Re: [ActiveDir] RE: [ActiveDir] Major screwup on AD for my company - Can't install AD on remote server now

2006-10-07 Thread Al Mulnick
We agree on security as a journey.  We seem to disagree about putting an application on a DC.  Exchange especially.  Will it work? Yes. But the tradeoffs in that situation can be distasteful from an operational and security point of view if security, flexibility, scalability, and availability are o

Re: [ActiveDir] RE: [ActiveDir] Major screwup on AD for my company - Can't install AD on remote server now

2006-10-06 Thread Matt Hargraves
Security a goal?  It's more of a journey where the destination is "we didn't get hacked this week (month/year)"BTW, I wasn't saying that it's the worst idea ever to put e-mail on a DC (if it's a GC it will save you the journey for authentication), but in an organization where you have 2+ sites (and

Re: [ActiveDir] RE: [ActiveDir] Major screwup on AD for my company - Can't install AD on remote server now

2006-10-06 Thread Al Mulnick
Hmm... I'm becoming more and more convinced that security on any platform is more of a goal than a destination anyway :)   Putting other apps on a server that is designed to be a security server is not best practice on any platform SBS or not. SBS exists because it makes more economic sense than mo

Re: [ActiveDir] RE: [ActiveDir] Major screwup on AD for my company - Can't install AD on remote server now

2006-10-06 Thread Susan Bradley, CPA aka Ebitz - SBS Rocks [MVP]
Granted external FTP isn't one that SBSers recommend either and we're freaking out going WHAT ARE YOU THINKING? as well. As we say down here we don't get hacked... we get stupid. Tim Vander Kooi wrote: It's not speed or resources that scare most of us when it comes to sharing DC space wit

[ActiveDir] RE: [ActiveDir] Major screwup on AD for my company - Can't install AD on remote server now

2006-10-06 Thread Tim Vander Kooi
It's not speed or resources that scare most of us when it comes to sharing DC space with other apps, it's security. With SBS Microsoft has (at least in theory) covered most of those security bases for the admin. The last time I allowed another admin to install FTP on a server he inadvertently put n