Re: How to add multiple contribution to tuscany?
Huang Kai Please see the following post [1] for more details on using multiple contributions, it also gives you pointer for a sample that is in my sandbox and use EmbeddedSCADomain with multiple contributions. [1] http://www.mail-archive.com/tuscany-user%40ws.apache.org/msg01074.html On 5/31/07, Luciano Resende <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Hi Huang Kai, thanks for your interest and feedback, see my comments inline for the issues you mentioned, some are bugs, some are functionalities that are not yet implemented and it would be great if you would be interested in helping us get these implemented. On 5/31/07, Huang Kai <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Hi, all: > > I got several question when looking into Tuscany's codes: > > 1)MULTIPLE CONTRIBUTION > > IMO, a contribution is a deployment unit, so a domain should be allowed to have more than one contribution. While Tuscany only handles one contribution. > > -- > > DefaultSCADomain: > > // Look for META-INF/sca-contribution.xml > contributionArtifactPath = Contribution.SCA_CONTRIBUTION_META; > contributionArtifactURL = classLoader.getResource(contributionArtifactPath); > > --- > > Should it be "classLoader.getResources(contributionArtifactPath)" for multiple contributions? > > And following codes doesn't handle multiple contribution neither. Like 'ContributionServiceImpl.addContribution', is called only once. > This really depends on how the hosting environment discover all contributions and decide which ones to be added to the domain. I think there was a discussion thread on this subject, or if not, I'll start a new one. > > > 2)CONTRIBUTION META DOCUMENT MERGING > > in SCA spec 1.10.2.2 write: "...accommodate this, it is also possible to have an identically structured document at META-INF/sca-contribution-generated.xml. If this document exists (or is generated on an as-needed basis), it will be merged into the contents of sca-contribution.xml, with the entries in sca-contribution.xml taking priority if there are any conflicting declarations." > > Tuscany seems won't load sca-contribution-generated.xml if sca-contribution.xml exists. Yes, this is a bug, would you please raise a JIRA for it ? And it would be great if you want to help with a patch as well. > > 3)CONTRIBUTION IMPORT/EXPORT > > Tuscany do resolved 'import' and 'export' in 'sca-contribution.xml'. If only one contribution is resolved, as said in (1), import/export become meaningless. This import/export functionality is not fully implemented in Tuscany yet, there is a JIRA for this http://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/TUSCANY-1161. > > 4)CONTRIBUTION META EXTENSION > > contribution meta document resolving hard-coded xml element name , not as extensible as DefaultURLArtifactProcessorExtensionPoint used else where. > > see also SCA spec 1.10.2.2 > > "...For example, can be used can be used to export java definitions, in which case the namespace should be a fully qualified package name." > This is not implemented yet, any contribution on this and the other mentioned areas would be appreciated. -- Luciano Resende Apache Tuscany Committer http://people.apache.org/~lresende http://lresende.blogspot.com/ -- Luciano Resende Apache Tuscany Committer http://people.apache.org/~lresende http://lresende.blogspot.com/ - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: How to add multiple contribution to tuscany?
[snip] Luciano Resende wrote: Hi Huang Kai, thanks for your interest and feedback, see my comments inline for the issues you mentioned, some are bugs, some are functionalities that are not yet implemented and it would be great if you would be interested in helping us get these implemented. On 5/31/07, Huang Kai <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Hi, all: I got several question when looking into Tuscany's codes: 1)MULTIPLE CONTRIBUTION IMO, a contribution is a deployment unit, so a domain should be allowed to have more than one contribution. While Tuscany only handles one contribution. -- DefaultSCADomain: // Look for META-INF/sca-contribution.xml contributionArtifactPath = Contribution.SCA_CONTRIBUTION_META; contributionArtifactURL = classLoader.getResource(contributionArtifactPath); --- Should it be "classLoader.getResources(contributionArtifactPath)" for multiple contributions? And following codes doesn't handle multiple contribution neither. Like 'ContributionServiceImpl.addContribution', is called only once. This really depends on how the hosting environment discover all contributions and decide which ones to be added to the domain. I think there was a discussion thread on this subject, or if not, I'll start a new one. A similar discussion has started on the tuscany-user list and I posted some info on how to add multiple contributions to a domain there, see this thread: http://www.mail-archive.com/[EMAIL PROTECTED]/msg01035.html -- Jean-Sebastien - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: How to add multiple contribution to tuscany?
Hi Huang Kai, thanks for your interest and feedback, see my comments inline for the issues you mentioned, some are bugs, some are functionalities that are not yet implemented and it would be great if you would be interested in helping us get these implemented. On 5/31/07, Huang Kai <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Hi, all: I got several question when looking into Tuscany's codes: 1)MULTIPLE CONTRIBUTION IMO, a contribution is a deployment unit, so a domain should be allowed to have more than one contribution. While Tuscany only handles one contribution. -- DefaultSCADomain: // Look for META-INF/sca-contribution.xml contributionArtifactPath = Contribution.SCA_CONTRIBUTION_META; contributionArtifactURL = classLoader.getResource(contributionArtifactPath); --- Should it be "classLoader.getResources(contributionArtifactPath)" for multiple contributions? And following codes doesn't handle multiple contribution neither. Like 'ContributionServiceImpl.addContribution', is called only once. This really depends on how the hosting environment discover all contributions and decide which ones to be added to the domain. I think there was a discussion thread on this subject, or if not, I'll start a new one. 2)CONTRIBUTION META DOCUMENT MERGING in SCA spec 1.10.2.2 write: "...accommodate this, it is also possible to have an identically structured document at META-INF/sca-contribution-generated.xml. If this document exists (or is generated on an as-needed basis), it will be merged into the contents of sca-contribution.xml, with the entries in sca-contribution.xml taking priority if there are any conflicting declarations." Tuscany seems won't load sca-contribution-generated.xml if sca-contribution.xml exists. Yes, this is a bug, would you please raise a JIRA for it ? And it would be great if you want to help with a patch as well. 3)CONTRIBUTION IMPORT/EXPORT Tuscany do resolved 'import' and 'export' in 'sca-contribution.xml'. If only one contribution is resolved, as said in (1), import/export become meaningless. This import/export functionality is not fully implemented in Tuscany yet, there is a JIRA for this http://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/TUSCANY-1161. 4)CONTRIBUTION META EXTENSION contribution meta document resolving hard-coded xml element name , not as extensible as DefaultURLArtifactProcessorExtensionPoint used else where. see also SCA spec 1.10.2.2 "...For example, can be used can be used to export java definitions, in which case the namespace should be a fully qualified package name." This is not implemented yet, any contribution on this and the other mentioned areas would be appreciated. -- Luciano Resende Apache Tuscany Committer http://people.apache.org/~lresende http://lresende.blogspot.com/ - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
How to add multiple contribution to tuscany?
Hi, all: I got several question when looking into Tuscany's codes: 1)MULTIPLE CONTRIBUTION IMO, a contribution is a deployment unit, so a domain should be allowed to have more than one contribution. While Tuscany only handles one contribution. -- DefaultSCADomain: // Look for META-INF/sca-contribution.xml contributionArtifactPath = Contribution.SCA_CONTRIBUTION_META; contributionArtifactURL = classLoader.getResource(contributionArtifactPath); --- Should it be "classLoader.getResources(contributionArtifactPath)" for multiple contributions? And following codes doesn't handle multiple contribution neither. Like 'ContributionServiceImpl.addContribution', is called only once. 2)CONTRIBUTION META DOCUMENT MERGING in SCA spec 1.10.2.2 write: "...accommodate this, it is also possible to have an identically structured document at META-INF/sca-contribution-generated.xml. If this document exists (or is generated on an as-needed basis), it will be merged into the contents of sca-contribution.xml, with the entries in sca-contribution.xml taking priority if there are any conflicting declarations." Tuscany seems won't load sca-contribution-generated.xml if sca-contribution.xml exists. 3)CONTRIBUTION IMPORT/EXPORT Tuscany do resolved 'import' and 'export' in 'sca-contribution.xml'. If only one contribution is resolved, as said in (1), import/export become meaningless. 4)CONTRIBUTION META EXTENSION contribution meta document resolving hard-coded xml element name , not as extensible as DefaultURLArtifactProcessorExtensionPoint used else where. see also SCA spec 1.10.2.2 "...For example, can be used can be used to export java definitions, in which case the namespace should be a fully qualified package name."
