Re: [whatwg] database full error (was: Re: executeSql API is synchronous)

2007-10-12 Thread Scott Hess
On 10/12/07, Anne van Kesteren [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 On Fri, 12 Oct 2007 20:46:52 +0200, Ian Hickson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
  Certainly that would be reasonable. I have added it. People should let me
  know if they want me to remove or add error codes, by the way.

 I think there should be an error code for the database being full. For
 some platforms there's not much storage space available and knowing
 whether or not there's some space left is useful. So you can decide to
 only store the critical data for instance.

My counter-argument to this is that by the time you get the database
is full error, you're probably already sunk.  Most likely there won't
be anywhere to store the critical data, either.  Assuming your
database has transactional semantics, you may not be able to delete
any data, because it will need more space while implementing the
delete.  You MAY be able to delete an entire database, except that
there's currently no API to do that, and on some platforms even that
may be challenging (on some systems, anyone with an open connection to
the database will likely prevent deletion.  On others, anyone with an
open connection will likely prevent reclaiming of the deleted space).

I think what you're really asking for, above, is a means of saying
How much data can I store?, so that you can make decisions about
what to store.  In the limit, that's hard for the browser to
guarantee, of course.

-scott


[whatwg] database full error (was: Re: executeSql API is synchronous)

2007-10-12 Thread Anne van Kesteren

On Fri, 12 Oct 2007 20:46:52 +0200, Ian Hickson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

Certainly that would be reasonable. I have added it. People should let me
know if they want me to remove or add error codes, by the way.


I think there should be an error code for the database being full. For  
some platforms there's not much storage space available and knowing  
whether or not there's some space left is useful. So you can decide to  
only store the critical data for instance.



--
Anne van Kesteren
http://annevankesteren.nl/
http://www.opera.com/