Re: [Talk-transit] maintenance is very time consuming on public transport routes

2013-12-02 Thread Teuxe


Mike N nice...@att.net a écrit :
On 12/1/2013 5:32 PM, Jo wrote:
 Hmm, I was thinking of staying more or less within the lines of what
we
 have now, but take away the burden of 10, 20, 70 relations on the
same
 piece of road.

  I'm just curious - what type of data consumer could use information 
from OSM which contains 70 routes in a road segment?  It would seem to 
be too many to fit on a map display, but I suppose a device would be 
able to highlight a single route variation on demand.

You're right, we would have to think of ways to integrate the following 
operations in edit tools:
- Adding items to a relation (OK itns available)
- Removing items from a relation (one by one, feasible)
- Copying a relation
- Splitting a relation into two relations (the main issue with our variants 
issue): how to visually handle this?
- Sorting items in a relation?

Regarding groups of segments to be represented on a tool, this is already 
possible since we do that with routes.
Now how to call this relationship?

Teuxe___
Talk-transit mailing list
Talk-transit@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-transit


Re: [Talk-transit] maintenance is very time consuming on public transport routes

2013-12-02 Thread Teuxe


Mike N nice...@att.net a écrit :
On 12/1/2013 5:32 PM, Jo wrote:
 Hmm, I was thinking of staying more or less within the lines of what
we
 have now, but take away the burden of 10, 20, 70 relations on the
same
 piece of road.

  I'm just curious - what type of data consumer could use information 
from OSM which contains 70 routes in a road segment?  It would seem to 
be too many to fit on a map display, but I suppose a device would be 
able to highlight a single route variation on demand.

You're right, we would have to think of ways to integrate the following 
operations in edit tools:
- Adding items to a relation (OK itns available)
- Removing items from a relation (one by one, feasible)
- Copying a relation
- Splitting a relation into two relations (the main issue with our variants 
issue): how to visually handle this?
- Sorting items in a relation?

Regarding groups of segments to be represented on a tool, this is already 
possible since we do that with routes.
Now how to call this relationship?

Teuxe___
Talk-transit mailing list
Talk-transit@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-transit