Re: [SOGo] Thunderbird Reminder Issue
Il 31/08/2012 18:34, Ludovic Marcotte ha scritto: What we could do in SOGo Integrator to mitigate the issue is that after reading/refreshing the ACLs from the server, we could disable alarms to calendars where we can't write to. +1 Thanks Ludovic. -- Alessio Fattorini (alessio.fattor...@nethesis.it) nethesis srl - Via degli Olmi 12 - 61122 Pesaro (PU) tel. +39 0721 405516 - fax +39 0721 268147 www.nethesis.it - i...@nethesis.it -- users@sogo.nu https://inverse.ca/sogo/lists
Re: [SOGo] Thunderbird Reminder Issue
Hello Zachary Acreman On 2012-08-31 04:55, Zachary Acreman wrote: This is an inadequate answer. 1) If reminders from shared calendars don't work in Thunderbird, they should be disabled by default; 2) Reminders from shared calendars SHOULD work in Thunderbird, because it is an obvious thing to want to be able to do. This has been an issue for years. The problems arising from this bug have made me look like kind of a jerk for pushing SOGo in my organization. As it works in the SOGo Webinterface, the error must be in Lightning. Lightning is developed by Mozilla And sorry, but this is a SOGo list not a Thunderbird / Lightning / Mozilla list. Did you open a bug report for that in the Mozilla Lightning bug tracking system? Kind regards, Christian Mack On 8/23/2012 10:55 AM, Christian Mack wrote: Hello Greg On 2012-08-07 19:14, supp...@conley-inc.com wrote: SOGo Server: CentOS 6 Sogo 1.3.17 Thunderbird 10.x Lightning 1.2.3 SOGo Connector 10.0.3 SOGo Integrator 10.0.3 PostgreSQL 8.4.12 LDAP Server: CentOS 6 OpenLDAP I am running into an issue lately with Thunderbird. I don't know how long this has been going on. This problem may have existed on previous versions of SOGo or the Thunderbird extensions, but I didn't notice it until recently. The problem occurs when a person (#1) is subscribed to another person's (#2) calendar (view only). If person #2 has current alarms set for events, these alarms will show up as reminders on person #1's Thunderbird. When person #1 attempts to dismiss these alarms he/she gets the following error: An error occurred when writing to the calendar Bob Smith! Error Code: MODIFICATION_FAILED Description: Status Code: 403, The user lacks the required permission to perform the request. ?xml version=1.0 encoding=ISO-8859-1? html xmlns=http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml; bodyh3An error occurred during object publishing/h3ptried to access private object (0x0x25ca428, SoClass=SOGoAppointmentObject)/p/body /html When person #1 attempts to set person #2's calendar to not show reminders, this setting does not take effect. Upon restart of Thunderbird, the Show Reminders box is once again checked. The only way to turn off the reminders is to login to the SOGo web interface and uncheck the Show Alarms box for that particular person's calendar. This problem occurs on both Windows (XP and 7) and Linux (Ubuntu 10.04) clients. Right now, using the web interface to disable alarms is a suitable workaround. However, it would be nice to have this functionality working in Thunderbird, as well. I don't know whether this is a SOGo (extension?) issue, or a Thunderbird issue. If anyone has some suggestions to solve this issue, I'm all ears! In Lightning and SOGo you can disable alarms for each calendar. Select it, right click it and choose Properties. There is an option Show Reminders (Lightning) or Show Alarms (SOGo). Just disable it ;-) -- Christian Mack Gruppe Informationsdienste Rechenzentrum Universität Konstanz -- users@sogo.nu https://inverse.ca/sogo/lists
Re: [SOGo] Thunderbird Reminder Issue
As the reported problem is not with calendar or alarm *display*, but with calendar *sharing* and permissions, that suggests a SOGo Connector or Integrator problem. The bug is not present in Thunderbird/Lightning alone, by definition. Even if it were a Lightning bug, SOGo's frontend tools require an old version of Lightning, so bug reports against that would not be particularly fruitful. The SOGo project bills Thunderbird integration as a selling point, so it's reasonable to expect problems with the SOGo/Thunderbird user experience to be taken seriously. This one has been reported before in the time that I've used SOGo. Do SOGo's frontend plugins have their own list? They do not appear to. If this is not the appropriate place to discuss problems with the SOGo/Thunderbird user experience, where is? Zachary Acreman zjacre...@nasen.org On 8/31/2012 3:50 AM, Christian Mack wrote: Hello Zachary Acreman On 2012-08-31 04:55, Zachary Acreman wrote: This is an inadequate answer. 1) If reminders from shared calendars don't work in Thunderbird, they should be disabled by default; 2) Reminders from shared calendars SHOULD work in Thunderbird, because it is an obvious thing to want to be able to do. This has been an issue for years. The problems arising from this bug have made me look like kind of a jerk for pushing SOGo in my organization. As it works in the SOGo Webinterface, the error must be in Lightning. Lightning is developed by Mozilla And sorry, but this is a SOGo list not a Thunderbird / Lightning / Mozilla list. Did you open a bug report for that in the Mozilla Lightning bug tracking system? Kind regards, Christian Mack On 8/23/2012 10:55 AM, Christian Mack wrote: Hello Greg On 2012-08-07 19:14, supp...@conley-inc.com wrote: SOGo Server: CentOS 6 Sogo 1.3.17 Thunderbird 10.x Lightning 1.2.3 SOGo Connector 10.0.3 SOGo Integrator 10.0.3 PostgreSQL 8.4.12 LDAP Server: CentOS 6 OpenLDAP I am running into an issue lately with Thunderbird. I don't know how long this has been going on. This problem may have existed on previous versions of SOGo or the Thunderbird extensions, but I didn't notice it until recently. The problem occurs when a person (#1) is subscribed to another person's (#2) calendar (view only). If person #2 has current alarms set for events, these alarms will show up as reminders on person #1's Thunderbird. When person #1 attempts to dismiss these alarms he/she gets the following error: An error occurred when writing to the calendar Bob Smith! Error Code: MODIFICATION_FAILED Description: Status Code: 403, The user lacks the required permission to perform the request. ?xml version=1.0 encoding=ISO-8859-1? html xmlns=http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml; bodyh3An error occurred during object publishing/h3ptried to access private object (0x0x25ca428, SoClass=SOGoAppointmentObject)/p/body /html When person #1 attempts to set person #2's calendar to not show reminders, this setting does not take effect. Upon restart of Thunderbird, the Show Reminders box is once again checked. The only way to turn off the reminders is to login to the SOGo web interface and uncheck the Show Alarms box for that particular person's calendar. This problem occurs on both Windows (XP and 7) and Linux (Ubuntu 10.04) clients. Right now, using the web interface to disable alarms is a suitable workaround. However, it would be nice to have this functionality working in Thunderbird, as well. I don't know whether this is a SOGo (extension?) issue, or a Thunderbird issue. If anyone has some suggestions to solve this issue, I'm all ears! In Lightning and SOGo you can disable alarms for each calendar. Select it, right click it and choose Properties. There is an option Show Reminders (Lightning) or Show Alarms (SOGo). Just disable it ;-) -- users@sogo.nu https://inverse.ca/sogo/lists
Re: [SOGo] Thunderbird Reminder Issue
On 31/08/12 11:59, Zachary Acreman wrote: As the reported problem is not with calendar or alarm *display*, but with calendar *sharing* and permissions, that suggests a SOGo Connector or Integrator problem. The bug is not present in Thunderbird/Lightning alone, by definition. That's not true. Lightning tries to do a PUT on the shared calendars where you activated alarms and where you don't have write permissions. Lightning shouldn't do that - it should simply update its internal cache for alerts acknowledgment. If you manually subscribe to a CalDAV calendar with a Thunderbird profile that doesn't have the SOGo extensions, you'll have the same error. I remember discussing that years ago with the Mozilla Calendar development team but I don't recall the outcome. What we could do in SOGo Integrator to mitigate the issue is that after reading/refreshing the ACLs from the server, we could disable alarms to calendars where we can't write to. -- Ludovic Marcotte +1.514.755.3630 :: www.inverse.ca Inverse inc. :: Leaders behind SOGo (www.sogo.nu) and PacketFence (www.packetfence.org) -- users@sogo.nu https://inverse.ca/sogo/lists
Re: [SOGo] Thunderbird Reminder Issue
This is an inadequate answer. 1) If reminders from shared calendars don't work in Thunderbird, they should be disabled by default; 2) Reminders from shared calendars SHOULD work in Thunderbird, because it is an obvious thing to want to be able to do. This has been an issue for years. The problems arising from this bug have made me look like kind of a jerk for pushing SOGo in my organization. Zakk Acreman zjacre...@nasen.org On 8/23/2012 10:55 AM, Christian Mack wrote: Hello Greg On 2012-08-07 19:14, supp...@conley-inc.com wrote: SOGo Server: CentOS 6 Sogo 1.3.17 Thunderbird 10.x Lightning 1.2.3 SOGo Connector 10.0.3 SOGo Integrator 10.0.3 PostgreSQL 8.4.12 LDAP Server: CentOS 6 OpenLDAP I am running into an issue lately with Thunderbird. I don't know how long this has been going on. This problem may have existed on previous versions of SOGo or the Thunderbird extensions, but I didn't notice it until recently. The problem occurs when a person (#1) is subscribed to another person's (#2) calendar (view only). If person #2 has current alarms set for events, these alarms will show up as reminders on person #1's Thunderbird. When person #1 attempts to dismiss these alarms he/she gets the following error: An error occurred when writing to the calendar Bob Smith! Error Code: MODIFICATION_FAILED Description: Status Code: 403, The user lacks the required permission to perform the request. ?xml version=1.0 encoding=ISO-8859-1? html xmlns=http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml; bodyh3An error occurred during object publishing/h3ptried to access private object (0x0x25ca428, SoClass=SOGoAppointmentObject)/p/body /html When person #1 attempts to set person #2's calendar to not show reminders, this setting does not take effect. Upon restart of Thunderbird, the Show Reminders box is once again checked. The only way to turn off the reminders is to login to the SOGo web interface and uncheck the Show Alarms box for that particular person's calendar. This problem occurs on both Windows (XP and 7) and Linux (Ubuntu 10.04) clients. Right now, using the web interface to disable alarms is a suitable workaround. However, it would be nice to have this functionality working in Thunderbird, as well. I don't know whether this is a SOGo (extension?) issue, or a Thunderbird issue. If anyone has some suggestions to solve this issue, I'm all ears! In Lightning and SOGo you can disable alarms for each calendar. Select it, right click it and choose Properties. There is an option Show Reminders (Lightning) or Show Alarms (SOGo). Just disable it ;-) Kind regards, Christian Mack -- users@sogo.nu https://inverse.ca/sogo/lists
[SOGo] Thunderbird Reminder Issue
SOGo Server: CentOS 6 Sogo 1.3.17 Thunderbird 10.x Lightning 1.2.3 SOGo Connector 10.0.3 SOGo Integrator 10.0.3 PostgreSQL 8.4.12 LDAP Server: CentOS 6 OpenLDAP I am running into an issue lately with Thunderbird. I don't know how long this has been going on. This problem may have existed on previous versions of SOGo or the Thunderbird extensions, but I didn't notice it until recently. The problem occurs when a person (#1) is subscribed to another person's (#2) calendar (view only). If person #2 has current alarms set for events, these alarms will show up as reminders on person #1's Thunderbird. When person #1 attempts to dismiss these alarms he/she gets the following error: An error occurred when writing to the calendar Bob Smith! Error Code: MODIFICATION_FAILED Description: Status Code: 403, The user lacks the required permission to perform the request. ?xml version=1.0 encoding=ISO-8859-1? html xmlns=http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml; bodyh3An error occurred during object publishing/h3ptried to access private object (0x0x25ca428, SoClass=SOGoAppointmentObject)/p/body /html When person #1 attempts to set person #2's calendar to not show reminders, this setting does not take effect. Upon restart of Thunderbird, the Show Reminders box is once again checked. The only way to turn off the reminders is to login to the SOGo web interface and uncheck the Show Alarms box for that particular person's calendar. This problem occurs on both Windows (XP and 7) and Linux (Ubuntu 10.04) clients. Right now, using the web interface to disable alarms is a suitable workaround. However, it would be nice to have this functionality working in Thunderbird, as well. I don't know whether this is a SOGo (extension?) issue, or a Thunderbird issue. If anyone has some suggestions to solve this issue, I'm all ears! Thanks! Greg -- users@sogo.nu https://inverse.ca/sogo/lists
