Re: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working
Issue has been implemented in nightly build : https://builds.apache.org/job/JMeter-trunk/lastSuccessfulBuild/artifact/trunk/dist/ Feel free to test it and give feedback. Regards Philippe On Wed, Oct 23, 2013 at 9:09 AM, Nicola Ambrosetti Brolin ambrosetti.nic...@gmail.com wrote: Done: https://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=55693 On 22 October 2013 17:26, Philippe Mouawad philippe.moua...@gmail.com wrote: Hello, It's documented in include controller but maybe needs clarification. @Nicola, could you open a bugzilla for your descriptio about save as ? Thanks On Tuesday, October 22, 2013, Robin D. Wilson wrote: It figures... That works. Now I'll have to go through all my Includes and change them from simple controllers to Test Fragments. Is this documented somewhere - clearly? I read through the Test Fragment stuff, and it was as clear as muddy water... -- Robin D. Wilson Sr. Director of Web Development KingsIsle Entertainment, Inc. VOICE: 512-777-1861 http://www.kingsisle.com -Original Message- From: Nicola Ambrosetti Brolin [mailto:ambrosetti.nic...@gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 8:40 AM To: JMeter Users List Subject: Re: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working The test fragment must be inside the included file, for the include controller will ignore any test element not placed under a test fragment. You can however have a test fragment as parent of the include controller, which includes a file containing another test fragment. I use this setup for example to be able to point to the include controller from a module controller in the thread group. To summarize this is the way to do it: Included file: Test Plan |--Test fragment |-- sampler 1 |-- sampler 2 Test project: Test Plan |--Test fragment | |-- Include controller (pointing to included file above) |-- Thread group |-- Sampler 3 |-- Module controller (pointing to Test Fragment Include controller) |-- Sampler 4 This will be run as: Sampler 3 sampler 1 sampler 2 Sampler 4 On 22 October 2013 14:49, Robin D. Wilson rwils...@gmail.com wrote: So let me understand, do I need to put the Test Fragment inside the included file, or do I put the Include Controller inside a Test Fragment? -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 22, 2013, at 6:52 AM, Nicola Ambrosetti Brolin ambrosetti.nic...@gmail.com wrote: I might add (since I was the reporter of bug 55464) that it is confusing that when using Save selection as the produced jmx project has the selected steps sitting right under the test plan, instead of being under a test fragment. Thus one could be led to believe that the saved selection could be included as is. However this is not the case: the include controller will completely ignore anything in the included project that is not child of a test fragment. Cheers, Nicola On 22 October 2013 10:58, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.comwrote: Hello, I think you are misusing Test Fragments. Test Fragment should be in INCLUDED Test Plan not INCLUDER. So in your case they should be Login.jmx and Timer.jmx. While according to what you show and to log file they are in INCLUDED Test Plan. I think this is what changes mentions: - The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. - The include controller is designed to use an external jmx file. To use it, create a Test Fragment underneath the Test Plan and add any desired samplers, controllers etc. below it. Then save the Test Plan. = The file is now ready to be included as part of other Test Plans.= Regards On Tue, Oct 22, 2013 at 4:13 AM, Robin D. Wilson rwils...@gmail.com wrote: That is exactly what I'm using (Test Fragments)... -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 21, 2013, at 6:49 PM, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.com wrote: Hello, Incompatible changes explains your issue: - http://jmeter.apache.org/changes.html --- To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscr...@jmeter.apache.org javascript:; javascript:; For additional commands, e-mail: user-h...@jmeter.apache.org javascript:; javascript:; -- Regards Ubik Load Pack http://ubikloadpack.com Team Follow us on Twitter http://twitter.com/ubikloadpack Cordialement L'équipe Ubik Load Pack http://ubikloadpack.com
Re: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working
Done: https://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=55693 On 22 October 2013 17:26, Philippe Mouawad philippe.moua...@gmail.comwrote: Hello, It's documented in include controller but maybe needs clarification. @Nicola, could you open a bugzilla for your descriptio about save as ? Thanks On Tuesday, October 22, 2013, Robin D. Wilson wrote: It figures... That works. Now I'll have to go through all my Includes and change them from simple controllers to Test Fragments. Is this documented somewhere - clearly? I read through the Test Fragment stuff, and it was as clear as muddy water... -- Robin D. Wilson Sr. Director of Web Development KingsIsle Entertainment, Inc. VOICE: 512-777-1861 http://www.kingsisle.com -Original Message- From: Nicola Ambrosetti Brolin [mailto:ambrosetti.nic...@gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 8:40 AM To: JMeter Users List Subject: Re: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working The test fragment must be inside the included file, for the include controller will ignore any test element not placed under a test fragment. You can however have a test fragment as parent of the include controller, which includes a file containing another test fragment. I use this setup for example to be able to point to the include controller from a module controller in the thread group. To summarize this is the way to do it: Included file: Test Plan |--Test fragment |-- sampler 1 |-- sampler 2 Test project: Test Plan |--Test fragment | |-- Include controller (pointing to included file above) |-- Thread group |-- Sampler 3 |-- Module controller (pointing to Test Fragment Include controller) |-- Sampler 4 This will be run as: Sampler 3 sampler 1 sampler 2 Sampler 4 On 22 October 2013 14:49, Robin D. Wilson rwils...@gmail.com wrote: So let me understand, do I need to put the Test Fragment inside the included file, or do I put the Include Controller inside a Test Fragment? -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 22, 2013, at 6:52 AM, Nicola Ambrosetti Brolin ambrosetti.nic...@gmail.com wrote: I might add (since I was the reporter of bug 55464) that it is confusing that when using Save selection as the produced jmx project has the selected steps sitting right under the test plan, instead of being under a test fragment. Thus one could be led to believe that the saved selection could be included as is. However this is not the case: the include controller will completely ignore anything in the included project that is not child of a test fragment. Cheers, Nicola On 22 October 2013 10:58, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.comwrote: Hello, I think you are misusing Test Fragments. Test Fragment should be in INCLUDED Test Plan not INCLUDER. So in your case they should be Login.jmx and Timer.jmx. While according to what you show and to log file they are in INCLUDED Test Plan. I think this is what changes mentions: - The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. - The include controller is designed to use an external jmx file. To use it, create a Test Fragment underneath the Test Plan and add any desired samplers, controllers etc. below it. Then save the Test Plan. = The file is now ready to be included as part of other Test Plans.= Regards On Tue, Oct 22, 2013 at 4:13 AM, Robin D. Wilson rwils...@gmail.com wrote: That is exactly what I'm using (Test Fragments)... -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 21, 2013, at 6:49 PM, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.com wrote: Hello, Incompatible changes explains your issue: - http://jmeter.apache.org/changes.html --- To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscr...@jmeter.apache.org javascript:; javascript:; For additional commands, e-mail: user-h...@jmeter.apache.org javascript:; javascript:; -- Regards Ubik Load Pack http://ubikloadpack.com Team Follow us on Twitter http://twitter.com/ubikloadpack Cordialement L'équipe Ubik Load Pack http://ubikloadpack.com Suivez-nous sur Twitter http://twitter.com/ubikloadpack --- -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscr...@jmeter.apache.org javascript:; For additional commands, e-mail: user-h...@jmeter.apache.org javascript:; -- Regards Ubik Load Pack http://ubikloadpack.com Team Follow us on Twitter http://twitter.com/ubikloadpack Cordialement
Re: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working
Hello, I think you are misusing Test Fragments. Test Fragment should be in INCLUDED Test Plan not INCLUDER. So in your case they should be Login.jmx and Timer.jmx. While according to what you show and to log file they are in INCLUDED Test Plan. I think this is what changes mentions: - The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. - The include controller is designed to use an external jmx file. To use it, create a Test Fragment underneath the Test Plan and add any desired samplers, controllers etc. below it. Then save the Test Plan. = The file is now ready to be included as part of other Test Plans.= Regards On Tue, Oct 22, 2013 at 4:13 AM, Robin D. Wilson rwils...@gmail.com wrote: That is exactly what I'm using (Test Fragments)... -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 21, 2013, at 6:49 PM, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.com wrote: Hello, Incompatible changes explains your issue: - jmeter.apache.org/changes.html - In previous versions, *IncludeController *could run Test Elements located inside a *Thread Group *, this behaviour ( *which was not documented *) ould result in weird behaviour, it has been removed in this version (see Bug 55464https://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=55464 ). The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. Regards @ubikloadpack On Tuesday, October 22, 2013, Robin D. Wilson wrote: I have a test that includes some test fragments using an 'Include Controller', and then those test frags are used throughout the thread groups by being added in a 'Module Controller'. When I load my test, I get these messages in the log: --- 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.gui.action.Load: Loading file: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test\W101 Login Stress Generator_wTestFrag.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Utility\Timer.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Utility\Timer.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree -- NOTE: The repeat of the INFO+WARN messages about trying to load the IncludeController is puzzling, since there are only 2 Include Controllers in the test plan... Not sure why it appears to be trying to load each of them twice. This same test works perfectly on JMeter 2.9 (and earlier). FYI, the test looks like this: Test Plan Setup stuff (User Defined Vars, Requests Defaults, Cookie Manager, etc.) Includes Test Fragment Include Controller - Login.jmx Include Controller - Timer.jmx Timer Start Thread Group User Parameters - Timer Start Module Controller - Timer (from Includes/Timer module above) Login Thread Group User Parameters - Login Module Controller - Login (from Includes/Login module above) Timer End Thread Group User Parameters - Timer End Module Controller - Timer (from Includes/Timer module above) Tree Listener (only shows 'errors') Summary Report Listener Near as I can tell, each thread group runs - for as many threads as I expect - but
Re: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working
I might add (since I was the reporter of bug 55464) that it is confusing that when using Save selection as the produced jmx project has the selected steps sitting right under the test plan, instead of being under a test fragment. Thus one could be led to believe that the saved selection could be included as is. However this is not the case: the include controller will completely ignore anything in the included project that is not child of a test fragment. Cheers, Nicola On 22 October 2013 10:58, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.comwrote: Hello, I think you are misusing Test Fragments. Test Fragment should be in INCLUDED Test Plan not INCLUDER. So in your case they should be Login.jmx and Timer.jmx. While according to what you show and to log file they are in INCLUDED Test Plan. I think this is what changes mentions: - The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. - The include controller is designed to use an external jmx file. To use it, create a Test Fragment underneath the Test Plan and add any desired samplers, controllers etc. below it. Then save the Test Plan. = The file is now ready to be included as part of other Test Plans.= Regards On Tue, Oct 22, 2013 at 4:13 AM, Robin D. Wilson rwils...@gmail.com wrote: That is exactly what I'm using (Test Fragments)... -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 21, 2013, at 6:49 PM, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.com wrote: Hello, Incompatible changes explains your issue: - jmeter.apache.org/changes.html - In previous versions, *IncludeController *could run Test Elements located inside a *Thread Group *, this behaviour ( *which was not documented *) ould result in weird behaviour, it has been removed in this version (see Bug 55464https://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=55464 ). The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. Regards @ubikloadpack On Tuesday, October 22, 2013, Robin D. Wilson wrote: I have a test that includes some test fragments using an 'Include Controller', and then those test frags are used throughout the thread groups by being added in a 'Module Controller'. When I load my test, I get these messages in the log: --- 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.gui.action.Load: Loading file: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test\W101 Login Stress Generator_wTestFrag.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Utility\Timer.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Utility\Timer.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree -- NOTE: The repeat of the INFO+WARN messages about trying to load the IncludeController is puzzling, since there are only 2 Include Controllers in the test plan... Not sure why it appears to be trying to load each of them twice. This same test works perfectly on JMeter 2.9 (and earlier). FYI, the test looks like this: Test Plan Setup stuff (User Defined Vars, Requests Defaults, Cookie Manager, etc.) Includes Test Fragment Include Controller - Login.jmx Include Controller - Timer.jmx Timer Start Thread Group
Re: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working
So let me understand, do I need to put the Test Fragment inside the included file, or do I put the Include Controller inside a Test Fragment? -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 22, 2013, at 6:52 AM, Nicola Ambrosetti Brolin ambrosetti.nic...@gmail.com wrote: I might add (since I was the reporter of bug 55464) that it is confusing that when using Save selection as the produced jmx project has the selected steps sitting right under the test plan, instead of being under a test fragment. Thus one could be led to believe that the saved selection could be included as is. However this is not the case: the include controller will completely ignore anything in the included project that is not child of a test fragment. Cheers, Nicola On 22 October 2013 10:58, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.comwrote: Hello, I think you are misusing Test Fragments. Test Fragment should be in INCLUDED Test Plan not INCLUDER. So in your case they should be Login.jmx and Timer.jmx. While according to what you show and to log file they are in INCLUDED Test Plan. I think this is what changes mentions: - The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. - The include controller is designed to use an external jmx file. To use it, create a Test Fragment underneath the Test Plan and add any desired samplers, controllers etc. below it. Then save the Test Plan. = The file is now ready to be included as part of other Test Plans.= Regards On Tue, Oct 22, 2013 at 4:13 AM, Robin D. Wilson rwils...@gmail.com wrote: That is exactly what I'm using (Test Fragments)... -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 21, 2013, at 6:49 PM, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.com wrote: Hello, Incompatible changes explains your issue: - jmeter.apache.org/changes.html - In previous versions, *IncludeController *could run Test Elements located inside a *Thread Group *, this behaviour ( *which was not documented *) ould result in weird behaviour, it has been removed in this version (see Bug 55464https://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=55464 ). The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. Regards @ubikloadpack On Tuesday, October 22, 2013, Robin D. Wilson wrote: I have a test that includes some test fragments using an 'Include Controller', and then those test frags are used throughout the thread groups by being added in a 'Module Controller'. When I load my test, I get these messages in the log: --- 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.gui.action.Load: Loading file: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test\W101 Login Stress Generator_wTestFrag.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Utility\Timer.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Utility\Timer.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree -- NOTE: The repeat of the INFO+WARN messages about trying to load the IncludeController is puzzling, since there are only 2 Include Controllers in the test plan... Not sure why it appears to be trying to load each of them twice. This same test works perfectly on JMeter 2.9 (and earlier). FYI, the test looks like this: Test Plan Setup stuff (User Defined Vars, Requests Defaults, Cookie Manager, etc.) Includes Test Fragment Include
Re: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working
The test fragment must be inside the included file, for the include controller will ignore any test element not placed under a test fragment. You can however have a test fragment as parent of the include controller, which includes a file containing another test fragment. I use this setup for example to be able to point to the include controller from a module controller in the thread group. To summarize this is the way to do it: Included file: Test Plan |--Test fragment |-- sampler 1 |-- sampler 2 Test project: Test Plan |--Test fragment | |-- Include controller (pointing to included file above) |-- Thread group |-- Sampler 3 |-- Module controller (pointing to Test Fragment Include controller) |-- Sampler 4 This will be run as: Sampler 3 sampler 1 sampler 2 Sampler 4 On 22 October 2013 14:49, Robin D. Wilson rwils...@gmail.com wrote: So let me understand, do I need to put the Test Fragment inside the included file, or do I put the Include Controller inside a Test Fragment? -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 22, 2013, at 6:52 AM, Nicola Ambrosetti Brolin ambrosetti.nic...@gmail.com wrote: I might add (since I was the reporter of bug 55464) that it is confusing that when using Save selection as the produced jmx project has the selected steps sitting right under the test plan, instead of being under a test fragment. Thus one could be led to believe that the saved selection could be included as is. However this is not the case: the include controller will completely ignore anything in the included project that is not child of a test fragment. Cheers, Nicola On 22 October 2013 10:58, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.comwrote: Hello, I think you are misusing Test Fragments. Test Fragment should be in INCLUDED Test Plan not INCLUDER. So in your case they should be Login.jmx and Timer.jmx. While according to what you show and to log file they are in INCLUDED Test Plan. I think this is what changes mentions: - The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. - The include controller is designed to use an external jmx file. To use it, create a Test Fragment underneath the Test Plan and add any desired samplers, controllers etc. below it. Then save the Test Plan. = The file is now ready to be included as part of other Test Plans.= Regards On Tue, Oct 22, 2013 at 4:13 AM, Robin D. Wilson rwils...@gmail.com wrote: That is exactly what I'm using (Test Fragments)... -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 21, 2013, at 6:49 PM, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.com wrote: Hello, Incompatible changes explains your issue: - jmeter.apache.org/changes.html - In previous versions, *IncludeController *could run Test Elements located inside a *Thread Group *, this behaviour ( *which was not documented *) ould result in weird behaviour, it has been removed in this version (see Bug 55464https://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=55464 ). The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. Regards @ubikloadpack On Tuesday, October 22, 2013, Robin D. Wilson wrote: I have a test that includes some test fragments using an 'Include Controller', and then those test frags are used throughout the thread groups by being added in a 'Module Controller'. When I load my test, I get these messages in the log: --- 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.gui.action.Load: Loading file: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test\W101 Login Stress Generator_wTestFrag.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Utility\Timer.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34
RE: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working
It figures... That works. Now I'll have to go through all my Includes and change them from simple controllers to Test Fragments. Is this documented somewhere - clearly? I read through the Test Fragment stuff, and it was as clear as muddy water... -- Robin D. Wilson Sr. Director of Web Development KingsIsle Entertainment, Inc. VOICE: 512-777-1861 http://www.kingsisle.com -Original Message- From: Nicola Ambrosetti Brolin [mailto:ambrosetti.nic...@gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 8:40 AM To: JMeter Users List Subject: Re: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working The test fragment must be inside the included file, for the include controller will ignore any test element not placed under a test fragment. You can however have a test fragment as parent of the include controller, which includes a file containing another test fragment. I use this setup for example to be able to point to the include controller from a module controller in the thread group. To summarize this is the way to do it: Included file: Test Plan |--Test fragment |-- sampler 1 |-- sampler 2 Test project: Test Plan |--Test fragment | |-- Include controller (pointing to included file above) |-- Thread group |-- Sampler 3 |-- Module controller (pointing to Test Fragment Include controller) |-- Sampler 4 This will be run as: Sampler 3 sampler 1 sampler 2 Sampler 4 On 22 October 2013 14:49, Robin D. Wilson rwils...@gmail.com wrote: So let me understand, do I need to put the Test Fragment inside the included file, or do I put the Include Controller inside a Test Fragment? -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 22, 2013, at 6:52 AM, Nicola Ambrosetti Brolin ambrosetti.nic...@gmail.com wrote: I might add (since I was the reporter of bug 55464) that it is confusing that when using Save selection as the produced jmx project has the selected steps sitting right under the test plan, instead of being under a test fragment. Thus one could be led to believe that the saved selection could be included as is. However this is not the case: the include controller will completely ignore anything in the included project that is not child of a test fragment. Cheers, Nicola On 22 October 2013 10:58, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.comwrote: Hello, I think you are misusing Test Fragments. Test Fragment should be in INCLUDED Test Plan not INCLUDER. So in your case they should be Login.jmx and Timer.jmx. While according to what you show and to log file they are in INCLUDED Test Plan. I think this is what changes mentions: - The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. - The include controller is designed to use an external jmx file. To use it, create a Test Fragment underneath the Test Plan and add any desired samplers, controllers etc. below it. Then save the Test Plan. = The file is now ready to be included as part of other Test Plans.= Regards On Tue, Oct 22, 2013 at 4:13 AM, Robin D. Wilson rwils...@gmail.com wrote: That is exactly what I'm using (Test Fragments)... -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 21, 2013, at 6:49 PM, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.com wrote: Hello, Incompatible changes explains your issue: - jmeter.apache.org/changes.html - In previous versions, *IncludeController *could run Test Elements located inside a *Thread Group *, this behaviour ( *which was not documented *) ould result in weird behaviour, it has been removed in this version (see Bug 55464https://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=55464 ). The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. Regards @ubikloadpack On Tuesday, October 22, 2013, Robin D. Wilson wrote: I have a test that includes some test fragments using an 'Include Controller', and then those test frags are used throughout the thread groups by being added in a 'Module Controller'. When I load my test, I get these messages in the log: --- 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.gui.action.Load: Loading file: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test\W101 Login Stress Generator_wTestFrag.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN
Re: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working
Hello, It's documented in include controller but maybe needs clarification. @Nicola, could you open a bugzilla for your descriptio about save as ? Thanks On Tuesday, October 22, 2013, Robin D. Wilson wrote: It figures... That works. Now I'll have to go through all my Includes and change them from simple controllers to Test Fragments. Is this documented somewhere - clearly? I read through the Test Fragment stuff, and it was as clear as muddy water... -- Robin D. Wilson Sr. Director of Web Development KingsIsle Entertainment, Inc. VOICE: 512-777-1861 http://www.kingsisle.com -Original Message- From: Nicola Ambrosetti Brolin [mailto:ambrosetti.nic...@gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 8:40 AM To: JMeter Users List Subject: Re: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working The test fragment must be inside the included file, for the include controller will ignore any test element not placed under a test fragment. You can however have a test fragment as parent of the include controller, which includes a file containing another test fragment. I use this setup for example to be able to point to the include controller from a module controller in the thread group. To summarize this is the way to do it: Included file: Test Plan |--Test fragment |-- sampler 1 |-- sampler 2 Test project: Test Plan |--Test fragment | |-- Include controller (pointing to included file above) |-- Thread group |-- Sampler 3 |-- Module controller (pointing to Test Fragment Include controller) |-- Sampler 4 This will be run as: Sampler 3 sampler 1 sampler 2 Sampler 4 On 22 October 2013 14:49, Robin D. Wilson rwils...@gmail.com wrote: So let me understand, do I need to put the Test Fragment inside the included file, or do I put the Include Controller inside a Test Fragment? -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 22, 2013, at 6:52 AM, Nicola Ambrosetti Brolin ambrosetti.nic...@gmail.com wrote: I might add (since I was the reporter of bug 55464) that it is confusing that when using Save selection as the produced jmx project has the selected steps sitting right under the test plan, instead of being under a test fragment. Thus one could be led to believe that the saved selection could be included as is. However this is not the case: the include controller will completely ignore anything in the included project that is not child of a test fragment. Cheers, Nicola On 22 October 2013 10:58, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.comwrote: Hello, I think you are misusing Test Fragments. Test Fragment should be in INCLUDED Test Plan not INCLUDER. So in your case they should be Login.jmx and Timer.jmx. While according to what you show and to log file they are in INCLUDED Test Plan. I think this is what changes mentions: - The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. - The include controller is designed to use an external jmx file. To use it, create a Test Fragment underneath the Test Plan and add any desired samplers, controllers etc. below it. Then save the Test Plan. = The file is now ready to be included as part of other Test Plans.= Regards On Tue, Oct 22, 2013 at 4:13 AM, Robin D. Wilson rwils...@gmail.com wrote: That is exactly what I'm using (Test Fragments)... -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 21, 2013, at 6:49 PM, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.com wrote: Hello, Incompatible changes explains your issue: - http://jmeter.apache.org/changes.html --- To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscr...@jmeter.apache.org javascript:; javascript:; For additional commands, e-mail: user-h...@jmeter.apache.orgjavascript:; javascript:; -- Regards Ubik Load Pack http://ubikloadpack.com Team Follow us on Twitter http://twitter.com/ubikloadpack Cordialement L'équipe Ubik Load Pack http://ubikloadpack.com Suivez-nous sur Twitter http://twitter.com/ubikloadpack --- -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscr...@jmeter.apache.orgjavascript:; For additional commands, e-mail: user-h...@jmeter.apache.orgjavascript:; -- Regards Ubik Load Pack http://ubikloadpack.com Team Follow us on Twitter http://twitter.com/ubikloadpack Cordialement L'équipe Ubik Load Pack http://ubikloadpack.com Suivez-nous sur Twitter http://twitter.com/ubikloadpack - To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscr...@jmeter.apache.orgjavascript:; For additional commands, e-mail: user-h
Re: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working
Hello, Incompatible changes explains your issue: - jmeter.apache.org/changes.html - In previous versions, *IncludeController *could run Test Elements located inside a *Thread Group *, this behaviour ( *which was not documented *) ould result in weird behaviour, it has been removed in this version (see Bug 55464https://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=55464 ). The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. Regards @ubikloadpack On Tuesday, October 22, 2013, Robin D. Wilson wrote: I have a test that includes some test fragments using an 'Include Controller', and then those test frags are used throughout the thread groups by being added in a 'Module Controller'. When I load my test, I get these messages in the log: --- 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.gui.action.Load: Loading file: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test\W101 Login Stress Generator_wTestFrag.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Utility\Timer.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Utility\Timer.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree -- NOTE: The repeat of the INFO+WARN messages about trying to load the IncludeController is puzzling, since there are only 2 Include Controllers in the test plan... Not sure why it appears to be trying to load each of them twice. This same test works perfectly on JMeter 2.9 (and earlier). FYI, the test looks like this: Test Plan Setup stuff (User Defined Vars, Requests Defaults, Cookie Manager, etc.) Includes Test Fragment Include Controller - Login.jmx Include Controller - Timer.jmx Timer Start Thread Group User Parameters - Timer Start Module Controller - Timer (from Includes/Timer module above) Login Thread Group User Parameters - Login Module Controller - Login (from Includes/Login module above) Timer End Thread Group User Parameters - Timer End Module Controller - Timer (from Includes/Timer module above) Tree Listener (only shows 'errors') Summary Report Listener Near as I can tell, each thread group runs - for as many threads as I expect - but nothing happens within the thread group (e.g., none of the 'Module Controllers' actually do anything). BTW, if I merge the two Included test fragments - into the Includes Test Fragment - and re-configure my module controllers to point to the merged stuff, it works. So it appears to be a problem with the Include Controller not actually loading my stuff. I have noted a significant performance boost on this new version of JMeter, but I can't use it if I can't get the Include Controller to work... So any help would be very appreciated. -- Robin D. Wilson Sr. Director of Web Development KingsIsle Entertainment, Inc. VOICE: 512-777-1861 http://www.kingsisle.com - To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscr...@jmeter.apache.org javascript:; For additional commands, e-mail: user-h...@jmeter.apache.orgjavascript:; -- Regards Ubik Load Pack http://ubikloadpack.com Team Follow us on Twitter http://twitter.com/ubikloadpack Cordialement L'équipe Ubik Load Pack
Re: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working
That is exactly what I'm using (Test Fragments)... -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 21, 2013, at 6:49 PM, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.com wrote: Hello, Incompatible changes explains your issue: - jmeter.apache.org/changes.html - In previous versions, *IncludeController *could run Test Elements located inside a *Thread Group *, this behaviour ( *which was not documented *) ould result in weird behaviour, it has been removed in this version (see Bug 55464https://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=55464 ). The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. Regards @ubikloadpack On Tuesday, October 22, 2013, Robin D. Wilson wrote: I have a test that includes some test fragments using an 'Include Controller', and then those test frags are used throughout the thread groups by being added in a 'Module Controller'. When I load my test, I get these messages in the log: --- 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.gui.action.Load: Loading file: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test\W101 Login Stress Generator_wTestFrag.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Utility\Timer.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Utility\Timer.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree -- NOTE: The repeat of the INFO+WARN messages about trying to load the IncludeController is puzzling, since there are only 2 Include Controllers in the test plan... Not sure why it appears to be trying to load each of them twice. This same test works perfectly on JMeter 2.9 (and earlier). FYI, the test looks like this: Test Plan Setup stuff (User Defined Vars, Requests Defaults, Cookie Manager, etc.) Includes Test Fragment Include Controller - Login.jmx Include Controller - Timer.jmx Timer Start Thread Group User Parameters - Timer Start Module Controller - Timer (from Includes/Timer module above) Login Thread Group User Parameters - Login Module Controller - Login (from Includes/Login module above) Timer End Thread Group User Parameters - Timer End Module Controller - Timer (from Includes/Timer module above) Tree Listener (only shows 'errors') Summary Report Listener Near as I can tell, each thread group runs - for as many threads as I expect - but nothing happens within the thread group (e.g., none of the 'Module Controllers' actually do anything). BTW, if I merge the two Included test fragments - into the Includes Test Fragment - and re-configure my module controllers to point to the merged stuff, it works. So it appears to be a problem with the Include Controller not actually loading my stuff. I have noted a significant performance boost on this new version of JMeter, but I can't use it if I can't get the Include Controller to work... So any help would be very appreciated. -- Robin D. Wilson Sr. Director of Web Development KingsIsle Entertainment, Inc. VOICE: 512-777-1861 http://www.kingsisle.com - To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscr...@jmeter.apache.org javascript:; For additional commands, e-mail:
Re: JMeter 2.10 Include Controller doesn't seem to be working
Hello, Can you open a bugzilla with a sample test plan ? Thank you On Tuesday, October 22, 2013, Robin D. Wilson wrote: That is exactly what I'm using (Test Fragments)... -- Robin D. Wilson VOICE: 512-777-1861 On Oct 21, 2013, at 6:49 PM, UBIK LOAD PACK Support supp...@ubikloadpack.com javascript:; wrote: Hello, Incompatible changes explains your issue: - jmeter.apache.org/changes.html - In previous versions, *IncludeController *could run Test Elements located inside a *Thread Group *, this behaviour ( *which was not documented *) ould result in weird behaviour, it has been removed in this version (see Bug 55464https://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=55464 ). The correct way to include Test Elements is to use *Test Fragment *as stated in documentation of *Include Controller *. Regards @ubikloadpack On Tuesday, October 22, 2013, Robin D. Wilson wrote: I have a test that includes some test fragments using an 'Include Controller', and then those test frags are used throughout the thread groups by being added in a 'Module Controller'. When I load my test, I get these messages in the log: --- 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.gui.action.Load: Loading file: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test\W101 Login Stress Generator_wTestFrag.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:33 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.services.FileServer: Set new base='X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Stress Test' 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Utility\Timer.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Login.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree 2013/10/21 18:20:34 INFO - jmeter.control.IncludeController: loadIncludedElements -- try to load included module: X:\Tests\JMeter\WizardHome\TestSuites\Functional Units\Utility\Timer.jmx 2013/10/21 18:20:34 WARN - jmeter.control.IncludeController: No Test Fragment was found in included Test Plan, returning empty HashTree -- NOTE: The repeat of the INFO+WARN messages about trying to load the IncludeController is puzzling, since there are only 2 Include Controllers in the test plan... Not sure why it appears to be trying to load each of them twice. This same test works perfectly on JMeter 2.9 (and earlier). FYI, the test looks like this: Test Plan Setup stuff (User Defined Vars, Requests Defaults, Cookie Manager, etc.) Includes Test Fragment Include Controller - Login.jmx Include Controller - Timer.jmx Timer Start Thread Group User Parameters - Timer Start Module Controller - Timer (from Includes/Timer module above) Login Thread Group User Parameters - Login Module Controller - Login (from Includes/Login module above) Timer End Thread Group User Parameters - Timer End Module Controller - Timer (from Includes/Timer module above) Tree Listene To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscr...@jmeter.apache.org javascript:; javascript:; For additional commands, e-mail: user-h...@jmeter.apache.orgjavascript:; javascript:; -- Regards Ubik Load Pack http://ubikloadpack.com Team Follow us on Twitter http://twitter.com/ubikloadpack Cordialement L'équipe Ubik Load Pack http://ubikloadpack.com Suivez-nous sur Twitter http://twitter.com/ubikloadpack - To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscr...@jmeter.apache.org javascript:; For additional commands, e-mail: user-h...@jmeter.apache.orgjavascript:; -- Cordialement. Philippe Mouawad.
