Re: [abcusers] Scan Tester's No 2

2000-08-25 Thread Jack Campin
>> Of course nobody says "This is in F sharp, C sharp" rather than >> saying it's in D. > Actually, I have heard people say things like "Let's play it in two > sharps" occasionally, but I'd agree that this isn't common phrasing > in any crowd that I hang out with. I play a lot with diatonic mo

Re: [abcusers] Scan's No 2/Double Hornpipes

2000-08-25 Thread Laura Conrad
> "John" == John Chambers <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: John> I just recently played Come Under My Plaidie (good title, that), I just ran into a reference to this tune. It's from the autobiography of Lucy Maude Montgomery, best known as the author of _Anne of Green Gables_. L

[abcusers] Scan's No2/Double Hornpipes/Jack on the Green......

2000-08-25 Thread Bryancreer
Given the variety of answers on the key or keys for Scan Tester's No 2, I rest my case. Richard Robinson says - > I've found myself tending to play, > particularly, Go to Berwick with a 1&3 beat. I think we probably mean the same thing here, I was just being a bit sloppy in the way I describe

Re: [abcusers] 3/2 hornpipe was: Modal confusion

2000-08-25 Thread Chris Walshaw
On Thu, Aug 24, 2000 at 02:46:04PM -0400, Bruce Olson wrote: > RE: In a history of the English stage I saw that a stage piece "Jack on > the Green" was attributed to a Mr. Birkhead. No music was given, or copy > of the tune referenced, but many copies of a tune of this title are > known (Jack on/i