Re: [Wien] Problems with hf and so

2019-01-08 Thread tran

Yes, one more bug. In calc_cnk.F, at line 156 replace

weigh_redk(1:nboccmax,ikfr) = 
weigh_redk_ibz(1:nboccmax,ikir)/dble(nkstarredkall(ikir))
by
weigh_redk(1:maxval(nbocc_redk_ibz),ikfr) = 
weigh_redk_ibz(1:maxval(nbocc_redk_ibz),ikir)/dble(nkstarredkall(ikir))

and at line 343

  weigh_redk(1:nboccmax,ikfr) = 
weigh_redk_ibz(1:nboccmax,ikir)/dble(nkstarredkall(ikir))
by
  weigh_redk(1:maxval(nbocc_redk_ibz),ikfr) = 
weigh_redk_ibz(1:maxval(nbocc_redk_ibz),ikir)/dble(nkstarredkall(ikir))

and recompile.

Concerning the previous bug with -newklist, you HAVE to fix it
as I mentioned, otherwise it may not work if -redklist is used
(maybe it was also a problem for the present case).


On Tuesday 2019-01-08 23:01, Mikhail Nestoklon wrote:


Date: Tue, 8 Jan 2019 23:01:03
From: Mikhail Nestoklon 
Reply-To: A Mailing list for WIEN2k users 
To: A Mailing list for WIEN2k users 
Subject: Re: [Wien] Problems with hf and so

Thank you for your reply.
The solution to the "-newklist" bug works (just to comment the line is also Ok).

To better understand the "-redklist" bug, I recompiled the code with some debug 
flags on. The same GaAs example,
$ init_lapw -b -vxc 19
$ run_lapw
$ save_lapw -d PBE_min
$ init_hf_lapw    (choose 32 nband in GaAs.hf, 36 nband in GaAs.in1c, 
redklist with number of k for lapw1=6x6x6 number of k for hf =1x1x1 )
$ run_lapw -hf -redklist
$ save_lapw -d HSE_min
$ initso_lapw (everything default)
$ run_lapw -hf -so -redklist

gives
"
 LAPW0 END
 LAPW0 END
 LAPW1 END
 LAPW2 END
 CORE  END
forrtl: severe (408): fort: (2): Subscript #1 of the array WEIGH_REDK_IBZ has 
value 15 which is greater than the upper bound of 14

Image  PC    Routine    Line    Source  
   
hfc    00C5C0A0  Unknown   Unknown  Unknown
hfc    00562B85  calc_cnk_ 156  
calc_cnk_tmp_.F
hfc    00BA72F7  read_cnk_ 258  
read_cnk_tmp_.F
hfc    00B595C6  MAIN__ 26  hf.f
"


Sincerely yours,
Mikhail Nestoklon



 Понедельник, 7 января 2019, 15:54 +03:00 от t...@theochem.tuwien.ac.at:

 Hi,

 Gavin is right, there is a bug. To fix the problem, you need
 at line 126 in read_weight.f to replace
  nk = nkibzall
 by
  if (newklist .eqv. .false.) then
    nk = nkibzall
  elseif (newklist .eqv. .true.) then
    nk = nkibzoldk
  endif

 Concerning the other problem with -redklist, try it again. If it still
 occurs, then give the details of your procedure.

 One unrelated thing:
 Use "save_lapw" when a calculation is finished to avoid to mix
 several different calculations in the same scf file.

 Thanks for having reported the problem.

 F. Tran

 On Sunday 2019-01-06 22:05, Mikhail Nestoklon wrote:

 >Date: Sun, 6 Jan 2019 22:05:12
 >From: Mikhail Nestoklon 
 >Reply-To: A Mailing list for WIEN2k users 

 >To: A Mailing list for WIEN2k users 
 >Subject: [Wien] Problems with hf and so
 >
 >
 >Dear wien2k community,
 >In the new version of WIEN2k the hybrid functionals are compatible with 
spin-orbit.
 >However, using such combination I can not continue calculations after I 
change the k-mesh.
 >
 >As a minimal non-working example, to compute the GaAs (the .struct is 
fine, the band structure with e.g. mBJ is perfect, for
 >completeness it is in attachment) I am trying to
 >$ init_lapw -b -vxc 19 -rkmax 8
 >$ run_lapw
 >$ init_hf_lapw    (choose 32 nband in GaAs.hf, 36 nband in 
GaAs.in1c number of k =30 )
 >$ run_lapw -hf
 >$ initso_lapw (everything default)
 >$ run_lapw -hf -so
 >This works, but if I then follow UG 4.5.8 and
 >$ mv GaAs.klist_fbz GaAs.klist_fbz_old
 >$ mv GaAs.klist_ibz GaAs.klist_ibz_old
 >$ mv GaAs.outputkgenhf GaAs.outputkgenhf_old
 >$ run_kgenhf_lapw  (choose 300)
 >$ run_lapw -hf -so -newklist
 >The result is
 > LAPW0 END
 > LAPW0 END
 > LAPW1 END
 > LAPW2 END
 > CORE  END
 >error in read_weight: wrong case.weighthfnoso
 >
 >Am I doing something wrong? The error message is strange and I can not 
understand how it is related with what I am doing.
 >
 >By the way, doing the same with reduced mesh, it gets worse: there is 
memory error on a first iteration with spin-orbit,
 >something like (this one for ubuntu 16.04 / ifort 15.0.1+mkl / xeon E5420)
 >*** Error in `.../WIEN2k_18/hfc': munmap_chunk(): invalid pointer: 
0x00d4cc90 ***
 >The exact message may be different for different machines/compilers, but 
I could not find the working combination. .
 >
 >Thank you in advance.
 >
 >Sincerely,
 >Mikhail Nestoklon
 >
 >

Re: [Wien] Problems with hf and so

2019-01-08 Thread Mikhail Nestoklon
Thank you for your reply.
The solution to the "-newklist" bug works (just to comment the line is also Ok).

To better understand the "-redklist" bug, I recompiled the code with some debug 
flags on. The same GaAs example, 
$ init_lapw -b -vxc 19
$ run_lapw
$ save_lapw -d PBE_min
$ init_hf_lapw    (choose 32 nband in GaAs.hf, 36 nband in GaAs.in1c, 
redklist with number of k for lapw1=6x6x6 number of k for hf =1x1x1 )
$ run_lapw -hf -redklist
$ save_lapw -d HSE_min
$ initso_lapw (everything default)
$ run_lapw -hf -so -redklist

gives
"
 LAPW0 END
 LAPW0 END
 LAPW1 END
 LAPW2 END
 CORE  END
forrtl: severe (408): fort: (2): Subscript #1 of the array WEIGH_REDK_IBZ has 
value 15 which is greater than the upper bound of 14

Image  PC    Routine    Line    Source  
   
hfc    00C5C0A0  Unknown   Unknown  Unknown
hfc    00562B85  calc_cnk_ 156  
calc_cnk_tmp_.F
hfc    00BA72F7  read_cnk_ 258  
read_cnk_tmp_.F
hfc    00B595C6  MAIN__ 26  hf.f
"


Sincerely yours,
Mikhail Nestoklon



>Понедельник,  7 января 2019, 15:54 +03:00 от t...@theochem.tuwien.ac.at:
>
>Hi,
>
>Gavin is right, there is a bug. To fix the problem, you need
>at line 126 in read_weight.f to replace
> nk = nkibzall
>by
> if (newklist .eqv. .false.) then
>   nk = nkibzall
> elseif (newklist .eqv. .true.) then
>   nk = nkibzoldk
> endif
>
>Concerning the other problem with -redklist, try it again. If it still
>occurs, then give the details of your procedure.
>
>One unrelated thing:
>Use "save_lapw" when a calculation is finished to avoid to mix
>several different calculations in the same scf file.
>
>Thanks for having reported the problem.
>
>F. Tran
>
>On Sunday 2019-01-06 22:05, Mikhail Nestoklon wrote:
>
>>Date: Sun, 6 Jan 2019 22:05:12
>>From: Mikhail Nestoklon < nestok...@mail.ru >
>>Reply-To: A Mailing list for WIEN2k users < wien@zeus.theochem.tuwien.ac.at >
>>To: A Mailing list for WIEN2k users < wien@zeus.theochem.tuwien.ac.at >
>>Subject: [Wien] Problems with hf and so
>>
>>
>>Dear wien2k community,
>>In the new version of WIEN2k the hybrid functionals are compatible with 
>>spin-orbit.
>>However, using such combination I can not continue calculations after I 
>>change the k-mesh.
>>
>>As a minimal non-working example, to compute the GaAs (the .struct is fine, 
>>the band structure with e.g. mBJ is perfect, for
>>completeness it is in attachment) I am trying to
>>$ init_lapw -b -vxc 19 -rkmax 8
>>$ run_lapw
>>$ init_hf_lapw    (choose 32 nband in GaAs.hf, 36 nband in GaAs.in1c 
>>number of k =30 )
>>$ run_lapw -hf
>>$ initso_lapw (everything default)
>>$ run_lapw -hf -so
>>This works, but if I then follow UG 4.5.8 and
>>$ mv GaAs.klist_fbz GaAs.klist_fbz_old
>>$ mv GaAs.klist_ibz GaAs.klist_ibz_old
>>$ mv GaAs.outputkgenhf GaAs.outputkgenhf_old
>>$ run_kgenhf_lapw  (choose 300)
>>$ run_lapw -hf -so -newklist
>>The result is
>> LAPW0 END
>> LAPW0 END
>> LAPW1 END
>> LAPW2 END
>> CORE  END
>>error in read_weight: wrong case.weighthfnoso
>>
>>Am I doing something wrong? The error message is strange and I can not 
>>understand how it is related with what I am doing.
>>
>>By the way, doing the same with reduced mesh, it gets worse: there is memory 
>>error on a first iteration with spin-orbit,
>>something like (this one for ubuntu 16.04 / ifort 15.0.1+mkl / xeon E5420)
>>*** Error in `.../WIEN2k_18/hfc': munmap_chunk(): invalid pointer: 
>>0x00d4cc90 ***
>>The exact message may be different for different machines/compilers, but I 
>>could not find the working combination. .
>>
>>Thank you in advance.
>>
>>Sincerely,
>>Mikhail Nestoklon
>>
>>
>___
>Wien mailing list
>Wien@zeus.theochem.tuwien.ac.at
>http://zeus.theochem.tuwien.ac.at/mailman/listinfo/wien
>SEARCH the MAILING-LIST at:  
>http://www.mail-archive.com/wien@zeus.theochem.tuwien.ac.at/index.html


-- 
Mikhail Nestoklon
___
Wien mailing list
Wien@zeus.theochem.tuwien.ac.at
http://zeus.theochem.tuwien.ac.at/mailman/listinfo/wien
SEARCH the MAILING-LIST at:  
http://www.mail-archive.com/wien@zeus.theochem.tuwien.ac.at/index.html