Chesterfield 70.80% 76 Stratford-on-Avon 70.73% 77 Fenland 70.50% 78 South Oxfordshire 70.38% 79 Uttlesford 70.05% 80 York 69.92% 81 Exeter 69.82% 82 West Berkshire 69.75% 83 South Gloucestershire 69.64% 84 Cornwall 69.64% 85 Bromsgrove 69.37% 86 Waverley 69.29% 87 Medway 69.28% 88 Wokingham 69.19% 89 North Dorset 68.99% 90 Wyre Forest 68.86% 91 Cherwell 68.73% 92 Highland 68.55% 93 Taunton Deane 68.41% 94 Cotswold 68.40% 95 Mole Valley 68.32% 96 Eastleigh 67.89% 97 Selby 67.86% 98 West Oxfordshire 67.85% 99 St. Edmundsbury 67.69% 100 East Hampshire 67.66% 101 Test Valley 67.52% 102 Chiltern 67.02% 103 Weymouth and Portland 66.84% 104 Wiltshire 66.35% 105 Midlothian 66.10% 106 Rugby 66.00% 107 Maldon 65.99% 108 Na h-Eileanan an Iar 65.84% 109 Bedford 65.69% 110 East Staffordshire 65.37% 111 Leeds 65.30% 112 Waltham Forest 65.24% 113 City of London 65.10% 114 Wakefield 65.03% 115 East Hertfordshire 64.90% 116 Christchurch 64.74% 117 Three Rivers 64.61% 118 Northumberland 64.60% 119 Darlington 64.55% 120 Abertawe - Swansea 64.31% 121 Gwynedd - Gwynedd 64.16% 122 Reading 64.13% 123 Stroud 63.85% 124 Suffolk Coastal 63.84% 125 East Riding of Yorkshire 63.76% 126 North Hertfordshire 63.68% 127 Cheshire East 63.65% 128 Orkney Islands 63.60% 129 Craven 63.60% 130 Mid Suffolk 63.25% 131 Sheffield 63.22% 132 Tamworth 63.13% 133 Norwich 62.95% 134 Solihull 62.82% 135 Warwick 62.75% 136 North West Leicestershire 62.67% 137 West Dorset 62.61% 138 Kensington and Chelsea 62.53% 139 Surrey Heath 62.34% 140 Vale of White Horse 62.33% 141 North
Re: [Talk-GB] OSM point of interest counts in each district as a proportion of FHRS
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA256 My apologies Andrew, I somehow managed to send a blank email from your address as a result of typing something into the wrong window and inadvertently triggering a key command! Sorry for the unnecessary noise... Happy New Year! Greg - -- Twitter: @gregrs_uk http://gregrs.dev.openstreetmap.org PGP key ID: 64907C8A Fingerprint: EBD1 077F CCDD 841E A505 3FAA D2E8 592E 6490 7C8A -BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE- iQEcBAEBCAAGBQJYaQi1AAoJEB7WhxSLszZlLBwH/2fOC0ZDMLA8UKsxR2pAfZwD ZTwslNRWvJwLtNOzi4eAIv4SCNRqwOM4Wu6VPCpp+sl57ggyV23n7EUgdQXJi5Q7 SiCDCkbYDnUn8NMAW3jsxeLQ89L92l1aeUIfnon87eEXauWu6lyi7dVzbve/N+Qv WkBXTKgkrcZM8URB6SjNKOTCelNGMSzB0fNujOg1te8e/84yul9m4oo/vSqs/He6 ItJNrNsF9t83vIkwQsUd4Hz/EwJKTcyUpoBd6n407QhfkP1Dpsg87FGeun50JB8n 2UaSpMaLR4IYBHvqFkKh9JDRBAW7yGarYjwUbjA592NW0LdvHGsftWsA8zpItGk= =nbeK -END PGP SIGNATURE- ___ Talk-GB mailing list Talk-GB@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb
[Talk-GB] OSM point of interest counts in each district as a proportion of FHRS
___ Talk-GB mailing list Talk-GB@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb ___ Talk-GB mailing list Talk-GB@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb
[Talk-GB] OSM point of interest counts in each district as a proportion of FHRS
As an exercise in measuring OSM’s coverage I have crunched the numbers in GregRS’s CSV output to calculate the number of OSM candidates in each district as a proportion of the number of FHRS entries that the program reports. The figures are a bit arbitrary and values over 100% are not necessarily wrong. The tool doesn’t cover Northern Ireland. The list is: 1 Tendring 135.07% 2 Gravesham 117.93% 3 Isles of Scilly 117.81% 4 Rushcliffe 117.58% 5 Blackpool 108.66% 6 East Northamptonshire 108.17% 7 Wellingborough 107.94% 8 Guildford 107.82% 9 Erewash 106.40% 10 Broxtowe 106.14% 11 Argyll and Bute 105.49% 12 Islington 104.16% 13 Gedling 98.48% 14 South Cambridgeshire 97.83% 15 Edinburgh 97.60% 16 Nottingham 97.45% 17 Derbyshire Dales 97.07% 18 Cambridge 96.83% 19 Allerdale 94.78% 20 Wychavon 94.78% 21 West Devon 94.47% 22 Bath and North East Somerset 93.83% 23 Oxford 93.09% 24 Aberdeenshire 92.90% 25 Ryedale 90.70% 26 Mid Devon 89.31% 27 Central Bedfordshire 88.97% 28 Westminster 87.99% 29 South Norfolk 87.13% 30 South Lakeland 86.94% 31 Amber Valley 86.34% 32 Birmingham 85.27% 33 Poole 84.66% 34 Melton 83.60% 35 Lancaster 82.43% 36 Southampton 82.31% 37 South Ribble 81.76% 38 Basingstoke and Deane 81.49% 39 Sevenoaks 81.44% 40 Staffordshire Moorlands 81.22% 41 Camden 81.09% 42 South Hams 80.09% 43 Copeland 79.87% 44 Carlisle 79.84% 45 Gateshead 79.72% 46 Hart 79.69% 47 New Forest 79.65% 48 Winchester 79.49% 49 High Peak 79.23% 50 Eden 78.69% 51 South Tyneside 78.59% 52 Rutland 78.34% 53 Perth and Kinross 77.14% 54 Derby 77.05% 55 East Cambridgeshire 76.82% 56 Shetland Islands 76.34% 57 Breckland 76.18% 58 North East Derbyshire 76.15% 59 Bristol 75.91% 60 Huntingdonshire 75.45% 61 Rother 75.34% 62 Sir Ynys Mon - Isle of Anglesey 75.00% 63 Malvern Hills 74.92% 64 Chelmsford 74.79% 65 Hambleton 74.79% 66 St. Albans 74.31% 67 Sutton 73.25% (corrected) 68 Shropshire 72.57% 69 Ashfield 72.34% 70 Richmondshire 71.91% 71 Lambeth 71.70% 72 Sir Ddinbych - Denbighshire 71.52% 73 Tewkesbury 71.37% 74 Runnymede 71.23% 75 Chesterfield 70.80% 76 Stratford-on-Avon 70.73% 77 Fenland 70.50% 78 South Oxfordshire 70.38% 79 Uttlesford 70.05% 80 York 69.92% 81 Exeter 69.82% 82 West Berkshire 69.75% 83 South Gloucestershire 69.64% 84 Cornwall 69.64% 85 Bromsgrove 69.37% 86 Waverley 69.29% 87 Medway 69.28% 88 Wokingham 69.19% 89 North Dorset 68.99% 90 Wyre Forest 68.86% 91 Cherwell 68.73% 92 Highland 68.55% 93 Taunton Deane 68.41% 94 Cotswold 68.40% 95 Mole Valley 68.32% 96 Eastleigh 67.89% 97 Selby 67.86% 98 West Oxfordshire 67.85% 99 St. Edmundsbury 67.69% 100 East Hampshire 67.66% 101 Test Valley 67.52% 102 Chiltern 67.02% 103 Weymouth and Portland 66.84% 104 Wiltshire 66.35% 105 Midlothian 66.10% 106 Rugby 66.00% 107 Maldon 65.99% 108 Na h-Eileanan an Iar 65.84% 109 Bedford 65.69% 110 East Staffordshire 65.37% 111 Leeds 65.30% 112 Waltham Forest 65.24% 113 City of London 65.10% 114 Wakefield 65.03% 115 East Hertfordshire 64.90% 116 Christchurch 64.74% 117 Three Rivers 64.61% 118 Northumberland 64.60% 119 Darlington 64.55% 120 Abertawe - Swansea 64.31% 121 Gwynedd - Gwynedd 64.16% 122 Reading 64.13% 123 Stroud 63.85% 124 Suffolk Coastal 63.84% 125 East Riding of Yorkshire 63.76% 126 North Hertfordshire 63.68% 127 Cheshire East 63.65% 128 Orkney Islands 63.60% 129 Craven 63.60% 130 Mid Suffolk 63.25% 131 Sheffield 63.22% 132 Tamworth 63.13% 133 Norwich 62.95% 134 Solihull 62.82% 135 Warwick 62.75% 136 North West Leicestershire 62.67% 137 West Dorset 62.61% 138 Kensington and Chelsea 62.53% 139 Surrey Heath 62.34% 140 Vale of White Horse 62.33% 141 North Warwickshire 61.97% 142 Hammersmith and Fulham 61.87% 143 Sandwell 61.83% 144 Aylesbury Vale 61.49% 145 Torbay 61.41% 146 Charnwood 61.31% 147 Ipswich 61.26% 148 South Staffordshire 61.21% 149 Ashford 61.00%
