Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories
Sorry for the late vote. I've been on vacation last two weeks. ;-) ballot A) Servlet 2.4 JSP 2.0 API 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi 3. [ ] Other: B) Catalina 2.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 4. [ ] Other: C) Coyote 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors 2. [ ] No, use: D) Tomcat 5.0 1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 3. [X] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat 4. [ ] Other: E) Jasper 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper 2. [ ] No, use: /ballot Amy Thanks for voting ;-) Remy -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
[5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories
New repositories are needed to host the new Tomcat 5.0 code, including the new servlet JSP API, Catalina, Coyote 2.0 and protocol handlers, Jasper. A) For the Servlet JSP API, I think a new separate repository is needed (jakarta-servletapi-5 to follow the current conventions). Or we could put it in the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi (and the old 2.1 API goes in a branch). B) For Catalina, we could either use a new repository, named either j-t-catalina or j-t-5.0, or use the HEAD of j-t-4.0 (the current code would then be branched). C) Coyote 2.0 will be in the HEAD of j-t-c. Coyote 1.0 will be put in a separate branch. D) Tomcat specific glue code (if some is needed) would go in either j-t-5.0, the HEAD of j-t-4.0, or the HEAD of j-t. E) Jasper 2+ goes in the HEAD of j-t-j. The current Jasper 2 will go in a branch. ballot A) Servlet 2.4 JSP 2.0 API 1. [ ] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi 3. [ ] Other: B) Catalina 2.0 1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 4. [ ] Other: C) Coyote 2.0 1. [ ] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors 2. [ ] No, use: D) Tomcat 5.0 1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat 4. [ ] Other: E) Jasper 2.0 1. [ ] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper 2. [ ] No, use: /ballot Thanks for voting ;-) Remy -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories
ballot A) Servlet 2.4 JSP 2.0 API 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi 3. [ ] Other: B) Catalina 2.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 4. [ ] Other: C) Coyote 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors 2. [ ] No, use: D) Tomcat 5.0 1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 3. [X] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat 4. [ ] Other: E) Jasper 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper 2. [ ] No, use: /ballot Remy -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories
Remy Maucherat wrote: New repositories are needed to host the new Tomcat 5.0 code, including the new servlet JSP API, Catalina, Coyote 2.0 and protocol handlers, Jasper. A) For the Servlet JSP API, I think a new separate repository is needed (jakarta-servletapi-5 to follow the current conventions). Or we could put it in the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi (and the old 2.1 API goes in a branch). B) For Catalina, we could either use a new repository, named either j-t-catalina or j-t-5.0, or use the HEAD of j-t-4.0 (the current code would then be branched). C) Coyote 2.0 will be in the HEAD of j-t-c. Coyote 1.0 will be put in a separate branch. D) Tomcat specific glue code (if some is needed) would go in either j-t-5.0, the HEAD of j-t-4.0, or the HEAD of j-t. E) Jasper 2+ goes in the HEAD of j-t-j. The current Jasper 2 will go in a branch. ballot A) Servlet 2.4 JSP 2.0 API 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi 3. [ ] Other: B) Catalina 2.0 1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina 2. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 4. [ ] Other: C) Coyote 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors 2. [ ] No, use: D) Tomcat 5.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat 4. [ ] Other: E) Jasper 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper 2. [ ] No, use: /ballot Thanks for voting ;-) Remy -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories
Quoting Remy Maucherat [EMAIL PROTECTED]: ballot A) Servlet 2.4 JSP 2.0 API 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi 3. [ ] Other: B) Catalina 2.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 4. [ ] Other: C) Coyote 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors 2. [ ] No, use: D) Tomcat 5.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat 4. [ ] Other: E) Jasper 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper 2. [ ] No, use: /ballot Which make Tomcat 5.0 a glue for edge packages (I feel it more modular) -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories
Remy, Below are my votes. I like the idea of using repositories without versions numbers for the Catalina, Jasper, and Tomcat code. It always seemed to me to be a pain to create a new CVS repository every time there is a new release instead of just creating a branch for the old release. Patrick Remy Maucherat wrote: ballot A) Servlet 2.4 JSP 2.0 API 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi 3. [ ] Other: B) Catalina 2.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 4. [ ] Other: C) Coyote 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors 2. [ ] No, use: D) Tomcat 5.0 1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 3. [X] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat 4. [ ] Other: E) Jasper 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper 2. [ ] No, use: /ballot -- Patrick Luby Email: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sun Microsystems Phone: 408-276-7471 901 San Antonio Road, USCA14-303 Palo Alto, CA 94303-4900 -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories
On Thu, 11 Jul 2002, Remy Maucherat wrote: ballot A) Servlet 2.4 JSP 2.0 API 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi 3. [ ] Other: B) Catalina 2.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 4. [ ] Other: C) Coyote 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors 2. [ ] No, use: D) Tomcat 5.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat 4. [ ] Other: That's a hard one... I would like it to go in jakarta-tomcat, but the current CVS organization is a mess and would create more problems. I'm actually more on jakarta-tomcat-5 ( without the .0 - since 5.1 will be in this CVS too ) E) Jasper 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper 2. [ ] No, use: /ballot -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
OFF TOPIC: RE: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories
As a lay person trying to learn, can I ask a question about the benefits of repository vs branch? Since I haven't really used CVS, I don't know the +/-, but would have proposed: A) Servlet 2.4 JSP 2.0 API Use new jakarta-servletapi-5.0 B) Catalina 2.0 Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina-2.0 C) Coyote 2.0 use new jakarta-tomcat-connectors-2.0 D) Tomcat 5.0 Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 E) Jasper 2.0 use new jakarta-tomcat-jasper-2.0 Which would seem more consistent, for someone just trying to dip in for the first time. Mitchell Evan Marx[EMAIL PROTECTED] ATT IP Network Configuration Provisioning Development -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Thursday, July 11, 2002 9:37 AM To: Tomcat Developers List Subject: Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories On Thu, 11 Jul 2002, Remy Maucherat wrote: ballot A) Servlet 2.4 JSP 2.0 API 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi 3. [ ] Other: B) Catalina 2.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 4. [ ] Other: C) Coyote 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors 2. [ ] No, use: D) Tomcat 5.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat 4. [ ] Other: That's a hard one... I would like it to go in jakarta-tomcat, but the current CVS organization is a mess and would create more problems. I'm actually more on jakarta-tomcat-5 ( without the .0 - since 5.1 will be in this CVS too ) E) Jasper 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper 2. [ ] No, use: /ballot -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
RE: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories
ballot A) Servlet 2.4 JSP 2.0 API 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi 3. [ ] Other: B) Catalina 2.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 4. [ ] Other: C) Coyote 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors 2. [ ] No, use: D) Tomcat 5.0 1. [2] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat 4. [1] Other: jakarta-tomcat-5 I agree with Costin that it is confusing to be building Tomcat 4.1.x in the jakarta-tomcat-4.0 repository. E) Jasper 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper 2. [ ] No, use: /ballot Larry -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: D) Tomcat 5.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat 4. [ ] Other: That's a hard one... I would like it to go in jakarta-tomcat, but the current CVS organization is a mess and would create more problems. I'm actually more on jakarta-tomcat-5 ( without the .0 - since 5.1 will be in this CVS too ) Yes, that makes sense (the current 4.0 in the repository name is awkward), and it's an easy change. Unless somebody has something against it, I'll consider vote 1. to be jakarta-tomcat-5. Remy -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
RE: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories
A) Servlet 2.4 JSP 2.0 API 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi 3. [ ] Other: B) Catalina 2.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 4. [ ] Other: C) Coyote 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors 2. [ ] No, use: D) Tomcat 5.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat 4. [ ] Other: Agree in call 5 not 5.0.. E) Jasper 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper 2. [ ] No, use: /ballot Saludos , Ignacio J. Ortega -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories
A) Servlet 2.4 JSP 2.0 API 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi 3. [ ] Other: B) Catalina 2.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 4. [ ] Other: C) Coyote 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors 2. [ ] No, use: D) Tomcat 5.0 1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat 4. [X] Other: jakarta-tomcat-5 E) Jasper 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper 2. [ ] No, use: /ballot -- Glenn Nielsen [EMAIL PROTECTED] | /* Spelin donut madder| MOREnet System Programming | * if iz ina coment. | Missouri Research and Education Network | */ | -- -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories
ballot A) Servlet 2.4 JSP 2.0 API 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi 3. [ ] Other: B) Catalina 2.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 4. [ ] Other: C) Coyote 2.0 1. [ ] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors 2. [ ] No, use: D) Tomcat 5.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat 4. [ ] Other: E) Jasper 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper 2. [ ] No, use: /ballot -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories
ballot A) Servlet 2.4 JSP 2.0 API 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi 3. [ ] Other: B) Catalina 2.0 1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina 2. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 4. [ ] Other: C) Coyote 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors 2. [ ] No, use: D) Tomcat 5.0 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat 4. [ ] Other: E) Jasper 2.0 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper 2. [ ] No, use: /ballot -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
