Re: [webkit-dev] FrameLoaderClient notifications
On Mar 13, 2008, at 8:50 AM, Artem Ananiev wrote: I suppose the following order of loading events for a page with a single frame (please, correct me, if I'm wrong): page load started main document load started title received icon received * main document load finished ** resource load started resource load finished page load finished The the FrameLoaderClient functions about the frame (not the ones that take DocumentLoader*) are what you want. They are all about this cycle. dispatchDidStartProvisionalLoad is the one that goes first, and then there are quite a few others, ending with dispatchDidFinishLoad, dispatchDidFailLoad or dispatchDidFailProvisionalLoad. OK, I see. Is there any other load process other than provisional? All loads start provisional. dispatchWillSendRequest will be called repeatedly with different URLs when a server does redirection. This is normal. How it should be handled depends on what API you've devised. Is there any separate notification about redirection, or this method is enough? There is dispatchDidReceiveServerRedirectForProvisionalLoad for loads of the main resource of a frame, but dispatchWillSendRequest alone is all that's needed for arbitrary resource loads. One more question: is there any method about starting loading of an external resource? Is it dispatchWillSendRequest? dispatchDidReceiveResponse? assignIdentifierToInitialRequest and dispatchWillSendRequest -- Darin ___ webkit-dev mailing list webkit-dev@lists.webkit.org http://lists.webkit.org/mailman/listinfo/webkit-dev
Re: [webkit-dev] FrameLoaderClient notifications
Please, see my comments below. Darin Adler wrote: On Mar 13, 2008, at 4:11 AM, Artem Ananiev wrote: I work on dispatching web load/progress events for Java port and have some questions about notifications in FrameLoaderClient class. 1. What is the right method to implement to get a 'page load started' and 'page load finished' events? I tried the following methods: postProgressStartedNotification() postProgressFinishedNotification() and the problem is they don't accept any params, so I can't get an URL being loaded. If I obtain the URL from frame->loader->documentLoader, it works for 'progress finished' notification, but returns an old URL for 'progress started'. I have no idea what you mean by "page load started" and "finished". If you look at the Mac port you'll see many different types of calls for these purposes. The ones you mention above are best for loading progress, as in a progress bar. I suppose the following order of loading events for a page with a single frame (please, correct me, if I'm wrong): page load started main document load started title received icon received * main document load finished ** resource load started resource load finished page load finished Notes: * = at this time some of the external resources like images may not be loaded yet ** = some resources may be loaded simultaneously After the page is loaded, more 'resource load started' and 'resource load finished' may be triggered by user actions or JavaScript calls. 2. What is the right method to implement to get a 'main document load started'? dispatchDidStartProvisionalLoad OK, I see. Is there any other load process other than provisional? 3. As I understand, the right way to handle resources (for example, images) loading is to track methods assignIdentifierToInitialRequest() dispatchWillSendRequest() dispatchDidFinishLoading() The latter two methods provide request identifiers which are assigned in the former one. However, sometimes I see two 'dispatchWillSendRequest' calls with the same ids and different URLs. For example, when loading www.google.com I the first URL is www.google.com and the second is www.google.co.uk. How is this situation should be handled? dispatchWillSendRequest will be called repeatedly with different URLs when a server does redirection. This is normal. How it should be handled depends on what API you've devised. Is there any separate notification about redirection, or this method is enough? 4. There are several notifications about resource loading is finished: dispatchDidFinishLoading() dispatchDidFinishLoad() dispatchDidFinishDocumentLoad() didFinishLoad() - is this a notification? finishedLoading() - is this a notification? Some of them provide DocumentLoader instances, others have no parameters passed. What is the difference between these methods? Are some of them outdated and shouldn't be used at all? - dispatchDidFinishLoading(DocumentLoader*, unsigned long identifier) This is called when done loading an individual resource, such as an image, script, or the main resource for a page. One more question: is there any method about starting loading of an external resource? Is it dispatchWillSendRequest? dispatchDidReceiveResponse? - dispatchDidFinishDocumentLoad() This is called when done loading the document for a frame, usually HTML, but not all the resources such as images. - dispatchDidFinishLoad() This is called when done loading an entire frame and its resources. Like the HTML load event. OK, thanks, this is very useful information. Artem -- Darin ___ webkit-dev mailing list webkit-dev@lists.webkit.org http://lists.webkit.org/mailman/listinfo/webkit-dev ___ webkit-dev mailing list webkit-dev@lists.webkit.org http://lists.webkit.org/mailman/listinfo/webkit-dev
Re: [webkit-dev] FrameLoaderClient notifications
On Mar 13, 2008, at 4:11 AM, Artem Ananiev wrote: I work on dispatching web load/progress events for Java port and have some questions about notifications in FrameLoaderClient class. 1. What is the right method to implement to get a 'page load started' and 'page load finished' events? I tried the following methods: postProgressStartedNotification() postProgressFinishedNotification() and the problem is they don't accept any params, so I can't get an URL being loaded. If I obtain the URL from frame->loader- >documentLoader, it works for 'progress finished' notification, but returns an old URL for 'progress started'. I have no idea what you mean by "page load started" and "finished". If you look at the Mac port you'll see many different types of calls for these purposes. The ones you mention above are best for loading progress, as in a progress bar. 2. What is the right method to implement to get a 'main document load started'? dispatchDidStartProvisionalLoad 3. As I understand, the right way to handle resources (for example, images) loading is to track methods assignIdentifierToInitialRequest() dispatchWillSendRequest() dispatchDidFinishLoading() The latter two methods provide request identifiers which are assigned in the former one. However, sometimes I see two 'dispatchWillSendRequest' calls with the same ids and different URLs. For example, when loading www.google.com I the first URL is www.google.com and the second is www.google.co.uk. How is this situation should be handled? dispatchWillSendRequest will be called repeatedly with different URLs when a server does redirection. This is normal. How it should be handled depends on what API you've devised. 4. There are several notifications about resource loading is finished: dispatchDidFinishLoading() dispatchDidFinishLoad() dispatchDidFinishDocumentLoad() didFinishLoad() - is this a notification? finishedLoading() - is this a notification? Some of them provide DocumentLoader instances, others have no parameters passed. What is the difference between these methods? Are some of them outdated and shouldn't be used at all? - dispatchDidFinishLoading(DocumentLoader*, unsigned long identifier) This is called when done loading an individual resource, such as an image, script, or the main resource for a page. - dispatchDidFinishDocumentLoad() This is called when done loading the document for a frame, usually HTML, but not all the resources such as images. - dispatchDidFinishLoad() This is called when done loading an entire frame and its resources. Like the HTML load event. -- Darin ___ webkit-dev mailing list webkit-dev@lists.webkit.org http://lists.webkit.org/mailman/listinfo/webkit-dev
Re: [webkit-dev] FrameLoaderClient notifications
Can you get the provisionalDocumentLoader from the FrameLoader and use that url? Patrick On Mar 13, 2008, at 9:19 AM, Artem Ananiev wrote: Hi, Patrick, in Java port we do the same: store Frame* in FrameLoaderClient. However, this frame's loader URL can't be used, for example, in postProgressStartedNotification as it contains the current URL, not the URL which is about to be loaded... Thanks, Artem Patrick Hanna wrote: Artem, For our port, we construct the FrameLoaderClient with a pointer to the Frame object. So in all the progress notification callbacks we can say m_frame->loader()->url() or whatever to get the current url of the frame. Patrick On Mar 13, 2008, at 7:11 AM, Artem Ananiev wrote: Hi, I work on dispatching web load/progress events for Java port and have some questions about notifications in FrameLoaderClient class. 1. What is the right method to implement to get a 'page load started' and 'page load finished' events? I tried the following methods: postProgressStartedNotification() postProgressFinishedNotification() and the problem is they don't accept any params, so I can't get an URL being loaded. If I obtain the URL from frame->loader- >documentLoader, it works for 'progress finished' notification, but returns an old URL for 'progress started'. 2. What is the right method to implement to get a 'main document load started'? I see the method dispatchDidLoadMainResource() but there is no similar method about starting... 3. As I understand, the right way to handle resources (for example, images) loading is to track methods assignIdentifierToInitialRequest() dispatchWillSendRequest() dispatchDidFinishLoading() The latter two methods provide request identifiers which are assigned in the former one. However, sometimes I see two 'dispatchWillSendRequest' calls with the same ids and different URLs. For example, when loading www.google.com I the first URL is www.google.com and the second is www.google.co.uk. How is this situation should be handled? 4. There are several notifications about resource loading is finished: dispatchDidFinishLoading() dispatchDidFinishLoad() dispatchDidFinishDocumentLoad() didFinishLoad() - is this a notification? finishedLoading() - is this a notification? Some of them provide DocumentLoader instances, others have no parameters passed. What is the difference between these methods? Are some of them outdated and shouldn't be used at all? Thanks, Artem ___ webkit-dev mailing list webkit-dev@lists.webkit.org http://lists.webkit.org/mailman/listinfo/webkit-dev ___ webkit-dev mailing list webkit-dev@lists.webkit.org http://lists.webkit.org/mailman/listinfo/webkit-dev
Re: [webkit-dev] FrameLoaderClient notifications
Hi, Patrick, in Java port we do the same: store Frame* in FrameLoaderClient. However, this frame's loader URL can't be used, for example, in postProgressStartedNotification as it contains the current URL, not the URL which is about to be loaded... Thanks, Artem Patrick Hanna wrote: Artem, For our port, we construct the FrameLoaderClient with a pointer to the Frame object. So in all the progress notification callbacks we can say m_frame->loader()->url() or whatever to get the current url of the frame. Patrick On Mar 13, 2008, at 7:11 AM, Artem Ananiev wrote: Hi, I work on dispatching web load/progress events for Java port and have some questions about notifications in FrameLoaderClient class. 1. What is the right method to implement to get a 'page load started' and 'page load finished' events? I tried the following methods: postProgressStartedNotification() postProgressFinishedNotification() and the problem is they don't accept any params, so I can't get an URL being loaded. If I obtain the URL from frame->loader->documentLoader, it works for 'progress finished' notification, but returns an old URL for 'progress started'. 2. What is the right method to implement to get a 'main document load started'? I see the method dispatchDidLoadMainResource() but there is no similar method about starting... 3. As I understand, the right way to handle resources (for example, images) loading is to track methods assignIdentifierToInitialRequest() dispatchWillSendRequest() dispatchDidFinishLoading() The latter two methods provide request identifiers which are assigned in the former one. However, sometimes I see two 'dispatchWillSendRequest' calls with the same ids and different URLs. For example, when loading www.google.com I the first URL is www.google.com and the second is www.google.co.uk. How is this situation should be handled? 4. There are several notifications about resource loading is finished: dispatchDidFinishLoading() dispatchDidFinishLoad() dispatchDidFinishDocumentLoad() didFinishLoad() - is this a notification? finishedLoading() - is this a notification? Some of them provide DocumentLoader instances, others have no parameters passed. What is the difference between these methods? Are some of them outdated and shouldn't be used at all? Thanks, Artem ___ webkit-dev mailing list webkit-dev@lists.webkit.org http://lists.webkit.org/mailman/listinfo/webkit-dev ___ webkit-dev mailing list webkit-dev@lists.webkit.org http://lists.webkit.org/mailman/listinfo/webkit-dev
Re: [webkit-dev] FrameLoaderClient notifications
Artem, For our port, we construct the FrameLoaderClient with a pointer to the Frame object. So in all the progress notification callbacks we can say m_frame->loader()->url() or whatever to get the current url of the frame. Patrick On Mar 13, 2008, at 7:11 AM, Artem Ananiev wrote: Hi, I work on dispatching web load/progress events for Java port and have some questions about notifications in FrameLoaderClient class. 1. What is the right method to implement to get a 'page load started' and 'page load finished' events? I tried the following methods: postProgressStartedNotification() postProgressFinishedNotification() and the problem is they don't accept any params, so I can't get an URL being loaded. If I obtain the URL from frame->loader- >documentLoader, it works for 'progress finished' notification, but returns an old URL for 'progress started'. 2. What is the right method to implement to get a 'main document load started'? I see the method dispatchDidLoadMainResource() but there is no similar method about starting... 3. As I understand, the right way to handle resources (for example, images) loading is to track methods assignIdentifierToInitialRequest() dispatchWillSendRequest() dispatchDidFinishLoading() The latter two methods provide request identifiers which are assigned in the former one. However, sometimes I see two 'dispatchWillSendRequest' calls with the same ids and different URLs. For example, when loading www.google.com I the first URL is www.google.com and the second is www.google.co.uk. How is this situation should be handled? 4. There are several notifications about resource loading is finished: dispatchDidFinishLoading() dispatchDidFinishLoad() dispatchDidFinishDocumentLoad() didFinishLoad() - is this a notification? finishedLoading() - is this a notification? Some of them provide DocumentLoader instances, others have no parameters passed. What is the difference between these methods? Are some of them outdated and shouldn't be used at all? Thanks, Artem ___ webkit-dev mailing list webkit-dev@lists.webkit.org http://lists.webkit.org/mailman/listinfo/webkit-dev ___ webkit-dev mailing list webkit-dev@lists.webkit.org http://lists.webkit.org/mailman/listinfo/webkit-dev
[webkit-dev] FrameLoaderClient notifications
Hi, I work on dispatching web load/progress events for Java port and have some questions about notifications in FrameLoaderClient class. 1. What is the right method to implement to get a 'page load started' and 'page load finished' events? I tried the following methods: postProgressStartedNotification() postProgressFinishedNotification() and the problem is they don't accept any params, so I can't get an URL being loaded. If I obtain the URL from frame->loader->documentLoader, it works for 'progress finished' notification, but returns an old URL for 'progress started'. 2. What is the right method to implement to get a 'main document load started'? I see the method dispatchDidLoadMainResource() but there is no similar method about starting... 3. As I understand, the right way to handle resources (for example, images) loading is to track methods assignIdentifierToInitialRequest() dispatchWillSendRequest() dispatchDidFinishLoading() The latter two methods provide request identifiers which are assigned in the former one. However, sometimes I see two 'dispatchWillSendRequest' calls with the same ids and different URLs. For example, when loading www.google.com I the first URL is www.google.com and the second is www.google.co.uk. How is this situation should be handled? 4. There are several notifications about resource loading is finished: dispatchDidFinishLoading() dispatchDidFinishLoad() dispatchDidFinishDocumentLoad() didFinishLoad() - is this a notification? finishedLoading() - is this a notification? Some of them provide DocumentLoader instances, others have no parameters passed. What is the difference between these methods? Are some of them outdated and shouldn't be used at all? Thanks, Artem ___ webkit-dev mailing list webkit-dev@lists.webkit.org http://lists.webkit.org/mailman/listinfo/webkit-dev
