Re: [Talk-hr] Ne treba svaka drzavna cesta biti primary
ned, 29. kol 2021. u 01:57 Matija Nalis napisao je: > BTW ako je zasticena, mozda joj trebamo staviti onda neki > https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:protect_class ? > Ja sam prije 5 godina ucrtao rutu Majstorske ceste: https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/6314837 Ali nije cijela zaštićena, trebalo bi naći od kuda do kuda. Valjda makadamski dio? I nisam siguran kako tagirati. Pretpostavljam area oko ceste? > Sto god da smislimo, svakom slucaju bih stavio na to i: > "note= > https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Croatia/Ceste#Klasifikacija_cesta; > (ili gdje cemo vec napisati ta pravila) > Slažem se. > Nazalost OSM izgleda na dosta highway=primary nema upisan surface=*, pa > ne znamo koliko toga jos potencijalno ima, vidi: > https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1aHG Ja sam prošao ove, i svima sam stavio surface. To su sve novi kružni tokovi, nove obilaznice, i takve sitnice na kojima se na satelitskim snimcima vidi da je asfalt. Čini se da i dalje ostaju ovi dosadašnji primjeri, osim ako imamo neku krivo tagiranu. Ako segment "highway=primary" ili "highway=secondary" ima "surface" koji > je losiji od "asphalt" i "concrete*", onda taj segment degradiramo u > npr. "highway=unclassified" + "surface=xxx" + "note=link_na_wiki" > Meni se ovo čini najbolje jer je jednostavno za objasniti i argumentirati. A tako već i piše u wiki-u, zar ne? Pitam se hoćemo li tako izgubiti renderiranje nekih županijskih cesta koje su stvarno važne u svojoj regiji, i želiš ih vidjeti na višim zoomovima da bude jasno da se tamo može proći, ali su ipak makadamske. Mislim da Majstorska cesta nije discouraged službeno, kad sam pročitao opet rečenicu, samo kaže da ju štite od sve jačeg prometa, i ne žele ju asfaltirati. Možda se nadaju da neće biti previše prometa, ali to je to. Nemamo dosta za staviti taj tag, pogotovo na one druge makadamske državne ceste koje nisu kulturno dobro. Janko ___ Talk-hr mailing list Talk-hr@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-hr
Re: [Talk-hr] Road network improvements in Croatia
Hi Matija, Thank you for all the provided information. Regarding the incorrectly mapped oneways on 8th of July @simulator1 contacted us and also left comments on relevant changesets. After discussions, all issues were resolved. You can find the details here: https://bit.ly/3js7v2B Regards, Murad On Sun, Aug 29, 2021 at 1:00 AM Matija Nalis < mnalis-openstreetmapl...@voyager.hr> wrote: > Hi Murad, > > Your post made it this time. This mailing list is "offical" contact, but we > do use Telegram channel often: see > https://osm-hr.org/openstreetmap-hrvatska/ > > I remember there being some issues previously with Bolt users > incorrectly mapping oneway streets if I recall correctly (and maybe > some other issues), but I do not know if it was resolved. > Perhaps the persons who noticed that problems could jump in with more > details? > > Local guidelines are documented at > https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Croatia > and links at the top (in Croatian only, sorry). Mostly regarding road > classificaton, public transport and hiking/cycling routes. > I think most of the other stuff is straightforward OSM usage. > > Feel free to ask if you have any questions. > > Cheers, > Matija > > On Thu, Aug 26, 2021 at 09:40:42AM +0400, Murad Vardzelyan via Talk-hr > wrote: > > I’m Murad from Bolt. > > > > We are improving the road network of Croatia. Project details can be > found > > here: > https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Organised_Editing/Activites/Bolt. > > We would like to get familiar with local mapping guidelines if there are > > any. > > > > Please, also, let me know if you have preferred contact channels other > than > > this talk-list. > > > > Waiting for your reply. > > > > P.S. We have contacted Croatian community also back in March, but seems > the > > message got lost. > > > > Regards, Murad from Bolt Map Production > > ___ > > Talk-hr mailing list > > Talk-hr@openstreetmap.org > > https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-hr > > -- > Opinions above are GNU-copylefted. > ___ Talk-hr mailing list Talk-hr@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-hr
