[Yahoo-eng-team] [Bug 1552056] Re: "router-interface-delete port=xxx" deletes the whole port instead of just removing the interface
** Changed in: openstack-api-site
Status: Fix Committed => Fix Released
--
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Yahoo!
Engineering Team, which is subscribed to neutron.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1552056
Title:
"router-interface-delete port=xxx" deletes the whole port instead of
just removing the interface
Status in neutron:
Won't Fix
Status in openstack-api-site:
Fix Released
Bug description:
The help message of "neutron router-interface-delete" says
"Remove an internal network interface from a router."
=
Expected behavior
=
neutron router-interface-add subnet=subnetx
--> creates a port, and adds this port as interface to the router
neutron router-interface-delete subnet=subnetx
--> removes that interface from the router and deletes the corresponding port
neutron router-interface-add port=portx
--> adds an already existing port as interface to the router
neutron router-interface-delete port=portx
--> removes that interface from the router. Does NOT delete that
corresponding port
=
Actual result
=
"neutron router-interface-delete subnet=subnetx" works as expected.
BUT
"neutron router-interface-delete port=portx" does not only remove the
interface from the router, it also deletes the whole port!
=
Proposed solution
=
Either
#1 Extend the API description to refelct this behavior
Or
#2 Change the behavior in the special case to NOT delete the port, but only
remove the interface from the router
==
Steps to reproduce
==
# neutron router-interface-delete -h
usage: neutron router-interface-delete [-h] [--request-format {json}]
ROUTER INTERFACE
Remove an internal network interface from a router.
positional arguments:
ROUTERID or name of the router.
INTERFACE The format is "SUBNET|subnet=SUBNET|port=PORT". Either
a subnet or port must be specified. Both ID and name
are accepted as SUBNET or PORT. Note that "subnet="
can be omitted when specifying a subnet.
[root@tecs218 ~(keystone_admin)]# neutron router-create test
Created a new router:
+---+--+
| Field | Value|
+---+--+
| admin_state_up| True |
| external_gateway_info | |
| id| 4039bd93-b183-4250-af0f-e9739ac1a19a |
| name | test |
| status| ACTIVE |
| tenant_id | 0d76aad1dda94f83a2a0a55c04547434 |
+---+--+
[root@tecs218 ~(keystone_admin)]# neutron router-interface-add test
port=90e0abe1-852b-4cfe-afd9-2bd31a42c279
Added interface 90e0abe1-852b-4cfe-afd9-2bd31a42c279 to router test.
[root@tecs218 ~(keystone_admin)]# neutron router-interface-add test
port=90e0abe1-852b-4cfe-afd9-2bd31a42c27^C
[root@tecs218 ~(keystone_admin)]# neutron port-show
90e0abe1-852b-4cfe-afd9-2bd31a42c279
+-+---+
| Field | Value
|
+-+---+
| admin_state_up | True
|
| bandwidth | 0
|
| binding:host_id |
|
| binding:profile | {}
|
| binding:vif_details | {}
|
| binding:vif_type| unbound
|
| binding:vnic_type | normal
|
| bond| 0
|
| cbs | 0
|
| device_id | 4039bd93-b183-4250-af0f-e9739ac1a19a
|
| device_owner| network:router_interface
[Yahoo-eng-team] [Bug 1552056] Re: "router-interface-delete port=xxx" deletes the whole port instead of just removing the interface
** Changed in: neutron
Status: In Progress => Won't Fix
--
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Yahoo!
Engineering Team, which is subscribed to neutron.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1552056
Title:
"router-interface-delete port=xxx" deletes the whole port instead of
just removing the interface
Status in neutron:
Won't Fix
Status in openstack-api-site:
In Progress
Bug description:
The help message of "neutron router-interface-delete" says
"Remove an internal network interface from a router."
=
Expected behavior
=
neutron router-interface-add subnet=subnetx
--> creates a port, and adds this port as interface to the router
neutron router-interface-delete subnet=subnetx
--> removes that interface from the router and deletes the corresponding port
neutron router-interface-add port=portx
--> adds an already existing port as interface to the router
neutron router-interface-delete port=portx
--> removes that interface from the router. Does NOT delete that
corresponding port
=
Actual result
=
"neutron router-interface-delete subnet=subnetx" works as expected.
BUT
"neutron router-interface-delete port=portx" does not only remove the
interface from the router, it also deletes the whole port!
=
Proposed solution
=
Either
#1 Extend the API description to refelct this behavior
Or
#2 Change the behavior in the special case to NOT delete the port, but only
remove the interface from the router
==
Steps to reproduce
==
# neutron router-interface-delete -h
usage: neutron router-interface-delete [-h] [--request-format {json}]
ROUTER INTERFACE
Remove an internal network interface from a router.
positional arguments:
ROUTERID or name of the router.
INTERFACE The format is "SUBNET|subnet=SUBNET|port=PORT". Either
a subnet or port must be specified. Both ID and name
are accepted as SUBNET or PORT. Note that "subnet="
can be omitted when specifying a subnet.
[root@tecs218 ~(keystone_admin)]# neutron router-create test
Created a new router:
+---+--+
| Field | Value|
+---+--+
| admin_state_up| True |
| external_gateway_info | |
| id| 4039bd93-b183-4250-af0f-e9739ac1a19a |
| name | test |
| status| ACTIVE |
| tenant_id | 0d76aad1dda94f83a2a0a55c04547434 |
+---+--+
[root@tecs218 ~(keystone_admin)]# neutron router-interface-add test
port=90e0abe1-852b-4cfe-afd9-2bd31a42c279
Added interface 90e0abe1-852b-4cfe-afd9-2bd31a42c279 to router test.
[root@tecs218 ~(keystone_admin)]# neutron router-interface-add test
port=90e0abe1-852b-4cfe-afd9-2bd31a42c27^C
[root@tecs218 ~(keystone_admin)]# neutron port-show
90e0abe1-852b-4cfe-afd9-2bd31a42c279
+-+---+
| Field | Value
|
+-+---+
| admin_state_up | True
|
| bandwidth | 0
|
| binding:host_id |
|
| binding:profile | {}
|
| binding:vif_details | {}
|
| binding:vif_type| unbound
|
| binding:vnic_type | normal
|
| bond| 0
|
| cbs | 0
|
| device_id | 4039bd93-b183-4250-af0f-e9739ac1a19a
|
| device_owner| network:router_interface
|
|
[Yahoo-eng-team] [Bug 1552056] Re: "router-interface-delete port=xxx" deletes the whole port instead of just removing the interface
** Also affects: openstack-api-site
Importance: Undecided
Status: New
** Changed in: openstack-api-site
Status: New => Confirmed
--
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Yahoo!
Engineering Team, which is subscribed to neutron.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1552056
Title:
"router-interface-delete port=xxx" deletes the whole port instead of
just removing the interface
Status in neutron:
In Progress
Status in openstack-api-site:
Confirmed
Bug description:
The help message of "neutron router-interface-delete" says
"Remove an internal network interface from a router."
=
Expected behavior
=
neutron router-interface-add subnet=subnetx
--> creates a port, and adds this port as interface to the router
neutron router-interface-delete subnet=subnetx
--> removes that interface from the router and deletes the corresponding port
neutron router-interface-add port=portx
--> adds an already existing port as interface to the router
neutron router-interface-delete port=portx
--> removes that interface from the router. Does NOT delete that
corresponding port
=
Actual result
=
"neutron router-interface-delete subnet=subnetx" works as expected.
BUT
"neutron router-interface-delete port=portx" does not only remove the
interface from the router, it also deletes the whole port!
=
Proposed solution
=
Either
#1 Extend the API description to refelct this behavior
Or
#2 Change the behavior in the special case to NOT delete the port, but only
remove the interface from the router
==
Steps to reproduce
==
# neutron router-interface-delete -h
usage: neutron router-interface-delete [-h] [--request-format {json}]
ROUTER INTERFACE
Remove an internal network interface from a router.
positional arguments:
ROUTERID or name of the router.
INTERFACE The format is "SUBNET|subnet=SUBNET|port=PORT". Either
a subnet or port must be specified. Both ID and name
are accepted as SUBNET or PORT. Note that "subnet="
can be omitted when specifying a subnet.
[root@tecs218 ~(keystone_admin)]# neutron router-create test
Created a new router:
+---+--+
| Field | Value|
+---+--+
| admin_state_up| True |
| external_gateway_info | |
| id| 4039bd93-b183-4250-af0f-e9739ac1a19a |
| name | test |
| status| ACTIVE |
| tenant_id | 0d76aad1dda94f83a2a0a55c04547434 |
+---+--+
[root@tecs218 ~(keystone_admin)]# neutron router-interface-add test
port=90e0abe1-852b-4cfe-afd9-2bd31a42c279
Added interface 90e0abe1-852b-4cfe-afd9-2bd31a42c279 to router test.
[root@tecs218 ~(keystone_admin)]# neutron router-interface-add test
port=90e0abe1-852b-4cfe-afd9-2bd31a42c27^C
[root@tecs218 ~(keystone_admin)]# neutron port-show
90e0abe1-852b-4cfe-afd9-2bd31a42c279
+-+---+
| Field | Value
|
+-+---+
| admin_state_up | True
|
| bandwidth | 0
|
| binding:host_id |
|
| binding:profile | {}
|
| binding:vif_details | {}
|
| binding:vif_type| unbound
|
| binding:vnic_type | normal
|
| bond| 0
|
| cbs | 0
|
| device_id | 4039bd93-b183-4250-af0f-e9739ac1a19a
|
| device_owner|
