Re: [Bug 747068] [NEW] /tmp = EXT3, the VM images gives EXT4-fs error

2011-04-01 Thread Serge Hallyn
 ((Ok, this is the first time every I file a bug, so give me also
 feedback when I report wrong..))

Thanks for taking the time to report this bug.

 First of all, I want to build a system for production in wich I can build 
 (very) fast new VM's.
 I installed Ubuntu Server 10.04.2 64Bit as host OS with the following 
 partitions:
 
 /Boot [Prim] 1GB (EXT4)
 / [Prim] 25GB (EXT4)
 swap [Prim] 25GB (swap)
 ---extended---
 /tmp [Logical] 25GB (EXT4)
 /var/log [Logical] 10GB (EXT4)
 lvm [Logical] 1,5TB (lvm)
 
 When I use VMBuilder and build to a RAW logica volume (lvm), it takes more 
 than 12 minutes!

I'd recommend building a single pristine image (where time to build doesn't 
matter), and
snapshot or copy that when you need a new image and make the few changes you 
need to.

Maybe that was your plan all along, but since you mention the time it took to 
make the
first image, I wasn't sure.

 Then I tried to change the /tmp partition (of the HOST) to EXT3 and it
did take less than 4 minutes

Interesting.

Are you using a local archive mirror?  It's possible that if you switch back
to ext4 now it'll go much faster.

 The only problem now is that the VM gives the following error on startup:
 EXT4-fs error (device sda1): ext4_mb_generate_buddy:
 EXT4-fs group 2: 3431 blocks in bitmap, 3597 in gd
 
 Any ideas?

Is sda1 your tmpfs?  If so, edit your fstab to mark it as ext3.

 Maybe first any ideas for a workaround?

Actually long-term for most image building we recommend switching to
live-build.  If you try that, and your host has enough memory (more than
4G), then building out of a tmpfs can make for very fast, 2-4 minute,
image builds.  Please feel free to ask for help on irc on freenode
#ubuntu-server or on the ubuntu-server mailing list.

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Server Team, which is subscribed to vm-builder in Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/747068

Title:
  /tmp = EXT3, the VM images gives EXT4-fs error

-- 
Ubuntu-server-bugs mailing list
Ubuntu-server-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com
Modify settings or unsubscribe at: 
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-server-bugs


Re: [Bug 747068] [NEW] /tmp = EXT3, the VM images gives EXT4-fs error

2011-04-01 Thread Serge Hallyn
 ((Ok, this is the first time every I file a bug, so give me also
 feedback when I report wrong..))

Thanks for taking the time to report this bug.

 First of all, I want to build a system for production in wich I can build 
 (very) fast new VM's.
 I installed Ubuntu Server 10.04.2 64Bit as host OS with the following 
 partitions:
 
 /Boot [Prim] 1GB (EXT4)
 / [Prim] 25GB (EXT4)
 swap [Prim] 25GB (swap)
 ---extended---
 /tmp [Logical] 25GB (EXT4)
 /var/log [Logical] 10GB (EXT4)
 lvm [Logical] 1,5TB (lvm)
 
 When I use VMBuilder and build to a RAW logica volume (lvm), it takes more 
 than 12 minutes!

I'd recommend building a single pristine image (where time to build doesn't 
matter), and
snapshot or copy that when you need a new image and make the few changes you 
need to.

Maybe that was your plan all along, but since you mention the time it took to 
make the
first image, I wasn't sure.

 Then I tried to change the /tmp partition (of the HOST) to EXT3 and it
did take less than 4 minutes

Interesting.

Are you using a local archive mirror?  It's possible that if you switch back
to ext4 now it'll go much faster.

 The only problem now is that the VM gives the following error on startup:
 EXT4-fs error (device sda1): ext4_mb_generate_buddy:
 EXT4-fs group 2: 3431 blocks in bitmap, 3597 in gd
 
 Any ideas?

Is sda1 your tmpfs?  If so, edit your fstab to mark it as ext3.

 Maybe first any ideas for a workaround?

Actually long-term for most image building we recommend switching to
live-build.  If you try that, and your host has enough memory (more than
4G), then building out of a tmpfs can make for very fast, 2-4 minute,
image builds.  Please feel free to ask for help on irc on freenode
#ubuntu-server or on the ubuntu-server mailing list.

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/747068

Title:
  /tmp = EXT3, the VM images gives EXT4-fs error

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs